Order the best Pizza near Shoreham, NY

$0 delivery fee • 2.1 mi • 29 min

(700+)

• Chicken • Seafood

"I recently ordered for the first time from Pompei and everything was DELICIOUS! The BEST, soft, fluffy, garlicky and buttery garlic knots! So good!! The fettuccine Alfredo with chicken was out of this world! So creamy and flavorful! Will be ordering again! Can't wait to try their pizza! "

"This is the 2nd order that has been disgusting so we will not be ordering again. The first time was grizzly veal parm and now we ordered a simple white pizzette and it was cardboard ant tasteless. I never review, after spending $100.00 2x I'm out. Also, not picky people will pretty much eat anything. Absolutely gross."

Round Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$25.9

Garlic Knots

Bread, topped with garlic & olive oil or butter, herb seasoning, baked to perfection. Melts in your mouth and arouses the taste buds.

$6.76

Regular Pizza Slice

Breaded cutlet topped with sauce.

$5.14

Chicken Cutlet Hero

A mixture of fresh seasonal greens.

$13.57

Pelligrino Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 1.0 mi • 24 min

"Pizza is pretty good, I honestly haven't had a great slice from anywhere in a long time but I order from Pellegrino's more often than other places so I guess that's saying something. The knots are just the way I like them, another review said they were undercooked but I like soft knots. The Godfather bread is amazing, if u haven't tried it I highly recommend that u do, the roasted red peppers and the spices they use really push this garlic bread to the top, after trying this there is no way I could go back to any other garlic bread."

"Honestly way too expensive for only two little things of Spinach Manicotti. The garlic knots were good but the Spinach Manicotti was not worth the money i spent. "

Neapolitan Pizza

Traditional round eight slices with cheese and tomato.

$25.13

Fresh Baked Garlic Knots

Fresh baked

$4.73

Regular Cheese Pizza Slice

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$4.47

Mozzarella Sticks (6)

Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite! Served with a side of marinara sauce.

$10.65

Pizza Hut

$0 delivery fee • 5.4 mi • 35 min

• Pizza • Chicken Wings

20% off on $20+

"the Oven-Baked Cheesy Alfredo Pasta was absolutely outstanding the best I've ever had! As per usual the Create Your Own Pizza was amazing too! overall worth every penny!"

"There were only 4 pepperonis on the entire pizza. Also, they put virtually no marinara sauce on it. I can't even see it. Maybe since I ordered (and paid for) extra marinara on the side, they somehow thought I didn't want any on the pizzas."

Personal Pan Pizza®

Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!

$7.64

Create Your Own Pizza

Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!

$21.47

Breadsticks

Nobody does breadsticks like the Hut. Crispy-on-the-outside, soft-on-the-inside, and seasoned with garlic and parmesan, they're perfect with pizza or pasta. Comes with a cup of our delicious marinara!

$7.17

Cheese Sticks

A side everyone can agree on! Get these cheese sticks sprinkled with flavorful Italian seasoning and a cup of our delicious marinara.

$8.36

Domino's

4.8

$0 delivery fee • 1.9 mi • 29 min

• Pizza • Pizzeria

Build Your Own Pizza

A custom pizza made to order. Choose from any of our delicious crust styles, including Handmade Pan.

$16.78

Stuffed Cheesy Bread

Our 8-piece oven-baked breadsticks are generously stuffed and covered with a blend of 100% real mozzarella and cheddar cheeses then seasoned with a touch of garlic.

$9.28

Wisconsin 6-Cheese

Feta, provolone, cheddar, Parmesan-Asiago, cheese made with 100% real mozzarella and sprinkled with oregano.

$18.28

Parmesan Bread Bites

Handmade from fresh buttery tasting pan dough, drizzled with garlic seasoning and sprinkled with Parmesan. Oven baked to perfection.

$8.59

Rocky Point Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 34 min

20% off on $40+

"Meatball Parm Roll Tasty and Crispy. tomato sauce on the side was OK."

"The Chicken Francese looked so delicious and smelled so good then I cut the chicken in half and it was raw inside and our appetites were ruined. Thank goodness I decided to cut the chicken in half as the serving size is so large. Seems fresh however raw chicken isn't something I want for dinner."

Napolitano Cheese Pizza

Traditional hand-tossed pizza. Large 18".

$30.9

Chicken Parm Roll

6". Hand-rolled housemade dough.

$12.9

Ultra Thin Cheese Pizza

10" (6 slices).

$13.58

Mozzarella Sticks

6 pieces.

$12.8

Papa Johns Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 6.7 mi • 36 min

• Chicken Wings • Pizza

"Door Dash and service from Papa John top notch in service and quality. A great delivery service used when working over nights at Mather Memorial Northwell Health Jefferson. Arrival hot and steamy. Incredibly tasty. Topping gator,,, affordable and worth the price. Keep it leveled when driving in supportive case to keep HOT. Engineering team Business to Business Top performance in service safe handling QUALITY 100% products 5Star "

"Papa John's is the only pizza I like on Long Island. My favorite is the Hawaiian bbq chicken. Who says pineapple doesn't go on pizza. <3. I also recommend bacon and pineapple with the 3 cheese blend. Perfect combo of sweet and salty. "

Cheesesticks

Our original dough covered with Special Garlic Sauce, topped with cheese and baked. Served with original pizza dipping sauce.

$9.16

Create Your Own Pizza

Build your own custom pizza and we'll handcraft it for you. With so many delicious options to choose from, your masterpiece is waiting!

