Order the best Pasta near Middle Island, NY

$0 delivery fee • 4.3 mi • 35 min

20% off, up to $10

"Meatball Parm Roll Tasty and Crispy. tomato sauce on the side was OK."

"very disappointed this time.Sausage & Pepperoni Roll was too doughy this time. Last time the dough was crisp and cooked just right. This time it was awful."

Pasta with Meatballs

With mozzarella & ricotta.

$18.35

Napolitano Cheese Pizza

Traditional hand-tossed pizza. Large 18".

$30.97

Ultra Thin Cheese Pizza

10" (6 slices).

$13.52

Chicken Parm Roll

6". Hand-rolled housemade dough.

$12.9

Applebee's Grill & Bar

4.3

(6k+)

• Sandwiches • Burgers

$0 delivery fee • 4.8 mi • 33 min

"You can't ever go wrong ordering Classic Blackened Shrimp Alfredo ! The shrimp are tender and juicy. Perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. I only order alfredo fettuccini from Applebee's because it' the creamiest and richest cheese flavor anywhere else. I highly recommend this dish!"

"Beef nachos on 2 separate containers super dry, no beef like 23 dollars for what"

Four-Cheese Mac & Cheese with Honey Pepper Chicken Tenders

Oodles of noodles covered with a creamy Alfredo sauce, then tossed with diced chicken and sprinkled with shredded Parmesan cheese. Comes with a choice of side and drink.

$21.85

Boneless Wings

Crispy breaded pieces of tender boneless chicken tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with Bleu cheese or house-made ranch buttermilk ranch dressings and celery.

$17.69

2 for $25

Two Entrees + One Appetizer (For menu item descriptions, please see the regular menu item)

$36.26

Brew Pub Pretzels & Beer Cheese Dip

Soft, Bavarian-style pretzel sticks are ready to dip in BLUE MOON® white Cheddar beer cheese and honey Dijon mustard.

$13.54

Pompei Pizzeria & Restaurant

$0 delivery fee • 4.1 mi • 35 min

• Chicken • Seafood

"I recently ordered for the first time from Pompei and everything was DELICIOUS! The BEST, soft, fluffy, garlicky and buttery garlic knots! So good!! The fettuccine Alfredo with chicken was out of this world! So creamy and flavorful! Will be ordering again! Can't wait to try their pizza! "

"Ordered from pompei a few times. Food is always delicious. One of the better Italian restaurants in the area. Will continue to order from them. "

Rigatoni Alla Vodka

Our old-world recipe meatballs served in plum tomato sauce like grandma used to make.

$21.89

Round Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$25.28

Garlic Knots

Bread, topped with garlic & olive oil or butter, herb seasoning, baked to perfection. Melts in your mouth and arouses the taste buds.

$6.55

Regular Pizza Slice

Breaded cutlet topped with sauce.

$5.13

Bella Maria Restaurant & Pizzeria

(50+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.1 mi • 31 min

Penne Ala Vodka

Flash fried squid, crunchy on the outside and simply perfect on the inside. Kick it up a notch with a squeeze of lemon.

$23.13

Meatball Parmigiana Hero

Strips of breaded chicken topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$16.23

Chocolate Mousse Cake

Chicken cutlet baked in tomato sauce & melted mozzarella.

Chicken Roll

Sautéed onions, prosciutto in a pink vodka cream sauce.

$11.25

Cafe Gia

$0 delivery fee • 5.4 mi • 36 min

• Pizza • Italian

"As always, all our meals were delicious...The grilled chicken in the salad was perfectly seasoned and the pasta with the ala Alla Vodka sauce is so so good! "

"Taste wise, everything was good. the canzone was not sealed, cheese ran out everywhere. The broccoli cost $15 and it was the smallest portion I've ever seen. Horrible. Calamari was good and was a large portion."

Alla Vodka

Sauteed prosciutto in a homemade pink vodka sauce.

$21.89

Neapolitan (8 Slices)

Round Pie with mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce.

$23.74

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce tossed with our homemade caesar dressing, topped with croutons & pecorino romano cheese.

$14.18

Garlic Bread

Served with a side of tomato sauce. Gluten free also available.

$6.67

Carlo's Pizza of Shirley

$0 delivery fee • 4.3 mi • 31 min

(4k+)

• Italian • Seafood

"My favorite things from here are the cheesy garlic bread and lentil soup, I could literally eat it forever. Their baked ziti pizza and baked ziti is great too. I haven't eaten something from here that I didn't like. Favorite pizza place by far."

