Order the best Italian near Middle Island, NY

Best Italian Restaurants Nearby in Middle Island

Alfredo's Pizzeria

Alfredo's Pizzeria

4.6
(3k+)
• Italian • Pizza
$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 30 min
"This was some of the best stuffed rigatoni I've had in years. The garlic bread was delicious & excellent dipped in the sauce. The chicken pieces were extremely tender. The portion was so huge I had it for two dinners & lunch!You will not be disappointed!"
"Large Grilled Chx Salad is delicious!! Plenty of chicken and fresh crispy vegetables. Alfredo's is one of my favorites. Definitely would recommend"
- Cheese Pizza (T)
(6) classic wings tossed in your choice of sauce, served with blue cheese dipping sauce, celery and carrot sticks.
$24.6
6 Garlic Knots
Seasoned rice with ground beef, peas, sauce and cheese in the middle.
$4.71
Slice
Our homemade rice ball filled with ground beef, peas, sauce and cheese, topped with pomodoro sauce and melted whole milk mozzarella.
$4.43
Specialty Slice
Chicken, pepperoni, vodka sauce, crushed red pepper flakes, fresh mozzarella
$6.85
Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.7
(50+)
• Italian • Pizzeria
$0 delivery fee • 0.8 mi • 32 min
$5 off on $40+
"These are really about the best wings around!! Perfectly cooked and seasoned to my liking! Everything is hands down delicious! Must must try!!!"
"Chicken Piccata was very good.Don't understand why they put red sauce on the Penne. The italian bread was soft and cheap and awful. Haven't tried the tiny salad yet."
Neapolitan Pizza
Crispy batter dipped mozzarella served with our traditional tomato sauce.
$22.7
Mozzarella Sticks
With chicken, mozzarella, and marinara sauce. Served with a side of sauce.
$10.99
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero
Sausage, onions, peppers, tomato sauce, and mozzarella. Served with a side of sauce.
$13.39
Chicken Roll
*
$10.99
La Bistro

La Bistro

4.7
(800+)
• Italian • Pizza
$0 delivery fee • 4.0 mi • 37 min
"the Capellini Alla Vodka was amazing! added breaded chicken, mozzarella and spinach. delicious!!!"
"Every time I get this dish it is perfect. From presentation to taste to the quality everything is perfect.!! The portion size is great !! all of the pasta fagioli is wonderful and the pasta is always al dente!!"
Regular Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$21.2
Garlic Knots
A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.
$4.09
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Fried chicken breast, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
$11.74
Alla Vodka Pasta
Crispy on the outside, yet light and fluffy on the inside. These mini Italian donut holes will become your new fave.
$18.59
Cafe Spiga Pizza And Restaurant

Cafe Spiga Pizza And Restaurant

4.5
(100+)
• Pizza • Salads
$0 delivery fee • 6.2 mi • 38 min
$7 off on $45+
"Linguini with white clam sauce is outstanding !!"
"The best thing about this meal was the garlic knots. The 4 stuffed mushrooms-not the 6 pictured - had mountain high stuffing that was almost all bread with hardly a speck of seafod. The marinara sauce was highly acidic and unpleasant. The lasagna, meatballs and ravioli were fine but the sauce really detracted from them. I was expecting better from this local restaurant."
Caesar Salad
Crisp Romaine lettuce and croutons tossed in our special Caesar dressing.
$18.93
Garlic Knots
1/2 dozen.
$7.85
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Thin crusted pan pizza with San Marzano style tomato, fresh garlic, fresh basil, and mozzarella.
$16.02
Grandma
Fresh iceberg lettuce, mixed baby greens, roasted pepper, and tomato with fresh mozzarella, tossed in our balsamic vinaigrette dressing,.
$32.47
Pizza Hut