$15.79

Cheese Pizza

Cheese and pizza sauce on your choice of crust.

$14.7

Pepperoni Pizza

Pepperoni, cheese and pizza sauce on your choice of crust.

$14.63

Fusilli

4.8

(200+)

$0 delivery fee • 3.8 mi • 37 min

"Well, the Neopolitan and specialty slices are delicious, however, specialty taste slices came cold, and there is no blue cheese on this buffalo chicken, which is strange. For seven dollars I expect fireworks."

"It was so fresh and delicious with lots of feta cheese! A bonus homemade bread! Love, love, love!"

Neapolitan Pie

CHEESE & TOMATO SAUCE

$30.66

6 Garlic Knots

THIN CRUST SICILIAN PIZZA WITH MOZZARELLA & PECORINO ROMANO CHEESE, WITH GARLIC PLUM TOMATO BASIL SAUCE

$5.85

White Slice

12" X 18" PAN MOZZARELLA CHEESE & TOMATO SAUCE

$6.57

Grandma Vodka Slice

BREADED CHICKEN CUTLETS TOPPED WITH OUR HOMEMADE POMODORO SAUCE AND MELTED MOZZARELLA

$5.26

Alfredo's Pizzeria

(3k+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.4 mi • 42 min

"This was some of the best stuffed rigatoni I've had in years. The garlic bread was delicious & excellent dipped in the sauce. The chicken pieces were extremely tender. The portion was so huge I had it for two dinners & lunch!You will not be disappointed!"

"Large Grilled Chx Salad is delicious!! Plenty of chicken and fresh crispy vegetables. Alfredo's is one of my favorites. Definitely would recommend"

- Cheese Pizza (T)

(6) classic wings tossed in your choice of sauce, served with blue cheese dipping sauce, celery and carrot sticks.

$24.6

6 Garlic Knots

Seasoned rice with ground beef, peas, sauce and cheese in the middle.

$4.71

Slice

Our homemade rice ball filled with ground beef, peas, sauce and cheese, topped with pomodoro sauce and melted whole milk mozzarella.

$4.43

Specialty Slice

Chicken, pepperoni, vodka sauce, crushed red pepper flakes, fresh mozzarella

$6.85

Uncle Giuseppe's Pizza

4.4

$0 delivery fee • 7.5 mi • 48 min

"Fresh, hot, & delicious! Did not expect for it to taste so good but it definitely is one of my new favorites! :)"

"Sicilian Square is not very good at all. Sauce is bitter. Don't know what these people are talking about that claim it's very good. They have select items that are very good however pizza is definitely not one of them."

Neapolitan Round (8 slices)

20” thin crust pizza with mozzarella & California tomato sauce.

$20.68

6 Garlic Knots

Our 6 Garlic Knots are a delectable appetizer or snack, perfect for garlic lovers. Made with soft, fluffy dough twisted into knots and baked to perfection, then brushed with a garlic-infused buttery blend for irresistible flavor. Enjoy these savory treats on their own or dipped in marinara sauce for an extra burst of taste.

$3.11

12 Garlic Knots

Our Garlic Knots are a delectable appetizer or snack, perfect for garlic lovers. Made with soft, fluffy dough twisted into knots and baked to perfection, then brushed with a garlic-infused buttery blend for irresistible flavor. Enjoy these savory treats on their own or dipped in marinara sauce for an extra burst of taste.

$7.15

Sicilian Square (8 slices)

Thick crust pan pizza topped with mozzarella & California tomato sauce,

$23.84

Marinelli’s Pizzeria

(800+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.0 mi • 44 min

"Have ordered Pizza and food from Marinellis . Everything is Awesome. Salads are Fresh Sauce is perfect . Love this place !!!"

"2nd time I ordered the eggplant parm hero it was horrible, but the 1st time it was amazing. Guess it depends on who is cooking that day. Will order from again because their food is generally really good and their prices are great compared to so many others."

Neapolitan Pizza

Tomato sauce, mozzarella. 18".

$21.24

Regular Pizza Slice

Tomato sauce, mozzarella.

$3.8

Neapolitan personal Pizza

Served with side of marinara sauce. 6 Pieces.

$14.62

Sicilian Square Pizza

Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onions, shaved carrots, black olives, and shredded mozzarella.

$23.22

Wading River Pizzeria - 6324 Route 25a

4.3

(70+)

$0 delivery fee • 3.5 mi • 35 min

Fried Chicken Cutlet (1)

Mid buffalo gold, honey bbq sweet sour, teriyaki, honey garlic, thai chili,mango habanero, plain garlic parmesan hot spicy garlic or hot

$4.8

Matt's Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 6.7 mi • 43 min

• Pizza • Italian

"The lasagna was excellent and such a generous portion. I've ordered lasagna from a few other local pizzerias and always been very disappointed with the quality as well as the portion size. Matts will ve my go to from now on!"

"Usually order pizza from here, I've had their sausage and pepper pasta, it's really good. However I ordered spaghetti Pasta with Alla Vodka Sauce and it has barely any sauce and taste like plain pasta. Very disappointed."

Roadhouse Brick Oven Pizza

(200+)

$0 delivery fee • 11.9 mi • 45 min

"Our family has been going here for nearly a decade now, they make some of the Best Pizza in new york in our opinion! "

" Neopolitan 19" Round Thin Crust is a standard Long Island, copy and paste pizza where the thin crust is still thick. Did half anchovies and half pepperoni - anchovies were burnt and or bad, and pepperoni side was kinda flavorless.. sauce is bland.. bottom of pie wasnt burnt. Decent spot."