"I don't what these shenanigans are, but it's not Chicken Piccata - which is what I ordered. It was tasty-ish, but not piccata by any stretch of the imagination. Couldn't taste the wine, no capers, it was orange. Not piccata. Portions were huge though, like 3 meals huge."

Penne ala Vodka

with our Original Tomato Sauce.

$17.23

Neapolitan (Large)

W/ chicken.

$21.2

Regular Slice

12 slices.

$3.64

Joe's Pizza & Pasta

$0 delivery fee • 9.0 mi • 44 min

(7k+)

• Sandwich • Italian

"Amazing!! The Baked Ravioli (6) was so soft and tasty. The Homemade Meatballs (3) were thick and filling. The Tossed Salad | Large was a lot of salad, but I wish it had cucumbers. The bread they give you for free with the entree is way better than the one you order on the menu. "

"The Sweet Italian Sausage (3) was delicious and cooked perfectly. They had a nice snap but stil very tender... Oh my GOSH THAT SAUCE WAS INCREDIBLE I wanted to drink it right of of that tin conta... One of the best saucs I have ever had!!"

Penne Alla Vodka

Our famous pink cream sauce with or without ground beef.

$23.34

Neapolitano Cheese Pizza | 18"

8 slices. Regular pizza.

$27.38

Garlic Knots (6 Pieces)

Includes tomato dipping sauce.

$6.86

Cheese Personal Pizza

Cheese personal pizza

$17.85

Marinelli’s Pizzeria

4.8

(700+)

$0 delivery fee • 5.3 mi • 45 min

"Absolutely fantastic, I've never seen so much chicken in a Chicken Roll"

"I order this wrap at least 2xs a month and each time its delicious. Usually the wrap is grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers with a balsamic glaze. Last nights delivery was disappointing! Fried chicken a little bit of lettuce and a small amount of tomato. Not what I was expecting at all. "

Penne Alla Vodka

Thin crust Sicilian, mozzarella, garlic, plum tomato sauce.

$17.05

Neapolitan Pizza

Tomato sauce, mozzarella. 18".

$21.17

Regular Pizza Slice

Tomato sauce, mozzarella.

$3.77

Neapolitan personal Pizza

Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onions, shaved carrots, black olives, and shredded mozzarella.

$14.58

Luigi's Pizzeria & Restaurant (East Setauket)

$0 delivery fee • 9.7 mi • 40 min

$5 off on $25+

"The food is always hot and good. The Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza was still steaming hot and had plenty of quality toppings without being soggy. The Chicken Tenders are also crispy and tasty cooked in fresh oil. Luigi's is expensive but worth it."

"We are a huge fan of their 16" - Large Vegan Pizza. Their crust tastes great, and they put the right amount of cheese on it and make it bubbly. I also enjoy their hot sandwiches, the Chicken Francese parm hero is my favorite."

16" - Large Cheese Pizza

Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!

$27.11

Garlic Knots

Tossed with Garlic, Oil, Parmesan Cheese & Fresh Parsley. Melted Mozzarella Available

$5.19

12" - Medium Cheese Pizza

Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!

$19.68

Plain

Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese - Click to add Toppings!

$4.75

La Vespa

$0 delivery fee • 5.2 mi • 37 min

"I had to make a last min order for some and thank goodness the people who were working! Order was delivered before time. I only wish I could have tipped Semintra more, such a doll, TY:) Vespa is my fam fav. For a few reasons. Quality and consistency Parted with kindness. Love this. The GF pizza is amazing too, fellow celiacs. God bless"

"I was not thrilled with how my food was packaged.. Both Pizza slices were shoved into a bag. What a mess! Container with sauce for mozzarella sticks was squashed. Another mess. Sicilian slice was burned .. gross. White slice was fair. Was not pleased with my order.. Quality of food poor quality "

Penne Alla Vodka

Ricotta & mozzarella cheese.

$19.25

Cheese Pizza (Pie)

6 per order.

$22.46

Mozzarella Sticks

A pink creamy meat sauce simmered with vodka.

$11.11

Cheese slice

Breaded chicken bites in sweet n' spicy sauce.

$3.98

Jc pizzera

$0 delivery fee • 7.1 mi • 49 min

"The grilled chicken pie with spinach & ricotta was SO good! The chicken was tender, seasoning perfect and the crust was crunchy outside & tender inside. Would definitely recommend! Our new favorite pie!!"

