Order the best Pizza near West Islip, NY
Best Pizza Restaurants Nearby in West Islip
The Pizzeria
4.7
(800+)$0 delivery fee • 0.9 mi • 53 min
"Arancini is my favorite! Ive been ordering it every week"
"Lovely restaurant interior, plenty of sitting and bar inside. I couldn't decide which slice to go for and a restaurant staff member went out of his way to prepare me two of my top choices. Both came out wonderfully. Slices are larger than normal pizza slices, sauce and toppings were not low quality. Fresh and crispy. I highly recommend The Pizzeria in Babylon"
Large Pie
Traditional new york style slice
$25.24
Regular Slice
No Order is Complete Without Them
$4.04
Garlic Knots
Traditional ny style sicilian slice
$4.38
Sicilian Slice
Marinated chicken, mozzarella cheese and drizzle of our homemade buffalo sauce
$4.24
Crispinos Pizza
4.7
(300+)$0 delivery fee • 300 ft • 30 min
"First time ordering and the pizza was delicious! Regular slice tastes like old school! Awesome! Bbq chicken slice just the right size and good. Bacon Chicken Ranch Slice good as well. The only weird thing is the door dash driver who called asking where to drop it off saying he couldn't speak English so that was fun "
"This was probably the most amazing rice ball I have ever had It was HUGE and lasted 3 meals. I will definitely be ordering again!!"
Chicken Roll
Chicken, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese.
$10.36
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with marinara sauce. 8 pcs.
$10.95
Pepperoni Pinwheel
Pepperoni, mozzarella cheese.
$4.34
Grandma Pie
Square thin crust pie. Shredded mozzarella with a garlic plum tomato sauce.
$23.9
Our Little Italy
4.6
(6k+)$0 delivery fee • 0.7 mi • 27 min
"Pepperoni on the Hot Honey Pepperoni Slice (7/10) made the slice so much better. Garlic Knots (Dozen) (7/10) were delicious and the Trio Slice was amazing (8.7/10) the mix of the sauces work well together. The Trio Slice is also a thicker than the Hot Honey Pepperoni Slice ."
"I have been to SO many different Italian restaurant's but this one really takes the cake. The Pasta Alla Vodka was cooked perfectly and I asked for a lot of mozzarella and THEY DELIVERED!! 110% only spending my money here! Thank you!!"
Regular Pie
A classic Italian pizza topped with mozzarella cheese and pizza sauce.
$21.01
Regular Slice
Mozzarella and pizza sauce on a regular crust
$3.65
Garlic Knots (Dozen)
Garlic knots mixed with grated cheese, garlic and oil
$5.54
Pinwheels
Pinwheels with choice of toppings: pepperoni, spinach, or mac and cheese.
$2.75
Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.7
(7k+)$0 delivery fee • 2.8 mi • 44 min
"I love this restaurant, their prices are amazing and the Vodka sauce is absolutely delicious especially with the fried chicken added to it. The Rice Ball is huge and crispy filled with cheesy meat stuffing "
"The sausage pepper roll was soggy and oily, and barely had any sausage and the chicken Caesar salad had so much salad dressing on it. It was uneditable.
I don't think I would order from your restaurant again unfortunately this is the second time that my food was not edible"
Regular Pie
With tomato and mozzarella.
$24.76
Garlic Knots
20 oz Soda
$5.54
Regular Slice
Green salad with caesar dressing and cheese.
$4.38
Sicilian Slice
Crispy dough filled with seasoned chicken and melted cheese, and tomato sauce
$4.48
Domino's
4.6
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 0.9 mi • 49 min
Build Your Own Pizza
A custom pizza made to order. Choose from any of our delicious crust styles, including Handmade Pan.
$16.16
Stuffed Cheesy Bread
Our 8-piece oven-baked breadsticks are generously stuffed and covered with a blend of 100% real mozzarella and cheddar cheeses then seasoned with a touch of garlic.
$10.88
Wisconsin 6-Cheese
Feta, provolone, cheddar, Parmesan-Asiago, cheese made with 100% real mozzarella and sprinkled with oregano.
$20.73
Ultimate Pepperoni
Two layers of pepperoni sandwiched between provolone, Parmesan-Asiago and cheese made with 100% real mozzarella then sprinkled with oregano.