Neopolitan 19" Round Thin Crust

Made with meatballs and sausage

$29.61

6 Garlic Knots

vodka sauce and fresh mozzerella on a square crust

$5.75

Chicken Roll

Breaded chicken cutlets, marinara sauce, topped with mozzerella and ricotta cheeses on a pizza crust.

$17.32

Grandma Thin Crust - Pan Style

sliced tomatoes with mozzerella and pesto sauce

$31.06

Bella Roma Restaurant & Pizzeria (Coram)

$0 delivery fee • 7.6 mi • 49 min

• Mexican • Fast Casual

"Best Pizza in the north shore! I thought it was Pompei but nope Def Bella Roma!"

"Okay. I planned on taking photos BEFORE taking a bite. Impossible with that irresistible smell 😅 but this is a new favorite spot. Portion size you say? Well Large Grandma's Pizza lives up to its name. 24 slices! This isn't one or the other either. It is both MASSIVE and DELICIOUS. The Meatball Parm Hero goes beyond fresh. Let it be known I took a large "sample bite" prior to the photos. Wow. Genuinely blown away. Meatballs are gigantic and that homemade sauce is authentic Italian at its finest. Old fashioned deliciousness. Conclusion: This is a 10/10 old school Italian restaurant all around. This isn't just a pizzeria. This is a true old fashioned Italian restaurant. The Large Grandma's Pizza is ideal for parties or family get togethers. The Meatball Parm Hero is the best I've had on Long Island and I HIGHLY recommend giving it a shot if you love meatballs. Zero complaints. Bella Roma gets an A++ from me and I will be back for more 😋"

Large Pizza Pie

Romaine lettuce croutons, shaved parmesan cheese caesar dressing on the side

$25.23

The Pie Coal-Fired Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 8.4 mi • 46 min

(500+)

• Calzones • Salads

"OMG! So glad we found this place! The Large Classic Margherita Pie was amazing. The Zucchini Fritter were sooooooo good and the Coal Fired Garlic Bread with Mozzarella was fantastic especially with a zucchini piece and dab of the delicious sauce on it. A little pricey but well worth it for a special treat"

"Everything we order is beyond delicious! We especially love the Small Classic Margherita Pie and their minestrone soup hits perfectly in this long, cold winter. Meatballs are a crowd pleaser as well. Our new favorite pizza place!"

Small Classic Margherita Pie

Crisp crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino Romano, and olive oil.

$17.51

Large Classic Margherita Pie

Crisp crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino Romano, and olive oil.

$29.06

Garlic Knots (3 Pieces)

Crisp crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino Romano, and olive oil.

$3.49

Medium Classic Margherita Pie

Tomato, cucumber, red onion, carrots, croutons, mushrooms, candied walnuts, and red wine vinaigrette.

$27.22

C.P. La Manno's Have A Pizza

(600+)

$0 delivery fee • 3.3 mi • 40 min

"C.p. La Mannos has the best baked clams period . Not stuffed with all breading like most places. The white clam sauce is also # 1 . Not only do you get plenty of clams on the shell but tou also get a generous portion of clams on the pasta !"

"A Miller Place Landmark! Great food and house salad is a must! Pan Pizza is also the best you will find in this area. "

Round

Signature salad mixed greens, three beans, tomato, salami, and mozzarella.

$18.23

Large Pan

Zesty pink sauce.

$16.17

Garlic Knots (Dozen)

Signature salad mixed greens, three beans, tomato, salami, and mozzarella.

$6.61

Small C.P. La Manno's House Salad

Signature salad mixed greens, three beans, tomato, salami, and mozzarella.

$7.22

Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant

(50+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.9 mi • 40 min

$5 off on $40+

"Chicken Piccata was very good.Don't understand why they put red sauce on the Penne. The italian bread was soft and cheap and awful. Haven't tried the tiny salad yet."

Cafe Spiga Pizza And Restaurant

$0 delivery fee • 5.9 mi • 38 min

• Pizza • Salads

$7 off on $45+

"Linguini with white clam sauce is outstanding !!"

"The best thing about this meal was the garlic knots. The 4 stuffed mushrooms-not the 6 pictured - had mountain high stuffing that was almost all bread with hardly a speck of seafod. The marinara sauce was highly acidic and unpleasant. The lasagna, meatballs and ravioli were fine but the sauce really detracted from them. I was expecting better from this local restaurant."

Grandma

Fresh iceberg lettuce, mixed baby greens, roasted pepper, and tomato with fresh mozzarella, tossed in our balsamic vinaigrette dressing,.

$32.36

Caesar Salad

Crisp Romaine lettuce and croutons tossed in our special Caesar dressing.

$18.96

Garlic Knots

1/2 dozen.

$7.85

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Thin crusted pan pizza with San Marzano style tomato, fresh garlic, fresh basil, and mozzarella.

$16.02

Caruso's Pizzeria

$0 delivery fee • 12.2 mi • 56 min

(400+)

• Pizza • Seafood

"The best pizzeria on the East End, with 50 years experience. If you're really looking for a treat, order the sausage, pepper and onion hero, on thin crust hero bread, no tomato sauce and request the sausages to be whole, not sliced or cut up, like one would get at the street fairs. Copy and paste the above, and you'll get a better sausage hero than you'd find at San Gennaro in Little Italy."