"best pizza on Long Island, and I have tried every pizza place on L.I. Don't change anything, it's perfect"

Large Cheese Pie.

"southern italian style" hearty ground meat sauce.

$19.18

Large Chicken Ceasar Salad

Golden fried calamari served with side of marinara sauce.

$14.04

Mamma Lombardi's

$0 delivery fee • 8.9 mi • 45 min

• Breakfast • Takeout

"This place never disappoints, whether ordering pizza to go or dining out in the restaurant-- and this is the first night we ordered the Nonnas's (Grandma's) Pizza, which was unfathomably delicious. Probably the best grandma pie I've ever had. "

"the Mozz Sticks (6) were very bland and had a very thick breading on them. The cheese wasn't melted at all. the Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero had a lot of chicken but very little cheese or sauce and were really dry"

Penne Alla Vodka

Meat sauce, butter, red pepper flakes, grated cheese, and heavy cream. this dish comes with meat but can be made without meat upon request. ALLERGIES: Dairy GLUTEN FREE: No (Unless requested to be made with gluten free pasta)

$27.84

SIDE Meatballs

2 homemade meatballs with tomato sauce ALLERGIES: Ask chef GLUTEN FREE: No (ask chef)

$8.28

18"" Round Neapolitan Cheese Pizza

BREADED CHICKEN TOPPED WITH TOMATO SAUCE AND MELTED MOZZARELLA. SERVED WITH A SIDE OFPASTA OR SALAD. THIS DISH CANBE REQUESTED TO BE MADE WITH GRILLED CHICKEN. ALLERGIES: DAIRY GLUTEN FREE: NO (UNLESS MADE WITH GRILLED CHICKEN)

$22.52

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero

Sauteed chicken served in a lemon and white wine sauce. Served with pasta or salad. ALLERGIES: Ask chef GLUTEN FREE: No

$14.86

Alberts Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 8.7 mi • 41 min

"Seriously the best Zucchini Sticks I've ever had! came delivered piping hot soo good! the Rice Ball with Sauce and Cheese was ahhmazing!! bigger than I even thought but my god delicious! and hands down my ultimate favorite is the Upside Down SLICE !! best around!"

"Cream of Spinach Slice was amazing, it sounds a little odd but was actually fantastic. Upside Down Square Slice was also very good. Dough was delicious and nice and crispy (for slices. I haven't tried a whole pie. Yet.) "

18" Neapolitan Pizza

Cheese under the sauce.

$22.7

Upside Down Square Pie

12 pieces.

$23.72

(6) Garlic Knots

Grandma crust with vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil

$4.49

Regular SLICE

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

$3.53

Carnival Restaurant

$0 delivery fee • 6.6 mi • 40 min

(5k+)

• Takeout • Pizza

"The Harvest Arugula, Apple, cranberry, almond & goat cheese salad was fresh and the dressing was delicious. Regular cheese pie was also very good. "

"Love the pasta fagioli soup it is delicious, however, it being $16.50 you would expect to get a full quart of the soup. They don't fill up the container. This has happened now a few times to me when ordering this here."

Penne Vodka

Tubettini pasta with white cannellini beans, sautéed onions and garlic in a hearty tomato broth.

$23.2

Cheese

Crisp romaine lettuce and homemade garlic crostini croutons tossed in a cream caesar dressing.

$22.7

Sicilian

Toasted Italian bread topped with melted mozzarella cheese in our famous garlic sauce.

$24.27

Caesar

Served in a pink cream sauce with sautéed onions, fresh tomatoes, and a touch of meat.

$14.2

Gino's

$0 delivery fee • 11.6 mi • 44 min

"Food is consistently fantastic. Every single item on the menu is delicious. The prices are fair. Great portions. The staff is great! Absolutely recommend !"

"By the time the order came the pizza was cold. Also the pizza was not the best taste. Definitely have had better pizza for a better value. Portion was normal portion and the salad was good. Probably won't order again"

Alla Vodka

Creamy vodka pink sauce sauteed with diced imported prosciutto.

$22.95

Regular Pie

18 inch round crust pizza with mozzarella and tomato sauce.

$27.14

Regular Slice

Traditional crust with mozzarella & tomato sauce.

$4.26

Garlic Knots (6 per order)

Baked dough knots marinated with fresh garlic, olive oil, grated cheese & seasonings.

$4.99

Bella Roma Restaurant & Pizzeria (Coram)

$0 delivery fee • 3.2 mi • 33 min

• Mexican • Fast Casual

"Best Pizza in the north shore! I thought it was Pompei but nope Def Bella Roma!"