$20.07
Pizzaiola
4.6
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 39 min
"I love their Sicilian pizza. I ordered it well done and it came well done.
My only complaint is, they could've put more sausage on the pie."
"Food is delicious and arrives as ordered We order our pizza lightly toasted and that is exactly how it is cooked. In the past places we order the pie comes well done to burned bottoms. The stuffed artichokes are wonderful a meal by themselves !!! It is a delight to receive delicious food exactly as you ordered complete orders with nothing missing. Delivery is fast we are very happy."
Neopolitan Slice
Traditional crust with mozzarella & tomato sauce.
$4.79
Neapolitan Pie
18' round crust pizza with mozzarella & tomato sauce.
$26.92
Garlic Knots (6 per order)
Baked dough knots marinated with fresh garlic, olive oil, grated cheese & seasonings.
$4.84
Buffalo Slice
Traditional crust pizza with mozzarella, mildly spicy buffalo chicken pieces, topped with our homemade bleu cheese dressing.
$6.48
Bella cucina
4.7
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 0.7 mi • 26 min
"This is my first time buying from here and I WILL be ordering again. The food us extremely good but I had to give it 4stars because of some hiccups but not based on taste!. The Baked Stuffed Shells tasted amazing honestly like really REALLY GOOD, I personally got mine with shirmp but what I wasn't expecting was for the shells to still be on the shrimp.. the food is covered in sauce I wasn't expecting the shells in a stuff shell dish, that doesn't really make sense ti me and it was an inconvenience but very tasty.
And for the Neapolitan Pizza Slice I was expecting it to come with everything as advertised and i selected to have EXTRA olives and sausage , but whn the pizza arrived it was ONLY olives and sausage. Not what I was expecting and I payed extra for that.
Food is delicious though"
"Foods delicious. Added fresh mozzarella to the mental Meatball Parmigiana Hero. Got pepperoni and meatballs on the Two Toppings Neapolitan Pizza Slice. Food was delivered quick and hot!"
Neapolitan Cheese Pizza
Mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce.
$21.53
Sicilian Pizza Slice
Mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce.
$3.45
Homemade Italian Style Meatballs
Creamy pink vodka sauce sautéed with imported diced prosciutto.
$8.56
Penne Alla Vodka
A combination of sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, peppers, fresh mushrooms, onions, black olives and extra cheese.
$20.05
Pizza Hut
4.2
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 3.9 mi • 41 min
"Wish whoever seasoned these Straight Cut Fries seasoned them evenly instead of just dumping the stuff in the middle
Boneless Wings are amazing tho"
"Pizza and wings were overcooked"
Personal Pan Pizza®
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$8.34
Breadsticks
Nobody does breadsticks like the Hut. Crispy-on-the-outside, soft-on-the-inside, and seasoned with garlic and parmesan, they're perfect with pizza or pasta. Comes with a cup of our delicious marinara!
$9.21
Create Your Own Pizza
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$24.48
Ultimate Hut Bundle
Customize your choice of ANY 2 Medium pizzas on ANY crust with ANY recipe; ANY breadsticks, cheese sticks, or cinnamon sticks; 8 boneless wings & ANY 2 dips. Prices, participation, and availability may vary. Exclusions apply.
$32.02
Gino's Pizzeria
4.4
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 28 min
$8 off on $55+
"Best Pizza, we just moved here from Brooklyn Absolutely delish from money and taste!!! Plus the zeppolies to die for, wish weren't that good lol"
"Gino's Pizzeria never disappoints! I honestly think they make the best pizza around. Their 6 Pieces Zeppoli are so big, soft, and not overly sweet. They're simply delicious and great for sharing."
Regular Slice
6 pieces
$5.01
18" Regular Pie
Crisp romaine lettuce, house made croutons, and grated pecorino Romano cheese
$29
10" Regular Pie
Crisp romaine lettuce, house made croutons, and grated pecorino Romano cheese
$16.47
14" Regular Pie
Made fresh to order
$22.4
Cafe Gio
4.5
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 1.9 mi • 30 min
"The food was absolutely delicious but the photos they posted were completely different. It looked as if it was a ball of burrata but completely wrong when you receive it it's just a piece. The whole purpose was to get the pasta with the burrata but when you get the pasta it's a piece of fresh mozzarella. Food is delicious.