"The meatball hero was outstanding, the meatballs truly taste homemade. The Caesar salad was fresh and delicious. I had ordered a similar meal the weekend before with a pizza. The pizza was gone in minutes. By accident my salad was left at store. When I called the woman I spoke to offered to replace it at a later date or fix it on my next DoorDash delivery. When the food you're purchasing, and the customer service is so wonderful it's easy to be a loyal customer. "

Cheese Pizza

Baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$17.59

Pizza

Pink cream sauce with onions.

$23.63

Mozzarella Sticks

Pink cream sauce with onions.

$10.02

Chicken Wings

Creamy butter sauce with parmigiano cheese.

$11.67

Cucina 25

(3k+)

$0 delivery fee • 13.1 mi • 52 min

"Classic cheese pizza was very good. Perfectly cooked crust, delicious sauce, good toppings. The Penne Florentine sauce was very very good."

" Meatball parm great. Greek salad also large and fresh. Guac was a little sparse. Green dressing not tasty. Greek dressing fine. Highly recommended. "

Classic cheese pizza

Romaine lettuce, croutons and parmesan cheese.

$21.51

Caesar Salad

golden fried chicken on toasted bread covered in fresh tomato sauce topped with melted mozzarella

$10.16

Garlic Bread with Mozzarella

Served with marinara sauce.

$5.34

Chicken Parm hero

Mixed greens, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, kalamata olives, onions, pepperoncini and feta cheese.

$12.26

Vincenzo’s Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 4.4 mi • 37 min

"I LOVE this place! The nicest people work here! The food is delicious! Best pizza in town! I've never had a bad meal here. Thanks Vincenzos !"

"I don't even know what to say about it ... under cooked, floppy and oily. The sad part is they use quality ingredients, the sauce is delicious.... the pizza making process and cooking time...... thumbs down. Time to teach the staff how to make a proper pizza pie. I wish I could upload a video, that would show the real deal."

Regular Slice

Tomato sauce & cheese.

$4.22

Penne Alla Vodka

Penne with our traditional vodka sauce with prosciutto.

$22.29

House Breadsticks

Homemade focaccia with our house sauce & Italian herbs.

$9.19

Calzone

Stuffed with mozzarella cheese & ricotta cheese.

$13.81

Bellissimo Pizzeria

$0 delivery fee • 4.6 mi • 34 min

(10+)

• Italian • American

"Great value! Will order again!"

Napolitano

Large 18" traditional hand- tossed pizza.

$24.55

Calzones

With mozzarella & ricotta toppings.

$10.29

Everything

Meatball, sausage, pepperoni, onions, peppers, mushrooms & extra cheese.

$30

Zara's Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 8.9 mi • 50 min

• Takeout • Italian

$5 off on $35+

"I stopped getting pizza anywhere else bc its not worth the headache. Zaras is on point and perfect EVERY SINGLE TIME. I make all types of crazy requests and they never miss a beat. Its not just the pizza either. All of their food is delicious. If im going to try a dish for the first time and I want to know that its going to be made well and correctly, ill get it through Zaras. Fried food for apps also come perfect. I only order delivery and I can get zucchini sticks or Mac and cheese bites etc and itll show up hot and crunchy! And mind you I do not live around the corner this is going from selden to port jeff area during dinner time. Enough said. Love love love this place! (Pic added is of one of my crazy requests. Just look at the abundance of toppings! its superb, i order this regularly) But you 100% get what you pay for AND THEN SOME! Btw this is just their medium pizza... it weighs as much as i do. "

"We love this place!!! Always consistently delicious and fresh!! They accommodate any request we have had and are very friendly. This is the go to spot for pizza!!! "

X-Large 18" Pizza

Add toppings for an additional charge.

$20.99

Medium 12" Pizza

Add toppings for an additional charge.

$16.05

Garlic Knots (Side Orders)

Rolled baked garlic bread.

$4.75

Fried Mozzarella Sticks (6)

Vodka, Mushroom & Onions in a Pink Sauce.

$10.03

Amici Restaurant

$0 delivery fee • 6.4 mi • 37 min

• Takeout • Italian

"We adore Amici. Consistently excellent food, timely delivery and good value. The Caesar salad is superb--fresh, crisp lettuce, homemade dressing and croutons, and Parmesan crisp. We love the plump, well-seasoned grilled shrimp added on. The Chicken Parmigiana is the best around. We get at least a big dinner and a nice lunch leftover out of an order. "

"You cannot go wrong with Amici's they have the best food... try the Lobster bisque it chock full of real lobster meat... their shrimp parm is to die for fresh cooked shrimp never frozen... veal parm you can cut with a fork...everything is Delicious..."

Chicken Alla Vodka

Grilled or fried chicken, pink sauce over penne

$26.42

Caesar Salad

Romaine, croutons, parmesan crisp & our housemade caesar dressing

$13.57

Chicken Parmigiana

with spaghetti & san marzano tomato sauce

$27.04

Via Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 10.3 mi • 49 min

• Pizza

"The food was delicious, well seasoned, and had great portions! We got the Pasta Alla Vodka with Angel hair and tortellini"

"Okay, it wasn't bad, but it wasnt good, either. Stuffed Meat Slice was just a slice of meat pizza with some pizza dough folded over the top. It tasted fine, but if I were trying to have a friend from out of town try stuffed pizza, this would be a terrible representation. Buffalo Chicken Slice was fine, very dry, chicken was suuuuper dry. The Caesar Salad with grilled chicken was also fine, but for almost $20, a terrible value. The dressing didn't taste like Caesar, it had no Parmesan that I could taste or see, and it was really bland, which for real caesar is pretty hard to accomplish. There was a generous amount of grilled chicken ontop, but it was also extremely dry and had little to no flavor. Overall edible, but worth about half what I paid for it and not what I expected quality-wise. "

Large Cheese Pizza

18 inch Pizza

$20.09

6 Garlic Knots

14 inch Pizza

$3.58

Regular Slice

Mozzarella cheese that has been coated and fried.