"Best pizza, always delicious. Never disappointed..when my food gets here its always hot, huge slices and portions. Will order at least 1x a week."

Large Pizza Pie

Romaine lettuce croutons, shaved parmesan cheese caesar dressing on the side

$25.13

Reg Slice

White or red sauce marinara sauce or garlic and oil.

$4.24

Pazzo Ristorante and Wood Fired Pizzeria

$0 delivery fee • 6.6 mi • 49 min

"Always pleased with Pazzo's food quality and preparation. The Chicken Marsala was a delight! A generous helping of pasta, plenty of sauce and mushrooms, and tender chicken. Full of flavor...not an easy dish to get right! Recommended!"

"Pazzo is fire. Hidden gem. I used to drive from rocky point right by 3 or 4 pizza spots for Pazzo, now I let doordash take it to me. Vodka Margherita WF is amazing, full size is always a great choice. Best regular slice around too. Enjoyed the Baked Combination tonight as well."

Rigatoni Alla Vodka

Small or large serving. Romaine lettuce, Parmesan, house-made croutons, Caesar dressing.

$21.75

Regular Pie

Toppings: pepperoni, meatball, sausage, mushroom, spinach, broccoli, peppers, onions.

$21.58

Garlic Knots

Crispy, golden, delicious garlic knots.

$5.77

Margherita WF

Crispy delicious fried mozzarella sticks.

$17.64

Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

(4k+)

$0 delivery fee • 10.4 mi • 50 min

"First time try the pepperoni pinwheel, it was delicious and so filling that I will have to save the pasta for later. Even though I did not order it this time around I would recommend their garden salad - it is one of the best I've ever had."

"Pizza was very good but I wish they offered thin and crispy. Caeser salad is delicious but I wish they offered smaller portions at a lower cost."

Penne alla Vodka Pasta

6 slices, cheese and tomato sauce.

$21.5

Neapolitan Pie

Eighteen inches round, eight slices, cheese and tomato sauce.

$22.2

Garlic Knots (6)

Sixteen inches square, twelve slices thin crust pan pizza with mozzarella cheese and spotted tomato basil sauce.

$3.73

Neapolitan By The Slice

Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, red onion, black olives, house dressing

$3.28

Renzo’s

$0 delivery fee • 6.1 mi • 43 min

"Welcome back Renzo's. I grew up on your Chicken Roll and it is better than ever. Easily feeds 4 or 2 with excellent left overs! Delicious and affordable. So freakin delicious. "

"The flavor of the pasta is INSANELY good. I ordered this pasta like 4 or 5 times already and I will definitely order it again. I had this pasta before from another pizza restaurant and it wasn't good as Renzo's. Nothing could beat Renzo's penne ala vodka. Period."

Penne Ala Vodka

Traditional Fried Calamari served hot with our Homemade Marinara Sauce

$25.32

Cheese Pizza

Jumbo chicken wings (8), tossed in our signature buffalo sauce served hot with blue cheese dressing

$21.53

Garlic Knots (6)

Classic Penne Ala Vodka with prosciutto in a pink cream sauce. Add Grilled Chicken, Grilled Shrimp for an additional charge.

Half Topping Pizza

Crispy Romaine hearts tossed with croutons in a creamy Caesar dressing topped with grated pecorino Romano

$25.1

La Grova Ristorante and Pizzeria

• Italian • Italian Restaurant

(900+)

$0 delivery fee • 9.3 mi • 43 min

"I love La Grova!!! from their pasta, pizza, and Grilled Chicken Salad..😘 Chef's Kiss! I fell for this restaurant when I ordered a bacon and onion pizza. I wasn't expecting full slices of bacon! I was hooked going forward and could not wait to try other dishes. Back to the Grilled Chicken Salad and Garlic Bread with Cheese ...Man o Man!!! I was craving this yesterday, but they are closed on Monday's. I couldn't wait for them to open today. Excellent staff, food, and service!"

"Excellent meal -my first try w/this restaurant a winner all the way-from the tasty large Sicilian salad which had great variety , to the fresh and flavorful Chicken Parm hero , cooked well and seasoned just enough ; shout out also to the fresh garlic infused toasted garlic bread , uniquely done-looking forward to ordering from here again "

Penne alla Vodka

Romaine lettuce topped with garlic croutons, Parmesan cheese shavings and homemade caesar dressing.