."
"the Zeppole had little to zero powdered sugar and the Garlic Knots had no Garlic Knots, the cheese pie was okay. The food use to be fantastic not it is hit or miss and the price has increased, but the quality should have been consistent"
18" Cheese Pie
6 pieces.
$24.1
Garlic Knots
Crispy chicken cutlets in a pink cream sauce topped with burrata.
$3.58
Stuffed Rigatoni Grimaldi
Rigatoni flambéed with vodka, tomato, bolognese, onions and scallions in a creamy Parmesan sauce.
$27.96
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Stuffed with bolognese meat sauce.
$24.56
Papa Johns Pizza
4.6
(3k+)$0 delivery fee • 3.8 mi • 34 min
"Like how there's no extra charge for the garlic dipping sauce that's included with the epic stuffed crust pizza..garlic knots cooked perfectly, everything delicious & fresh tasting "
"As a carnivore diet person, I broke my diet today ( I've been on it for a year) . I have to say it was sooo worth it. the Garlic Parmesan Boneless Wings were on point. the Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites were to die for. Everything was delicious. highly recommend"
Cheese Pizza
Simple, yet simply delicious. Real cheese made from mozzarella on top of our signature pizza sauce with your choice of crust, then baked to a golden brown. It has just what you want, and nothing you don’t.
$15.92
Cheesesticks
Original fresh dough covered with Special Garlic sauce, topped with mounds of real cheese made from mozzarella, then baked to a cheesy, gooey goodness. Served with original pizza sauce for dipping!
$8.44
Pepperoni Pizza
Your choice of crust covered with our signature pizza sauce, real cheese made from mozzarella, and pepperoni. With a pepperoni in almost every bite, it's one of our most popular pizzas.
$16.14
Create Your Own Pizza
Build your own custom pizza and we'll handcraft it for you. With so many delicious options to choose from, your masterpiece is waiting!
$17.34
Angela’s Pizza
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 5.6 mi • 37 min
"Tried this place after hearing about the angry Italian pie. Had The Hangry Hero and it was incredible. Crispy thin cutlets, excellent sauce and really good garlic bread. Would 10/10 recommend trying that hero. Also ordered a Buffalo Chicken Slice and it was huge/tasty. Buffalo sauce wasn't dried out like other pizza places. "
"Every single pizza I've tried from this place has been amazing and they take care of special requests very well! An amazing price for a BIG Regular Slice. Definitely my new favorite go to spot for pizza."
Large Pie
Large Cheese Pie
$21.5
Regular Slice
Charred Pepperoni over Vodka Sauce with Hot Honey Drizzle
$3.99
1/2 Dozen Knots
TELL FLAVOR IN COMMENTS.
--> BUFFALO, SWEET CHILI, CHIPOTLE, GARLIC PARM, BBQ, SICILIAN
$4
Hot Honey Slice
Medium pie : size 14’
$4.84
Mulberry Street of Babylon
4.7
(500+)$0 delivery fee • 1.1 mi • 31 min
"Food is great. Grilled Small House Salad With Chicken was flavorful and big portion for the price. Pizza was just excellent. Very happy they had Beef Pepproni for non pork eaters. Thats a game changer for me."
"Huge portion , best chicken parm in Long Island
Always fresh salad and definitely the best buffalo chicken pizza"
Large Round Cheese
egg battered, zesty lemon, white wine, butter
$25.17
6 Garlic Knots
Deep dish, has Fried Chicken and Bacon
$4.45
Vodka Grandma Slice
Bacon, chicken, mozzarella, ranch dressing
$5.68
Chicken Francaise
sicilian marsala wine sauce, mushrooms
$36.04
Alfredos Pizza
4.7
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 2.3 mi • 36 min
"White Pizza is Delicious Every time!!! Especially when you order it Well Done. They actually always read and follow the preferences you choose for your food. Bonus they always deliver your food pretty quickly or at least before the expected time. Thank You Alfredos for your great food and customer service!!!!"
"Im addicted to all the food they make. Always fresh, delicious!!!"