$3.71

Small Cheese Pizza

Tube shaped pasta. tomato and vodka pasta sauce.

$16.3

Alanza Pizza by Wonder

Italian • Pizzeria

$0 delivery fee • 8.2 mi • 44 min

$5 off on $20+

Pepperoni Pizza

Marinara and mozzarella are topped with crisp pepperoni cups in Alanza's version of the classic favorite. 12" pie - 6 slices

$11.55

Vodka Pizza

A spin on a classic cheese pie, this version replaces marinara with creamy, mildly spicy tomato vodka sauce. Finished with mozzarella, shaved Parmesan, and basil. 12" pie - 6 slices

$10.95

Cheese Pizza

Topped with rich marinara and creamy mozzarella, this simple and delicious pizza is the starting point for all of Alanza's classic red sauce pies. 12" pie - 6 slices

$10.95

Parmesan Mozzarella Sticks

Mozzarella sticks are fried until crispy, then sprinkled with grated Parmesan cheese. Served with a side of our vodka sauce for dipping. 4 per order

$9.75

Pizza Corner

$0 delivery fee • 10.1 mi • 47 min

(20+)

• Italian • Calzones

Cheese Pie (Large 16") (8 Slices)

6 Pieces

$22.84

Cheese Pie (Personal 12")

6 Pieces

$15.03

Garlic Knots

Add Garlic Chicken for an additional charge

$5.47

Mozzarella Sticks

Grilled chicken topped with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and sliced tomato on panini bread.

$8.94

Medford Pastaria

4.4

(4k+)

$0 delivery fee • 9.9 mi • 44 min

"Great pizza as always. Was a nice crispy crust that hits the spot. Sauce is perfect. Cannolies are excellent. And massive. Def not cheating out on the filling. I typically get the rainbowcake That too is amazing. I will be getting both next time. lol eat the cake tomorrow, cannoli night of pizza. Best place around by far. "

"The Fried Calamari and the Pear Salad are delightful. The Fried Calamari is crispy, not very oily, and has substance. Topping it off with lemon makes it pop. The sauce is robust, sits on the tongue well, and is juicy without being very acidic at all. I wish there was a way to order or include more. The Pear Salad is fresh and balanced. The pears taste like Christmas, the candied walnuts are fun, and the lettuce and gorgonzola are crisp and fresh. The dressing is great but not necessary with all the above elements. It is a personal choice. Portions are great. My partner and I are were able to split both items and have leftovers for the day after. Note: you may want to either air fry or stick the Fried Calamari in the oven to reheat so it doesn't get soggy."

18" Large Pizza

Breaded chicken tomato sauce and cheese sandwich.

$27.91

Alla Vodka Sauce

Add a side of sauce for additional fees.

$25.48

Garlic Knots 6

Smooth tube shaped pasta.

$6.58

Chicken Parmigiana Entree

A long sandwich on a roll. add-ons for an additional charge.

$27.57

La Vespa

$0 delivery fee • 8.8 mi • 48 min

"I had to make a last min order for some and thank goodness the people who were working! Order was delivered before time. I only wish I could have tipped Semintra more, such a doll, TY:) Vespa is my fam fav. For a few reasons. Quality and consistency Parted with kindness. Love this. The GF pizza is amazing too, fellow celiacs. God bless"

"This is the 6th time we've ordered from them, and it's been perfect every time. We have had the plain cheese Cheese Pizza (Pie), the Sicilian pie, and the broccoli rabe and sausage rigatoni. Our new favorite place."

Cheese Pizza (Pie)

6 per order.

$22.93

Cheese slice

A pink creamy meat sauce simmered with vodka.

$4.01

Mozzarella Sticks

Breaded chicken bites in sweet n' spicy sauce.

$11.26

6 Knots

12 per order, served hot or plain.

$5.07

Detroit Brick Pizza Co. by Wonder

Italian • American

$0 delivery fee • 8.2 mi • 43 min

$5 off on $20+

Classic Red Top Pizza

A classic cheese pizza in our signature Detroit style. A blend of melted cheeses on a fluffy dough with a frico crust—cheese crisped to an irresistible, lacy crunch. Topped with red sauce

$16.95

Spicy Pepperoni Pizza

A kick of spicy Calabrian chile flakes added to crispy pepperoni cups and a blend of cheeses, all on a fluffy dough with a frico crust—cheese crisped to an irresistible, lacy crunch. Topped with red sauce

$19.14

Meat Lovers Pizza

Crispy pepperoni cups, crumbled sausage, smoky bacon, and a blend of melted cheeses on a fluffy dough with a frico crust—cheese crisped to an irresistible, lacy crunch. Topped with red sauce

$21.35

Cheesy Garlic Bread

Herb butter and a blend of melted cheeses on fluffy dough with a frico crust—cheese crisped to an irresistible, lacy crunch. Served with a side of warm red sauce for dipping

$15.95

Pennachio's

$0 delivery fee • 8.5 mi • 51 min

• Pizza • Italian

"The best food and Hero I ever had !!!!!!!"