$19.07

Neopolitan

Thin crust pizza with mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

$20.07

Garlic Knots

Penne cooked with vodka, cream, prosciutto and a touch of marinara sauce.

$3.34

Caesar Salad

Crispy chicken breast coated with Mozzarella , served with options: penne or spaghetti in tomato sauce or mixed or Caesar salad.

$13.66

Uncle Joes Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 9.4 mi • 43 min

"Wow!! I ordered the kids penne vodka and a side of cutlets. I asked them to please add a little broccoli in there because I didnt see an option to just add it to the pasta. They added a decent amount and the portion sizes were GENEROUS. The pasta was perfectly al dente. It was all delicious and you can tell they add a little love into each order. "

"CONSISTENTLY DELICIOUS!!!!!! Portions are perfect, food is always fresh!! Best Buffalo Slice, Pizza is cheesy and delicious!!! Best lentil soup! Best Penne Vodka!! We love Uncle Joe's!!! Would order 100000 times again!"

Penne Alla Vodka

Romaine lettuce, croutons, and grated parmesan cheese.

$18.43

Neapolitan Pizza

Personal gluten free or cauliflower pizza available.

$23.76

Stuffed Garlic Knots

Cheese or pepperoni.

$3.96

Regular Slice

Ham, salami, provolone, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, red onions & house vinaigrette.

$3.69

La Volpe Ristorante & Anton Pizzeria

(200+)

$0 delivery fee • 9.2 mi • 41 min

"My parents have lived in Center Moriches for almost 15 years now. They found this restaurant & pizzeria immediately, lots & lots of recommendations from the neighbors at the gated 55+ community where they bought a retirement home. I've honestly never heard a bad word about this eatery. IMHO, the ONLY bad thing is they're closed 2 days a week, Mon. & Tues. 🥺 You want a quick slice at lunch or a casual meal with your kids? You go to the right, the pizzeria side. Order there & sit in the pizza parlor or pick up your take-out order, pay & go. Would you rather have a nice, long, boozy, delicious dinner with friends or a romantic evening with a loved one? Then, you go in the left doors, the restaurant. It's beautifully decorated, dim ambient lighting, candles on the tables, big or small. Surprisingly, it's also rather private & quiet in the dining area, considering there is also a lively bar area at the back of the restaurant with a jukebox. I'm not 100% sure, but I think there are some small cafe tables, maybe booths, in the bar area for apps., snacks, those drunken noshes we've all craved, IF you drink, that is. Of course, most importantly though, the food is absolutely divine. It's definitely some of the BEST Italian food I've ever had the pleasure of indulging in. And, I've lived in the city, on & off, since the 1980's, when I was about 12yo. Spending decades living & eating in NYC, you get spoiled. Great food is on every block & around every corner! La Volpe is up there with my all-time favorites in Manhattan. La Volpe or Anton's pizza is a must try if you're in the area, you WILL NOT be disappointed!"

"Excellent Pizza best ive had in awhile , actually followed up directions "

Penne Vodka

Roasted Beets, Arugula, Caramelized Walnuts, Red Onion, Goat Cheese & Honey Dijon Vinaigrette

$20.04

Cheese Pizza

Tomato sauce, mozzarella and fresh basil.

$22.63

Margherita Pizza

Chopped meat, ham, onion and mushrooms in a pink sauce.

$16.36

Mozzarella Sticks

Grilled or breaded and fried covered with tomato sauce and topped with melted mozzarella.

$9.25

Spuntino St. James

$0 delivery fee • 12.2 mi • 43 min

• Pizza • Italian

"I got a blackened chicken Caesar Salad and it was amazing, a good portion of chicken and lettuce, very tasty. I also enjoyed the Vegetarian Pizza Vegetarian Pizza Slice, it had a good selection of toppings and was loaded with them. "

"Spuntino's is such a wonderful St. James staple. While there is no shortage of good pizza around here, their take on The Little Neapolitan Pizzette (12") as well as the specialty little pizzas (like the clam pizzette, holy toledo) occupy more mind space than I care to admit. Make sure to order their cauliflower or gluten-free crust option for any of their pizzas!!"

Penne Alla Vodka

Chicken hero with marinara sauce and parmesan cheese.

$24.9

Neapolitan Round Cheese Pizza

Mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

$24.76

The Little Neapolitan Pizzette (12")

Mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

$20.29

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce, garlic croutons, Parmesan cheese & Caesar dressing.