Pizza Hut

4.5
(1k+)
• Pizza • Chicken Wings
$0 delivery fee • 0.2 mi • 21 min
20% off on $20+
"the Oven-Baked Cheesy Alfredo Pasta was absolutely outstanding the best I've ever had! As per usual the Create Your Own Pizza was amazing too! overall worth every penny!"
"There were only 4 pepperonis on the entire pizza. Also, they put virtually no marinara sauce on it. I can't even see it. Maybe since I ordered (and paid for) extra marinara on the side, they somehow thought I didn't want any on the pizzas."
Personal Pan Pizza®
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$7.64
Create Your Own Pizza
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$21.5
Breadsticks
Nobody does breadsticks like the Hut. Crispy-on-the-outside, soft-on-the-inside, and seasoned with garlic and parmesan, they're perfect with pizza or pasta. Comes with a cup of our delicious marinara!
$7.18
Cheese Sticks
A side everyone can agree on! Get these cheese sticks sprinkled with flavorful Italian seasoning and a cup of our delicious marinara.
$8.36
Domino's

Domino's

4.5
(200+)
• Pizza • Pizzeria
$0 delivery fee • 3.6 mi • 29 min
Build Your Own Pizza
A custom pizza made to order. Choose from any of our delicious crust styles, including Handmade Pan.
$16.98
Stuffed Cheesy Bread
Our 8-piece oven-baked breadsticks are generously stuffed and covered with a blend of 100% real mozzarella and cheddar cheeses then seasoned with a touch of garlic.
$9.38
Wisconsin 6-Cheese
Feta, provolone, cheddar, Parmesan-Asiago, cheese made with 100% real mozzarella and sprinkled with oregano.
$19.51
Ultimate Pepperoni
Two layers of pepperoni sandwiched between provolone, Parmesan-Asiago and cheese made with 100% real mozzarella then sprinkled with oregano.
$21.12
Subway

Subway

4.2
(200+)
• Salad • Snacks
$0 delivery fee • 0.6 mi • 19 min
"Everything was great. The meatball parm was particularly tasty and good. We enjoyed it. "
"blt was too sparce and not enough mayo"
6 Pack Cookie Box
Our 6 Pack Cookie Box is the most delicious out-of-the-box thinking. Pick your favorite flavor and enjoy a half-dozen of fresh-baked cookies. One for you, one for him, one for her and even more to keep sharing…or not! Get the New 6 Pack Cookie Box today and get that sweet treat you’re craving.
$4.3
Oven-Roasted Turkey
Oven-roasted Turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo served on our freshly baked Artisan Italian bread.
$12.06
Tuna
100% wild caught Tuna salad, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & onions served on our freshly baked Artisan Italian bread.
$13.03
Grilled Chicken
Tender grilled chicken, Monterey cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo served on our freshly baked Artisan Italian bread.
$14.22
Steve Wading River Deli

Steve Wading River Deli

4.6
(300+)
• Deli • Sandwiches
$0 delivery fee • 6.5 mi • 43 min
"The staff there is very kind, egg sandwich came out great, iced coffee was good. "
"I love the Chicken club, the chicken cutlets and cooked perfectly and delicious. My husbands favorite is the Clipper"
2 eggs with meat and cheese on a roll
2 eggs cooked any style and Your choice of bacon,ham or sausage
$10.09
1/2 pound macaroni salad
A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.
$3.75
2 eggs with meat on a roll
Chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella cheese, bacon,coleslaw, thousand island dressing on a toasted garlic hero
$9.88
Two Egg Platter Served with Home Fries and Toast
Turkey,ham,bologna,salami,pepperoni,everoast chicken,or Buffalo chicken,pastrami or corned beef. Your choice of toppings and dressings
$7.91
Wading River Pizzeria - 6324 Route 25a

Wading River Pizzeria - 6324 Route 25a

4.3
(70+)
• Italian • Pizzeria
$0 delivery fee • 6.5 mi • 42 min
Fried Chicken Cutlet (1)
Mid buffalo gold, honey bbq sweet sour, teriyaki, honey garlic, thai chili,mango habanero, plain garlic parmesan hot spicy garlic or hot
$4.8
Caffe Amici