"Consistently good pizza prepared fast. Comfortable dining in, and my favorite for pick-up or delivery"

Regular Cheese Pizza

18". Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$19.25

Chicken Wings

Six pieces. Homemade chicken wings with your choice of plain, buffalo or BBQ sauce served with blue cheese and a side of celery.

$13.01

Sicilian Cheese Pizza

18". Square-shaped, thick crust pizza with mozzarella and red sauce.

$23.56

Spaghetti with Meatballs

Spaghetti topped with three of our homemade meatballs and topped in a delicious red sauce.

$18.25

Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

$0 delivery fee • 13.4 mi • 59 min

(4k+)

• Pizzeria • Italian

"First time try the pepperoni pinwheel, it was delicious and so filling that I will have to save the pasta for later. Even though I did not order it this time around I would recommend their garden salad - it is one of the best I've ever had."

"Pizza was undercooked and inedible. The crust and sauce boundary tasted like gooey uncooked dough. Look at the photo the cheese didn't even melt entirely and you can still see the cheese grates"

Neapolitan Pie

Eighteen inches round, eight slices, cheese and tomato sauce.

$22.17

Garlic Knots (6)

Sixteen inches square, twelve slices thin crust pan pizza with mozzarella cheese and spotted tomato basil sauce.

$3.73

Neapolitan By The Slice

Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, red onion, black olives, house dressing

$3.28

Grandma Pie

Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, parmesan cheese, caesar dressing.

$26.32

South Paw Brewing Company

$0 delivery fee • 7.6 mi • 36 min

(300+)

• Pizza • Salads

"This place does not disappoint. At first it may appear pricey however the quality and generous portions make it feel absolutely justified!"

"$23 for a pizza that's actually just personal sized is.....a choice for sure. Didn't receive second drink either. Vodka sauce pizza was not only small but bland as well"

Classic Pizza

Mozzarella cheese, Tomato Sauce, Romano Cheese

$19.85

Wings

9 battered fried crispy wings tossed in your choice of sauce.

$19.25

NY Vodka Sauce Pizza

Fresh Mozzarella, Vodka Sauce, Basil, Romano Cheese

$23.82

Boneless Wings (12)

12 breaded chicken breast chunks fried and tossed in your choice of sauce.

$19.2

Mama Lisa Restaurant

$0 delivery fee • 11.0 mi • 43 min

(14k+)

• Pickup • Italian

"Literally everything from mama lisas is the best! I have never had a bad meal here! The chicken Marsala from here is the best one you will ever have. I get my Christmas Eve dinner catered from here too and all my guests love it! "

"I have eaten many times at Mama Lisa and it's good. Tonight I ordered Chicken Cacciatore and it was excellent. It may be the best thing I have ever had from there. Nice size portion, enough for 2 meals or to split. Would 100% order again. "

Pasta alla Vodka

Pink cream vodka sauce with prosciutto, peas and bits of onions. All pasta dinners served with freshly baked bread.

$20.29

Cheese Pizza | Neapolitan (slice)

With tomato sauce.

$3.8

Chicken Cutlet Hero w/ Tomato Sauce

Served with 4 oz. tomato sauce.

$12.24

Mozzarella Sticks

All soups served with some ditalini pasta and some bread.

$14.15

Setauket Pastaria

(700+)

$0 delivery fee • 9.3 mi • 48 min

"ALWAYS EXCELLENT EVERYTHING! BETTER THAN O SOLO MIO........ANYTIME.....NO COMPARISON!"

"We took advantage of the Buy One Get One with the Eggplant Rollatini. Huge portion, perfectly packaged along with delicious sesame seed rolls and butter. Will definitely order again."

16" Large Pizza

Toppings for an additional charge.

$23.57

Pasta with Vodka Sauce

Toppings for an additional charge.

$20.1

Create Your Own 12" Personal Pie

Served with mozzarella cheese and balsamic vinaigrette.

$15.02

Regular Pizza Slice

Served with Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing.

$4.57

Carlo's Pizza of Shirley

$0 delivery fee • 8.4 mi • 41 min

(5k+)

• Italian • Seafood

"My favorite things from here are the cheesy garlic bread and lentil soup, I could literally eat it forever. Their baked ziti pizza and baked ziti is great too. I haven't eaten something from here that I didn't like. Favorite pizza place by far."

"The Garlic Knots (Dozen) are SO good. also served with a beautiful side of sauce. The value for the Chic Cutlet Parmigiana with Pastaken is amazing. The food here is consistently delicious. If you're under the weather their Chicken Soup (Quart) is seasoned perfectly and is a healthy serving."

Neapolitan (Large)

W/ chicken.

$21.56

Garlic Knots (Dozen)

W/ chicken.

$5.97

Regular Slice

12 slices.