$17.22

Mozzafiato Pizzeria

4.8

$0 delivery fee • 7.8 mi • 39 min

• Panini • Pizza

"LOVE this new Pizzeria in town. The meatballs are by far the best, they are moist and flavorful. The Chicken Marsala, the gravy was REAL gravy with mushroom and herbs, tasted just like home made. The Penne Ala Vodka was cooked perfectly and the mozzarella sticks were large, hot and stringy! I have not had the pizza yet, going to try it tonight. I used Doordash and the order was here within 25 minutes of ordering. "

"The Meatball Parmigiana Hero was good. They used a vented container so it didn't get soggy. But for a $19 hero four meatballs barely filled the small hero. The meat balls and sauce were good, not great but good. And the meatballs were uncut which was the worst part. Try to take a bite and they fly out the side."

Rigatoni Alla Vodka

Thick pan pizza with mozzarella and tomato sauce.

$22.78

Neapolitan

18" round pizza with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$25.69

Garlic Knots

Each. Angel hair pasta and cheese formed into patties and deep fried.

$6.14

Capellini Cake

Thin pan pizza with mozzarella and fresh San Marzano plum tomatoes.

$4.26

La Famosa Pizzaria

$0 delivery fee • 7.4 mi • 40 min

"La Famosa is an excellent pizzeria with delicious food. The Garlic Bread with Cheese & Pepperoni had a generous amount of pepperoni, which is much appreciated. You should definitely try the Vodka Slice too. The Cannoli had a generous helping of cream too"

"Wow I was impressed I order chicken franchese with spaghetti flavor is so on point and texture wow good job!! And my family is Italian"

Regular Pie

Classic cheese or create your own pie

$22.89

Regular Slice

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$3.83

Garlic Knots

Tossed in BBQ or buffalo sauce.

$5.65

Fried Mozzarella Sticks

Fresh mozzarella cheese, pomodoro sauce, fresh basil.

$10.03

Selden Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 5.9 mi • 38 min

(700+)

• Pizza • Heroes

"When my son first said he wanted to eat here I saw the rating on Google and didn't really want to. My son swore up and down this place was amazing and he is a big pizza fanatic so I reluctantly agreed to go ahead and give it a try. I will be the first to admit that I prejudged this place without actually reading the reviews and how long ago they were posted. It's been well over a year that we have been eating here (with the exception of my long time loyal son) and I can easily say that Selden Pizza is the best around here. As for today's order the Neapolitan Round Cheese Pie was perfectly cooked as per usual. Hot, cheesy, and the crust cooked perfectly. Selden Pizzas consistency is what keeps us loyal and coming back. It doesn't matter what time of day you order the pizza is always excellent. This is the first time we ordered the Chicken Fingers with Fries and I was a little nervous since small places like this tend to be hit or miss with this kind of meal especially when their specialty is pizzas and pastas. My daughter who can't eat dairy can be pretty picky so I wasn't sure how she would like the meal. Of course there was no reason to worry. The chicken fingers were really good. Hot, great taste, cooked perfectly and was portioned just right but what I was even more impressed with were the fries. Fries can easily go wrong and in my home everyone can be quite snobby. These were perfectly cooked. They were hot, seasoned tasty, and cooked absolutely perfect not burnt or soggy like some places and priced more than fair at $10 for fries and chicken fingers."

"This pizza is the real deal. Sauce is tangy and perfect. Cheese is perfectly cooked. Crust floppy but not wet and just a bit chewy. Like the perfect amount of chewy. And thats before I get high. Well done team Selden Pizza!"

Penne Ala Vodka

Flavorful red meat, roasted on a spit to seal in its juices.

$17.26

Neapolitan Round Cheese Pie

Eighteen inches.

$22.81

Round Neapolitan Cheese Pizza Slice

Thin Sicilian crust brushed with olive oil & garlic, fresh mozzarella, and spotted with chunky San Marzano tomato sauce.

$3.42

Grandma Pizza Slice

Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Served with marinara sauce.

$3.71

The Pie Coal-Fired Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 8.0 mi • 39 min

(400+)

• Calzones • Salads

"OMG! So glad we found this place! The Large Classic Margherita Pie was amazing. The Zucchini Fritter were sooooooo good and the Coal Fired Garlic Bread with Mozzarella was fantastic especially with a zucchini piece and dab of the delicious sauce on it. A little pricey but well worth it for a special treat"

"Food was delicious! We've been searching for a Neapolitan style brick oven pizza on Long Island for a while and this was the best! Ordered a side of House Meatballs and Artichoke Heart Oregonata and all were delicious!!! "

Penne Vodka

Topped with ricotta and mozzarella.