Caffe Amici

4.5
(1k+)
• Italian • Pizza
$0 delivery fee • 6.1 mi • 34 min
"Pollo Romano was extraordinary! the chicken was incredibly tender and paired so beautifully with the sliced eggplant and the tomato sauce was the best as always. Cafe Amici always delivers high quality Italian food but yesterday's dish was truly one of their best."
"The Margarita Pie was huge and tasty!! My husband loved his Garlic Knots and the Wings were nice and juicy! Definitely coming back"
Neapolitan Pizza
A round pizza with cheese.
$24.43
Garlic Knots
Pink cream and vodka sauce with a touch of meat.
$7.11
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Crisp romaine topped with homemade garlic croutons, aged Parmesan cheese, and homemade dijon Caesar dressing.
$23.18
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Three per order served in traditional sauce.
$16.32
South Paw Brewing Company

South Paw Brewing Company

4.6
(300+)
• Pizza • Salads
$0 delivery fee • 3.3 mi • 34 min
"This place does not disappoint. At first it may appear pricey however the quality and generous portions make it feel absolutely justified!"
"$23 for a pizza that's actually just personal sized is.....a choice for sure. Didn't receive second drink either. Vodka sauce pizza was not only small but bland as well"
Classic Pizza
Mozzarella cheese, Tomato Sauce, Romano Cheese
$19.85
Wings
9 battered fried crispy wings tossed in your choice of sauce.
$19.25
NY Vodka Sauce Pizza
Fresh Mozzarella, Vodka Sauce, Basil, Romano Cheese
$23.82
Boneless Wings (12)
12 breaded chicken breast chunks fried and tossed in your choice of sauce.
$19.2
Pizza Corner

Pizza Corner

4.6
(30+)
• Italian • Calzones
$0 delivery fee • 5.0 mi • 42 min
Cheese Pie (Large 16") (8 Slices)
6 Pieces
$22.82
Cheese Pie (Personal 12")
6 Pieces
$15.03
Garlic Knots
Add Garlic Chicken for an additional charge
$5.47
Mozzarella Sticks
Grilled chicken topped with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and sliced tomato on panini bread.
$8.94
Bellissimo Pizzeria

Bellissimo Pizzeria

4.5
(10+)
• Italian • American
$0 delivery fee • 7.4 mi • 39 min
"Great value! Will order again!"
Napolitano
Large 18" traditional hand- tossed pizza.
$24.54
Calzones
With mozzarella & ricotta toppings.
$10.25
Everything
Meatball, sausage, pepperoni, onions, peppers, mushrooms & extra cheese.
$30
Roadhouse Brick Oven  Pizza

Roadhouse Brick Oven Pizza

4.5
(200+)
• Italian • Pizzeria
$0 delivery fee • 13.3 mi • 44 min
"Our family has been going here for nearly a decade now, they make some of the Best Pizza in new york in our opinion! "
" Neopolitan 19" Round Thin Crust is a standard Long Island, copy and paste pizza where the thin crust is still thick. Did half anchovies and half pepperoni - anchovies were burnt and or bad, and pepperoni side was kinda flavorless.. sauce is bland.. bottom of pie wasnt burnt. Decent spot."
Neopolitan 19" Round Thin Crust
Made with meatballs and sausage
$29.61
6 Garlic Knots
vodka sauce and fresh mozzerella on a square crust
$5.75
Chicken Roll
Breaded chicken cutlets, marinara sauce, topped with mozzerella and ricotta cheeses on a pizza crust.
$17.32
Grandma Thin Crust - Pan Style
sliced tomatoes with mozzerella and pesto sauce
$31.04
Uncle Giuseppe's Pizza