$3.69

Di Fara Pizza By Wonder

Italian • Pizzeria

$0 delivery fee • 8.2 mi • 41 min

$5 off on $20+

Regular Pizza

They call it the "Regular," but there's nothing regular about this pizza—housemade tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, Parmesan, and Di Fara's signature fresh basil

$21.69

Vodka Sauce Square Pizza

Di Fara's Original Square pizza with a twist: creamy vodka sauce tops the golden, fluffy, focaccia-like crust you know and love

$29.05

Pepperoni Pizza

The Di Fara classic "Regular" pizza, upgraded with the addition of crispy pepperoni

$24.15

Pepperoni, Sausage & Meatball Pizza

Heads up, meat lovers, this one's for you: crispy pepperoni, sweet Italian sausage, and juicy meatballs top Di Fara's "Regular" pizza

$27.08

Old Town Pizza

(800+)

$0 delivery fee • 8.3 mi • 50 min

"The 6 Garlic Parm Wings were a big surprise! Big pieces, juicy, and the particular mixture they use is really tasty. Cheese Pie (l) was great as always. Fr Calamari_Marinara was so-so. A little undercooked, maybe."

"The salad slice..lettuce nice and crisp, crust cooked to perfection and the sauce/dressing always delicious! "

Cheese Pie (l)

(6) battered mozzarella sticks served with tomato dipping sauce

$26.53

Meatball Parm Hero

Crispy cannoli shell filled to order with creamy cannoli cream and chocolate chips

$17

Chicken Parm Roll

crispy or grilled chicken, spicy vodka sauce, grilled pepperoni, mozzarella melt, sriracha honey

$11.77

Mozzarella Sticks

Fresh orecchiette pasta, chicken, broccoli, oven roasted tomato, artichoke, kalamata olive, and roasted garlic white wine sauce

$12.92

Port Jefferson Pizza & Gyro

4.2

(300+)

• Salads • Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 8.5 mi • 50 min

"Pasta not eatable could do better next"

"I've ordered this before and it was good. this time it was all bread, a couple of tiny pieces of chicken, no sauce and barely any cheese. it was disgusting"

Large Pizza

Bread, topped with garlic & olive oil or butter, herb seasoning, baked to perfection. Melts in your mouth and arouses the taste buds.

$17.04

Gyro with Fries

Tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$11.02

Garlic Knot

Tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$3.51

Chicken Fingers with French Fries

Lemon sauce.

$7.92

Selden Pizza

(800+)

$0 delivery fee • 9.7 mi • 47 min

"When my son first said he wanted to eat here I saw the rating on Google and didn't really want to. My son swore up and down this place was amazing and he is a big pizza fanatic so I reluctantly agreed to go ahead and give it a try. I will be the first to admit that I prejudged this place without actually reading the reviews and how long ago they were posted. It's been well over a year that we have been eating here (with the exception of my long time loyal son) and I can easily say that Selden Pizza is the best around here. As for today's order the Neapolitan Round Cheese Pie was perfectly cooked as per usual. Hot, cheesy, and the crust cooked perfectly. Selden Pizzas consistency is what keeps us loyal and coming back. It doesn't matter what time of day you order the pizza is always excellent. This is the first time we ordered the Chicken Fingers with Fries and I was a little nervous since small places like this tend to be hit or miss with this kind of meal especially when their specialty is pizzas and pastas. My daughter who can't eat dairy can be pretty picky so I wasn't sure how she would like the meal. Of course there was no reason to worry. The chicken fingers were really good. Hot, great taste, cooked perfectly and was portioned just right but what I was even more impressed with were the fries. Fries can easily go wrong and in my home everyone can be quite snobby. These were perfectly cooked. They were hot, seasoned tasty, and cooked absolutely perfect not burnt or soggy like some places and priced more than fair at $10 for fries and chicken fingers."

"This pizza is the real deal. Sauce is tangy and perfect. Cheese is perfectly cooked. Crust floppy but not wet and just a bit chewy. Like the perfect amount of chewy. And thats before I get high. Well done team Selden Pizza!"

Neapolitan Round Cheese Pie

Eighteen inches.

$22.93

Round Neapolitan Cheese Pizza Slice

Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Served with marinara sauce.

$3.44

Mozzarella Sticks

Thin Sicilian crust brushed with olive oil & garlic, fresh mozzarella, and spotted with chunky San Marzano tomato sauce.

$8.61

Grandma Pizza Slice

Crispy on the outside, yet light and fluffy on the inside. These mini Italian donut holes will become your new fave.

$3.72

Salvinos Pizza and Restaurant

$0 delivery fee • 9.1 mi • 51 min

(700+)

• Soup • Salad

"Half meatball half sausage, super fairly priced and literally scrumptious. 10/10 would order again and will"

"Best pizza on earth. Definitely recommend to everyone I know. Fresh mozzarella and handmade dough. More than enough to share in the large. Perfect pizza for anyone."

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$23.03

Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, and grated cheese.

$11.9

Homemade Mozzarella Sticks

Deep-fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside.

$10.4

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero

Chicken hero with marinara sauce and parmesan cheese.

$14

Tony's Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 11.0 mi • 47 min

• Pizza • Salads

"Tony's Pizza never disappoints! When you're working from home and need a comforting lunch, this colossal ham and cheese calzone surely hits the spot! High recommend!"

"I love Tony's pizzeria. I've been looking forever for a place that puts enough lemon on their chicken Francese entree and chicken Francese pizza and with Tony's pizza I've found it! Sounds simple but try finding a place that knows how to make a proper chicken Francese entree and Francese pizza like Tony's does!"

Pan Pizza (Deep Dish)

Thin sicilian crust topped with mozzarella cheese a chunky tomato sauce and fresh garlic.

$24.09

Garlic Knots

Bread herb seasoning baked to perfection. melts in your mouth and arouses the taste buds.