$29.14

Large Classic Margherita Pie

Crisp crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino Romano, and olive oil.

$28.95

Small Classic Margherita Pie

Crisp crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino Romano, and olive oil.

$17.42

Garlic Knots (3 Pieces)

Crisp crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino Romano, and olive oil.

$3.48

Roadhouse Brick Oven Pizza

4.4

$0 delivery fee • 13.3 mi • 41 min

"Our family has been going here for nearly a decade now, they make some of the Best Pizza in new york in our opinion! "

" Neopolitan 19" Round Thin Crust is a standard Long Island, copy and paste pizza where the thin crust is still thick. Did half anchovies and half pepperoni - anchovies were burnt and or bad, and pepperoni side was kinda flavorless.. sauce is bland.. bottom of pie wasnt burnt. Decent spot."

Neopolitan 19" Round Thin Crust

Made with meatballs and sausage

$29.69

Matt's Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 3.7 mi • 33 min

• Pizza • Italian

"The lasagna was excellent and such a generous portion. I've ordered lasagna from a few other local pizzerias and always been very disappointed with the quality as well as the portion size. Matts will ve my go to from now on!"

"So our first time ordering from Matt's and was definitely a success with everyone in the house hold ( 9 )of us and some of us are VERY picky . The one thing I liked was they ran out of manicotti :( BUT for that they gave me extra meatballs :) "

Pasta with Alla Vodka Sauce

With romaine, lettuce, and celery.

$14.37

Neapolitan (18")

Cooked wing of a chicken coated in sauce or seasoning.

$18.76

Neapolitan (14")

Long thing pasta.

$16.09

Garlic Knot

Cooked in oil.

$23.92

Avino's Italian Table

(700+)

$0 delivery fee • 8.8 mi • 35 min

"food was fantastic. Nana's Giant Meatball Caesar al Romana Nanas Crushed Meatball were awesome. meatball moist, piping hot and delightful. Caesar salad dressing is really good."

"Fruit i di Mare – fruits of the sea ok, they use bay scallops need I say more? Barely any linguine which is surprising, 3 shrimp, 5 clams, 10 mussels and cheap calamari with the cheap bay scallops plus to top it off was literally no sauce and you think since it's an Italian restaurant there'd be fresh basil leaves here and there? When Medford pizzeria makes a better one than an Italian restaurant there's a problem. Baked Stuffed Clams there's nothing Italian about these clams, dried out chopped, too much bread crumbs and bacon in there also. One word Yuck! Penne Alla Vodka- news flash! There should be prosciutto in there. Rule one at an Italian restaurant is make sure you know how to boil pasta. Mushy, terrible and embarrassing. The best thing was the Rustica which I thought would be the issue. Get it together people. Oh I almost forgot the bread, stale.. and I'm a gavon so I always dip in the sauces when I'm eating. Other than that this place is terrifically terrible!"

Cavatelli alla Uncle Leo

Ricotta pasta/parmesan cream sauce/crispy breaded chicken breast/green peas/ crumbled bacon.

$33.4

Caesar Salad

Chopped romaine hearts/creamy dressing crushed garlic crostini/shaved reggiano

$18.92

Baked Stuffed Clams

Chopped clams/bacon/garlic/parmesan.

$17.14

Penne Alla Vodka Buratta

Our classic sliced Italian bread stuffed with garlic, oil, and finely chopped veggies.

$28.85

Old Town Pizza

(600+)

$0 delivery fee • 5.8 mi • 38 min

"The salad slice..lettuce nice and crisp, crust cooked to perfection and the sauce/dressing always delicious! "

"The 6 Garlic Parm Wings were a big surprise! Big pieces, juicy, and the particular mixture they use is really tasty. Cheese Pie (l) was great as always. Fr Calamari_Marinara was so-so. A little undercooked, maybe."