Uncle Giuseppe's Pizza

4.4
(1k+)
• Italian • Pizza
$0 delivery fee • 5.9 mi • 47 min
"Fresh, hot, & delicious! Did not expect for it to taste so good but it definitely is one of my new favorites! :)"
"Sicilian Square is not very good at all. Sauce is bitter. Don't know what these people are talking about that claim it's very good. They have select items that are very good however pizza is definitely not one of them."
Neapolitan Round (8 slices)
20” thin crust pizza with mozzarella & California tomato sauce.
$20.7
12 Garlic Knots
Our Garlic Knots are a delectable appetizer or snack, perfect for garlic lovers. Made with soft, fluffy dough twisted into knots and baked to perfection, then brushed with a garlic-infused buttery blend for irresistible flavor. Enjoy these savory treats on their own or dipped in marinara sauce for an extra burst of taste.
$7.16
6 Garlic Knots
Our 6 Garlic Knots are a delectable appetizer or snack, perfect for garlic lovers. Made with soft, fluffy dough twisted into knots and baked to perfection, then brushed with a garlic-infused buttery blend for irresistible flavor. Enjoy these savory treats on their own or dipped in marinara sauce for an extra burst of taste.
$3.12
Sicilian Square (8 slices)
Thick crust pan pizza topped with mozzarella & California tomato sauce,
$23.84
Alanza: Traditional Italian by Wonder

Alanza: Traditional Italian by Wonder

Italian • Casual Dining
$0 delivery fee • 6.6 mi • 46 min
$5 off on $20+
Chicken Milanese
A favorite uncle's favorite dish: breaded chicken cutlet, pan-fried and topped with arugula, radicchio, fennel, grape tomatoes, basil, pine nuts, Parmesan, and a tangy lemon vinaigrette
$21.05
Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta Pomodoro
Breaded chicken cutlet is layered with rich marinara and mozzarella and Parmigiano Reggiano cheeses. Served with a side portion of al dente tortiglioni topped with marinara, Parmesan, basil, and parsley
$31.79
Sunday Meatballs
This recipe is even better than nonna used to make. 3 delicate, fluffy beef and pork meatballs slow cooked in Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes and topped with grated Parmesan and chopped parsley
$15.35
Garlic Bread
This crusty, chewy, ridiculously delicious garlic bread, made with sesame seed semolina, is baked with plenty of parsley-garlic butter.
$7.55
Mangiamo Market

Mangiamo Market

4.8
(1k+)
• Italian • Deli
$0 delivery fee • 6.6 mi • 39 min
"I created my own sandwich with Prosciutto Di Parma, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, hot peppers with olive oil on a baguette. It is so good and so fresh! This place always completes the order in a timely matter. I also love how you can add a note because at first it made me choose a condiment for the sandwich and I did not want any of the condiments offered. Other places do not let you type a message to tell them exactly how you want the sandwich which makes it frustrating when trying to door dash exactly what I'm craving. Mangiamo Market is always a go to for me when im craving a nice Italian sub. They have so many choices and it is always delicious and fresh. I highly recommend!"
"I really wanted to give them 5 stars but it's an easy fix. The place is nice, big, and clean. The staff is friendly and the portions are definitely fair for the price. My only issue is taste. While the breaded chicken hero was good, the breading needs to be seasoned. It was just a little bland. The cook on the chicken, toppings, and quality of bread were perfect. On the chicken parm hero (H-1) it was the same issue. Also make sure the marinara sauce completely covers the chicken. I will definitely return in the future because these were minor issues. ***On a side note. This might just be a Door Dash thing. When customizing sandwiches on the menu, have an option for No Cheese. Sometimes people like a chicken cutlet hero with no cheese. ***"
W-1 Chicken Caesar
Grilled chicken, Romaine lettuce, Parmigiano and Caesar dressing.
$13.02
1/2 lb Macaroni Salad
Breaded Chicken Cutlets, Prosciutto di Parma, In House Made Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers, Lettuce, Arugula, Tomatoes, Balsamic Glaze, Pesto, Fresh Evoo, Oregano on a toasted semolina with garlic butter
$3.79
Create Your Own Salad
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
$15.04
#42. The LI Italian Speciale
Ham, salami, ham capicola, mortadella, provolone, tomato, onion, lettuce, and roasted peppers with oil and vinegar on a semolina hero.
$16.13
Bella Pizzeria