$4.9

Cheese Stuffed Garlic Knots (6)

Served with a side of marinara sauce.

$9.14

Grandma Pizza

Substitute garlic bread for an additional charge.

$22.85

Luigi's Pizzeria & Restaurant (East Setauket)

$0 delivery fee • 10.6 mi • 40 min

$5 off on $25+

"The food is always hot and good. The Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza was still steaming hot and had plenty of quality toppings without being soggy. The Chicken Tenders are also crispy and tasty cooked in fresh oil. Luigi's is expensive but worth it."

"We are a huge fan of their 16" - Large Vegan Pizza. Their crust tastes great, and they put the right amount of cheese on it and make it bubbly. I also enjoy their hot sandwiches, the Chicken Francese parm hero is my favorite."

Large Cheese Pizza

16" Pie Baked With Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!

$26.89

Garlic Knots

Tossed with Garlic, Oil, Parmesan Cheese & Fresh Parsley. Melted Mozzarella Available

$5.07

12" - Medium Cheese Pizza

12" Pie Baked With Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!

$19.84

Small Cheese Pizza

10" Pie Baked With Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!

$15.11

Middle Island Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 5.8 mi • 40 min

(900+)

• Chicken • Seafood

"Good portion sizes, packaged up nicely, and fresh. The tomato sauce in the Side of Pasta is chunky and flavorful, the Chicken Parmigiana with vodka sauce added was delicious too. Salad is nice presentation even when to go, added chicken which was a nice portion "

"Omg it came hot and fresh ! Pizza was amazing they even brushed the crust with garlic knot spread for me ! Best Sicilian pizza I ever had ! 10/10 stars ! Top notch better than every place around them for miles ! "

Big Italy Pizzeria

(40+)

$0 delivery fee • 9.4 mi • 96 min

"The pies we ordered for the office were great! I personally enjoyed the Sicilian. Would definitely order again. The staff were friendly at pickup and even loaded the pies into my car."

"Was unusually disappointed with this evenings order. First time ordering the sampler pie which is made from remaining slices of other pies, in this case plain, chicken bacon ranch and white pizza.The chicken marsala had an off flavor tasting like more of a watery tomato type sauce and certainly not a marsala flavor sauce... Will write this off as a bad night but at $60+ for this order, will watching carefully at future orders."

Large Cheese Pie

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, ginger ale, grape, cream, root beer, lemonade, iced teas, espresso, regular water, cherry, raspberry.

$24.25

Pie Sampler

Chopped prosciutto, in a pink cream sauce. Add chicken and shrimp for an additional charge.

$22.02

Penne alla Vodka

Lettuce, croutons, Parmesan cheese.

$24.08

Sicilian Pie

Lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, olives, feta cheese, and grape leaves.

$28

Taco Bell

4.3

$0 delivery fee • 4.5 mi • 28 min

• Mexican • Fast Food

"Chips were super soggy and there were missing toppings. Everything was just piled together and didn't taste the way it was supposed to. My husband and I are super disappointed. It was pretty expensive for such poor quality. Really weird since Taco Bell usually delivers the same experience every time."

"ridge tacobell is lazy, they miss constantly their ingredients don't taste as good aretires I have received tomatoes that were bad. i have yet to ever receive sauce when putting it in m order, and that kind of kills the whole experiene for me."

Crunchwrap Supreme®

A warm flour tortilla filled with seasoned beef, warm Nacho Cheese sauce, a crispy tostada shell, lettuce, diced tomatoes, and reduced-fat sour cream folded into our signature Crunchwrap form and grilled to go (530 cal.)

$7.9

MTN DEW® Baja Blast®

The exhilarating taste of DEW® and a blast of tropical lime flavor. Small MTN DEW® Baja Blast® (220 cal.) Medium MTN DEW® Baja Blast® (280 cal.) Large MTN DEW® Baja Blast® (420 cal.)

$3.5

Chicken Quesadilla

A large flour tortilla filled with a blend of mozzarella, pepperjack, and cheddar cheeses, grilled, marinated all-white-meat chicken, Creamy Jalapeño sauce, and grilled to perfection. (500 cal.)

$7.54

Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria

$0 delivery fee • 10.1 mi • 57 min

• Pickup • Pizza

"The Neapolitan Round Pizza (18") and Mozzarella Sticks NEVER FAIL. The food is always hot and delicious each time we order. We order out at least once a week and Goomba Johnnys is our go to when we do. The staff is always nice and helpful, service is quick and efficient, and the food quality and taste is incredible every time. The ham and cheese calzone is my all time favorite! The portion is huge that I have enough for lunch for work the next day. Definitely recommend Gomba Johnny's."

"Great service by the dudes at the counter. Amazing delivery personnel. Great cooks. Great management and all around place to order food. Great catering prices."

Neapolitan Round Pizza (18")

Fried chicken cutlets, fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce on garlic bread.

$23.71

The Goomba Hero

1/2 doz

$15.35

Garlic Knots

12 piece

$8.68

Mozzarella Sticks

Parmigiana cheese, cream, vodka, and sundried tomatoes with a touch of tomato sauce.

$12.26

Brooklyn Boys Pizza Company

3.8

(70+)

• Food Trucks • Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 8.4 mi • 46 min

Traditional Deep Dish Cheese Pizza

Choice of dressing.

$21.15

Escarole with White Beans in Garlic & Olive Oil

Sliced beef and lamb with spices

$12.99

Caffe Amici