Cheese Pie (l)

(6) battered mozzarella sticks served with tomato dipping sauce

$26.33

Chicken Parm Roll

Crispy cannoli shell filled to order with creamy cannoli cream and chocolate chips

$11.74

Meatball Parm Hero

Fresh orecchiette pasta, chicken, broccoli, oven roasted tomato, artichoke, kalamata olive, and roasted garlic white wine sauce

$17

Mozzarella Sticks

jumbo shrimp sauteed with a touch of butter, garlic and white wine

$12.91

Caribbean Spot 112

4.2

(800+)

• Curry • Caribbean

$0 delivery fee • 3.6 mi • 30 min

"Lawddd have mercy!!! The food from this restaurant is OUT OF THIS WORLD❤❤❤. Please don't open if the cook have a day off or sick. This is authentic Jamaican food,that when you are eating,you are taken back to your granny woodfire in the outside kitchen. This is how good the soups are. The oxtail weekend soup is no joke,it is damn good!!! Today I had a wicked red peas soup with chicken from this place. Keep cooking like this. We really appreciate the good food ,good portions and great prices One very satisfied customer 😀"

"The oxtails are so fresh, tender, and yummy every single time! All of their dishes are delicious! They give you a generous amount of food, perfect for sharing. Love, love,love this restaurant. I'm ordering from them weekly. Oh and on weekends they have curry shrimp and fried shrimp and lots of specialty dishes. Sooo good! "

Oxtail Meal

Tota.

$23.45

Jerk Chicken Meal

The juices are: Sorrel ginger, carrot ginger, pineapple lime, Mauby (it is a bittersweet drink also good for the body).

$14.2

Brown Stewed Chicken Meal

The bold, refreshing, robust cola

$12.98

Beef Patty

Leafy green vegetable dish.

$3.75

Uncle Joe's Famous Pizzeria

4.2

$0 delivery fee • 8.8 mi • 36 min

"Giuseppe Cheese Slice isn the best on the island BUT for the price, it's pretty stellar. The crust was the perfect texture and the cheese/sauce ratio was great. The Alla Vodka slice was much more similar to a white slice than a traditional vodka slice - a small amount of mild vodka sauce, topped with mozz and ricotta dollops. It is the newer vodka square style too, so dont expect triangles there. Overall would dine again, especially given the fair price point compared to other bellport/patchogue/medford options."

"Pretty good food but always an issue with them. Doesn't matter if you call them directly or use DoorDash for pickup or DoorDash for delivery. Orders are always messed up, items are not available, there are always huge delays. Staff is unfriendly, barely ever apologetic for their mistakes."

Giuseppe Cheese

Signature Cheese Pie that's made pizzaiolo Joe Sciara a Long Island legend since 1968.

$23.95

Brooklyn Garlic Parmesan Knots

Baked dough with melted garlic butter, parmesan, parsley

$6.11

Pizza Margherita

Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, Pecorino-Romano

$23.55

Mozz Sticks

Mozzarella breaded with Italian bread crumbs, marinara

$10.44

Ruggero's

$0 delivery fee • 7.4 mi • 48 min

• Italian • Chicken

"Great Italian food! Never fails to satisfy! So glad they're are on door dash now so we can have it delivered to us! "

"Both pasta orders (Marsala & Francese) had penne that was hardly cooked - not in an al dente way -, sauce was very liquidy. Definitely not worth the extreme price, for what should be such basic dishes. "

Penne A La Vodka

Add chicken or sausage for additional cost.

$29.76

Parmigiana

Served with pasta.

$29.58

Rigatoni Bolognese

Meaty with tomatoes, cream, oregano, slow cooked.

$25.27

Mamma's Meatballs (3)

Smothered in marinara sauce served with ricotta and crusty bread.

$19.59

Miller's Ale House

4.4

(3k+)

• Burgers • American (New)

$0 delivery fee • 10.1 mi • 43 min

" I added extra chicken to the grilled chicken fajita dinner which cost me an additional $6.50 and the serving looked like a normal size serving-not extra. Also, the grilled chicken GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD salad had the smallest amount of grilled chicken. Not enough for a serving. Take out dinners are not the same size as in person res dinners. They give way less meat but its the same price. Very disappointed! "

"Blackened Shrimp and Chicken Cobb salad had 4 tiny pieces of shrimp and tiny slivers if chicken. the Bavarian pretzels were hard and cold and the cheese sauce was watery. And the Party House Salad barely had any cucumbers. "

ZINGERS® MAC ‘N’ CHEESE

Bite-sized pieces of medium sauced Zingers®, shell pasta, creamy sauce of blended cheese, scallions, toasted breadcrumbs.

$22.46

ZINGERS®

Celery sticks.

$19.48

ZINGERS MOUNTAIN MELT®

Zingers®, blended cheeses, applewood-smoked bacon and scallions on a mountain of fries.

$22.57

Wading River Pizzeria - 6324 Route 25a

4.2

(40+)