Bella Pizzeria

4.8
(10+)
• Italian • Pizzeria
$0 delivery fee • 7.1 mi • 44 min
$5 off on $45+
Cheese
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$22.02
Jersey Mike's Subs

Jersey Mike's Subs

4.7
(1k+)
• Sandwiches • Cheesesteaks
$0 delivery fee • 4.2 mi • 26 min
"They make the greatest sandwiches. My favorite is the turkey provolone. If you haven't ordered from them yet don't hesitate. "
"Okay whoever made my sandwich today deserves a gold star!!! PERFECTION!!! I always get pickles and banana peppers and usually they aren't as generous meaning did you even add them. Today's glorious sandwich had enough!!! I love the Italian and today's was (chefs kiss)!!!!"
Chips
classic lays unavailable
$2.1
#13 The Original Italian
Provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni. Served Mike's Way with onions, lettuce, tomato, vinegar, oil, oregano, and salt.
$14.51
#7 Turkey and Provolone
Provolone and Turkey. Served Mike's Way with onions, lettuce, tomato, vinegar, oil, oregano, and salt.
$13.09
#17 Mike's Famous Philly
Turkey, ham, provolone, applewood smoked bacon & mayo. Served Mike's Way with onions, lettuce, tomato, vinegar, oil, oregano, and salt.
$15
Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.5
(4k+)
• Pizzeria • Italian
$0 delivery fee • 10.4 mi • 55 min
"First time try the pepperoni pinwheel, it was delicious and so filling that I will have to save the pasta for later. Even though I did not order it this time around I would recommend their garden salad - it is one of the best I've ever had."
"Pizza was undercooked and inedible. The crust and sauce boundary tasted like gooey uncooked dough. Look at the photo the cheese didn't even melt entirely and you can still see the cheese grates"
Neapolitan Pie
Eighteen inches round, eight slices, cheese and tomato sauce.
$22.17
Garlic Knots (6)
Sixteen inches square, twelve slices thin crust pan pizza with mozzarella cheese and spotted tomato basil sauce.
$3.73
Neapolitan By The Slice
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, red onion, black olives, house dressing
$3.28
Grandma Pie
Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, parmesan cheese, caesar dressing.
$26.32
Cafe Gia

Cafe Gia

4.6
(2k+)
• Pizza • Italian
$0 delivery fee • 5.4 mi • 41 min
"As always, all our meals were delicious...The grilled chicken in the salad was perfectly seasoned and the pasta with the ala Alla Vodka sauce is so so good! "
"This is the best chicken noodle soup I've had in a very long time!!! packed to the brim absolutely delicious and fresh!"
Neapolitan (8 Slices)
Round Pie with mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce.
$24
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce tossed with our homemade caesar dressing, topped with croutons & pecorino romano cheese.
$14.53
Alla Vodka
Sauteed prosciutto in a homemade pink vodka sauce.
$22.08
Garlic Bread
Served with a side of tomato sauce. Gluten free also available.
$6.81
Holy Stromboli

Holy Stromboli

Italian
$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 32 min
The Briagone
Crispy chicken cutlet, vodka sauce, whole milk mutz, crispy prosciutto, pecorino cheese, served with homemade vodka sauce
$16.04
Fried Mozzarella Cheese Curds
Before fresh mozzarella, there was the cheese curd...Crispy gooey morsels of fried cheese curds...yum! Served with vodka dipping sauce
$16.85
Guido Balls
Totally outside the box mac&cheese….Made with angel hair pasta, ricotta, mozzarella and pecorino cheese, golden fried, served with alfredo dipping sauce
$19.45
The Rocky Balboa
Sliced Italian beef roast, caramelized onion, gravy, provolone and mozzarella blend, brown gravy dipping sauce
$19.09
Renzo’s