Cheese Pizza
Our classic regular pizza
$20.32
Garlic Knots
Penne pasta in an ala vodka sauce.
$3.69
Penne ala Vodka
Homemade Mozzarella served with Sauce on the Side.
$16.82
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken, sauce, & mozzarella wrapped in dough.
$8.58
Villa Pizza
4.7
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 3.7 mi • 39 min
"Small Chicken Caesar Salad was packed to the brim and the chicken really juicy and not dry. They also gave a side of parmesan cheese. The Chicken Vodka Parmigiana Hero was packed well and really good. The Meatballs were really flavor and melted in to your mouth. Would get again "
"Excellent! Shrimp Scampi is great. Shrimp is extremely good. you can take every ingredient in the Scampi. one of the best I have had.
Baked Ziti is equally excellent."
18" Extra Large Cheese Pie
Six pieces. With side of sauce.
$24.51
Garlic Knots
Served in a pink, cream sauce.
$3.6
10" Small Cheese Pizza
Romaine, seasoned croutons and Parmesan.
$15.46
Penne Ala Vodka
Six pieces.
$17.66
Francescos Pizza & Restaurant
Italian • Pizzeria
$0 delivery fee • 0.7 mi • 44 min
"Best Fettuccini Alfredo with Broccoli I've had in like 20 years! I'll be back thank thank you!"
"Food was terrible. Would never order from them again"
Reg Pie
16" Regular Cheese Pie, Non Bleached, Non Brominated King Auther Flour, Grande Mozzarella and the finest California Tomatoes.
$22.54
20 oz
chicken simmered in a marsala wine sauce with mushrooms
$3.34
Alla Vodka
Carmelized walnuts, cran raisins, and crubmbled gorgonzola cheese tossed with lettuce in our house rasberry vinaigrette
$28.37
Chicken Marsala
seasonal fluke or flounder egg battered and sauteed in a lemon, white chardonnay sauce
$27.89
Vinnies Mulberry Street
4.8
(40+)$0 delivery fee • 2.4 mi • 33 min
Large Pie 18" (8 Slices)
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
$28.99
House Salad
Breaded chicken cutlet, baked in tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella.
$17.91
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Homemade vodka sauce with prosciutto and onion.
$31.97
Penne Alla Vodka
Prosciutto, onions and broccoli, sautéed in a pink cream sauce.
$27.3
Albert’s Pizza
4.5
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 1.9 mi • 29 min
"The girl at Alberts (I forgot her name) always goes above n beyond for us and called to make sure our order was correct and good!
Very happy food was delishhhh "
"Do not order their Alfredo pasta. It's watered down and the pasta was pretty dry . It was pretty much all at the bottom and even then the sauce wasn't good at all . Feel like I got what I paid for cause it's cheaper than some restaurants. "
Albert's Sicilian Pizza
Square pie: 10 slices. Cheese under the tomato sauce with a touch of grated Romano cheese and oregano
$26.12
Neapolitan Pizza
18" cheese pizza
$26.42
Mamma Santina Pizza
4.5
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 45 min
"The Grilled Salmon is so delicious with cannelini beans and spinach. "
"I have been going here since 1989 when it was Frank's. The Sicilian is right off the boat. The new renovation is spectacular, and it is unbelievably busy. Yet somehow, the service is always the best. Family owned and operated. Top notch."
Meatball Parmigiana Hero - Heroes
Romaine, toasted bacon bits, tomatoes, corn, red onion, dried cranberries, provolone strips, croutons, and ranch on the side.
$22.22
Country Salad - Salads
Whole littleneck clams broiled with seasoned breadcrumbs.
$28.54
Baked Clams Oreganata - Appetizers
Sautéed with garlic, butter, white wine sauce and topped with toasted breadcrumbs,
$22.5
Mama's Brick Oven Pizzeria
4.5
(90+)$0 delivery fee • 3.1 mi • 35 min
"Always great service and food from Mamas "
"First time ordering. The brick oven pizza was delicious. "
Large Cheese Pizza
18" (8 slices). Crispy round pie, topped with fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese.
$21.91
Brick Oven Pizza
Round 18'' (8 slices). Extra thin crust, layered with fresh mozzarella cheese with our flavorful tomato sauce and basil.
