Here at Mikes Pasta and Sandwich Shoppe in Nutley, NJ, we strive to give the best possible products to our customers. Classic Italian deli fare executed well. We source the best products available an…
Full Menu
closed
Featured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
--
delivery time
Featured Items
Mike's Fried Eggplant
$18.00
The Nutley
$20.00
Caesar & Co.
$19.00
O.G.
$18.00
Love A Parm
$20.00
Italian Standard
$19.00
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Mike's Specials
Our Weekly Specials, here until they're not.
The Cutlets
This is our Chicken Cutlet sandwich lineup. All cutlets are fried in beef tallow. You're gonna love them. All of our sandwiches made with bread from the renowned Balthazar Bakery.
The Hitters
Just a collection of a few awesome sandwiches. All of our sandwiches made with bread from the renowned Balthazar Bakery.
Sides
Housemade Pasta
We offer bronze dye extruded Semolina Pasta and frozen handrolled pasta for you to cook and enjoy at home.
Sandwich Boxes
Your box comes with 4 sandwiches cut into 4. All sandwiches served on Balthazar Bread and all sauces / dressings are on the side. Perfect for Game Day, to order for parties, or just a nice gift to yourself.
Sauces
Sauces made in house, sold fresh by the quart or pint
Drinks
All your favorite Italian sodas + beverages
Official Merch
Whatever we wanna sell. Support Your Local Pasta Dealer.