Renzo’s

4.6
(600+)
• Italian • Pizza
$0 delivery fee • 6.1 mi • 42 min
"Welcome back Renzo's. I grew up on your Chicken Roll and it is better than ever. Easily feeds 4 or 2 with excellent left overs! Delicious and affordable. So freakin delicious. "
"The flavor of the pasta is INSANELY good. I ordered this pasta like 4 or 5 times already and I will definitely order it again. I had this pasta before from another pizza restaurant and it wasn't good as Renzo's. Nothing could beat Renzo's penne ala vodka. Period."
Cheese Pizza
Jumbo chicken wings (8), tossed in our signature buffalo sauce served hot with blue cheese dressing
$21.78
Garlic Knots (6)
Classic Penne Ala Vodka with prosciutto in a pink cream sauce. Add Grilled Chicken, Grilled Shrimp for an additional charge.
$5.09
Half Topping Pizza
Crispy Romaine hearts tossed with croutons in a creamy Caesar dressing topped with grated pecorino Romano
$25.31
Penne Ala Vodka w/ Crispy Chicken
The Classic - Parmigiana with our homemade tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
$17.82
Paisano's Pizza & Catering

Paisano's Pizza & Catering

4.7
(1k+)
• Pizza • Italian
$0 delivery fee • 7.4 mi • 48 min
15% off on $40+
"Pizza is well made - thin, crispy crust, right amount of sauce and cheese. My favorite "parm" heroes in the area. Good portions, fair prices, great service. "
"This place is the best!! Delicious food at a great value! They always get the order and modifications right!! Best around for sure. "
18" Cheese Pizza
A large 18-inch pizza topped with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a crispy, golden crust.
$24.38
Rigatoni Alla Vodka Dinner
Rigatoni in a creamy vodka sauce, topped with grated cheese.
$21.11
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Breaded chicken cutlets, marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a hero roll.
$14.95
Garlic Knot Crust Pizza
Mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers and fried chicken topped with Shredded cheese.
$31.18

Middle Island Italian Delivery FAQs

Is Italian delivery available near me in Middle Island?

Yes, Italian delivery is available near you in Middle Island through DoorDash. Enter your address in the DoorDash app or website to find the best Italian options available for delivery near you.

Where can I find the best Italian delivery near me in Middle Island?

To find the best Italian delivery near you in Middle Island, look for restaurants with high ratings and user reviews on DoorDash. You can filter by ratings to see the top-rated Italian spots near you.

Where can I find cheap Italian near me in Middle Island?

For affordable Italian delivery near me in Middle Island, DoorDash allows you to filter restaurants by price. Look for spots marked with a single dollar for budget-friendly options.

What is open now for Italian delivery near me in Middle Island?

To see which Italian restaurants are open for delivery in Middle Island right now, enter your address on the DoorDash website or app. You will be shown a list of Italian places that are currently available for delivery, including their hours of operation.

Can I schedule a Italian delivery in Middle Island?

Yes, DoorDash allows you to schedule a Italian delivery in Middle Island at a time that works best for you. During checkout, simply choose the schedule option to set a future delivery time for your order.

How can I get free Italian delivery in Middle Island?

To enjoy 0 delivery fees on Italian orders in Middle Island, consider joining DashPass, DoorDash’s subscription service. DashPass members get free delivery on eligible orders from participating restaurants.

How do I pay for my Italian delivery on DoorDash in Middle Island?

Payment for your Italian delivery in Middle Island is easy and secure with DoorDash. You can pay through the app using credit/debit cards, DoorDash credits, or other available payment methods. No need to handle cash!

What are the most popular Italian dishes I can order near me in Middle Island?

Enter your address on DoorDash to discover the most-ordered Italian dishes from restaurants near you.

Checking if the site connection is secured...