$26.72
Chicken Wings
5 or 10 pieces
$13.28
Side of Penne with Vodka Sauce
Our classic light cream sauce.
$11.79
Miceli Brothers Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.3
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 3.1 mi • 41 min
"Delicious food and great quality!
The Side of Meatballs are so flavorful they
literally melt in your mouth.
The Spinach Pinwheel is my absolute obsession. The only pizzeria I'll use for delivery. They never miss!"
"The Regula Cheese Pizza Personal 10"r is the best when youre craving two different kinds of pizza but dont want to buy two full pies. Every came to me fresh and hot like the Garlic Knots (6 Pieces) and Zeppoles (6) not stale or hard super fluffy soft and flavorful WILL BUY AGAIN"
Regular Cheese Pizza Round 18"
Le
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$25.56
Cheese Pizza Slice
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$3.6
Pepperoni Garlic Knots
Sauteed prosciutto, onions in a creamy pink sauce.
$5.13
Garlic Knots (6 Pieces)
Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.
$5.04
Little Caesars
4.4
(700+)$0 delivery fee • 7.6 mi • 51 min
"Custom Stuffed Crust amazing with the Caesar Dip® 🍕🔥🔥🔥🥳"
"I am addicted to these little pizza bubbles
They are filled with pepperoni, buttery and so delicious
I highly recommend them
The next time I will take a picture before I devour them "
ExtraMostBestest® Pepperoni
Large round pizza with more Pepperoni and Cheese than our Classic Pizza
$12.05
Custom Stuffed Crust
Large stuffed crust pizza with toppings of your choice
$17.77
ExtraMostBestest® Cheese
Large round pizza with more Cheese than our Classic Pizza
$12.05
Italian Cheese Bread
Ten pieces of freshly baked bread with a crispy edge, covered with cheese and topped with Italian spices (1340 Cal)
$7.46
The Pie at Salvatore's
4.8
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 3.4 mi • 36 min
"It was amazing, first time I tried and I gotta tell you it was outstanding, the flavor on point, the portion size and also the way they baked it was very very soft and yummy ( definitely a must try if you live in bayshore or around the area trust me you'll get your money's worth and be satisfied)"
"my favorite overall pizza spot in the bay shore islip area. One of my favorite pizza spots in ny in general. Original Neapolitan Pizza (Large) and Supreme Pizza (Large) are awesome. This is not a classic slice joint - you have to order whole pies here. With that said, you can order small or medium pies if you wish."
Original Neapolitan Pizza (Large)
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & Basil.
$28.63
Original Neapolitan Pizza (Small)
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & Basil.
$13.89
Original Neapolitan Pizza (Medium)
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & Basil.
$26.78
Caesar Salad (Small)
Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese, homemade Caeser Dressing
$11.45
Dominick's Pizza & Pasta
4.4
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 4.4 mi • 42 min
20% off, up to $5
"Rice Ball Parmigiana Huge and baked, cut in half topped with that marinara n mozz!! whole meal by itself!!Fried Mozzarella Sticks Good all the time! hot and just a app we enjoy ! Eggplant Roll Eggplant fried thin and breaded nicely. Crust wrap is crispy and soft. Extra cup of sauce added the needed kick. Eggplant fans skip the hero for this here and there. @ person size,"
"I LOVEEEE this pizza place. Something about the crust and sauce is incredible. Cheapest whole pie you can buy for family on nights you don't feel like cooking. Ugh. So so yummy. This is true Long Island pizza. Fresh sauce, cheap cheese, crispy crust."
18” Large Cheese Pie
Prosciutto sautéed in a creamy pink sauce.
$21.28
Hand Tossed Personal Pizza
Breaded breast of chicken topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$13.31
Garlic Knots
Romaine, croutons, parmesan cheese.
$3.98
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
Penne pasta with ricotta, mozzarella & our delicious tomato sauce.
$10.49
Blaze Pizza
4.3
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 3.8 mi • 37 min
"very good I should have added more stuff on ny pizza the cheasey bread is very good also all of it was very fulfilling."
"Ordered red-vine pizza to have fresh Mozzarella plus shredded mozzarella . There was zero shredded mozzarella and so much sauce. The amount of sauce was enough for 3 Pizzas. I order this pizza in-store often but maybe quality goes down when you're not there to say something. "
Build Your Own Pizza (11-inch)
choose any toppings
$14.35
Cheese Pizza (Simple Pie) (11-inch)
mozzarella, parmesan, red sauce
$9.74
2 Top Pizza (11-inch)
sauce, cheese & 2 toppings
$12.48
1 Top Pizza (11-inch)
sauce, cheese & 1 topping
$10.83
Dalisa Pizza
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 3.1 mi • 38 min
"Food is always hot, fresh and delicious! I've tried their pizza, paninis, chicken tenders, pasta dishes and they never disappoint. Portions are good and they even throw in a couple extra Chicken Tenders sometimes. The Zeppoles are my favorite...always soft, chewy and sweet. Great restaurant in the Deer Park area!"
"I ordered on a whim because I'd never tried the place before despite it being fairly close to where I live. I was in the mood for some linguine with white clam sauce and a salad. I really didn't have any expectations but thought I was taking a chance. I was absolutely wrong, the food was immaculate. The linguine was sturdy and not double boil soft, the clam sauce was exactly what you would want from a Long Island pizza joint. And the side salad was perfect. Vegetables fresh as can be and a delicious red wine oil dressing. It was honestly a phenomenal meal. I'm actually going to order again tonight. Something new this time now that I know the care that goes into the food."
Regular Cheese & Tomato: Large (8 Slices)
Dalisa's signature pizza.
$19.8
Garlic Knots
The classic kids favorite.
$4.26
Mini Pie
Breaded chicken in a tomato sauce with mozzarella on bread
$10.15
Zeppoles (6)
Breaded. in a tomato sauce with mozzarella.
$4.63
Richie's Pizza
4.7
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 4.2 mi • 39 min
"Our food arrived timely, everything was very good the chicken parm dinner as well as the chicken cutlet parm hero. Our pizza was hot and freshly made as well. This was very much appreciated after a long day"
"We've always loved Ritchie's but tonight's order wasn't only cold, but also was over cooked, (fried raviollii and fried zucchini sticks), very hard to chew and swallow. So while Richie's is usually much better, last night was a bomb."
Regular Pie
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
$26.24
Chicken Cutlet
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
$16.89
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Pan browned and sautéed in a white wine lemon butter sauce.
$19.5
Chicken Francese
In a peanut and pineapple sauce.
$24.4
La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria
4.6
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.6 mi • 46 min
"Pizza was great ! Exactly as ordered....my family enjoys pizza frequently but request it to be very lightly toasted. The pie was wonderful not dry or hard. I had a very happy family !!! Along with this the shrimp parm and artichoke was fabulous as
Always. We are happy to have this great restaurant close to our home. "
"We ordered the eggplant "rollatini" app, plus the Margarita pie. The rollatini was so tiny, and so smothered in cheese, you actually needed to dig around to find them! Think they're were two. Seemed like a tiny slice of breaded eggplant, folded in half, and smothered in mozzarella. Didn't see any ricotta. For 13.99, it was an embarrassment!
The Margarita pie was expensive, but very large... and again, smothered in mozzarella. Overall, the taste of the food was good, but we didn't spend all that money for a lot of cheese !
I can excuse the pie. That's our preference to have less cheese, and more sauce. But that eggplant app...just not good !
LaScala, you can do better!
"
Sicilian Pizza
Homemade potato pasta in a pink cream meat sauce.
$25.85
6 pc. Cheese Filled Garlic Knots
Crisp romaine topped with homemade garlic croutons, aged Parmesan cheese and homemade Dijon caesar dressing.
$7.18
6 pc. Regular Garlic Knots
Chopped romaine topped with diced tomatoes, red onions, and cucumbers, topped with shredded mozzarella cheese.
$6.31
Caesar Salad
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$16.36
Luigi's Pizza
4.7
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 3.5 mi • 35 min
"Omg, their pizza is amazing!!! the dough is light and not dense. It's perfect!!!"
"First time ordering from Luigis, our daughter loved the chicken fingers! Husband found the broccoli roll a little bland, but the pizza, garlic knots and pepperoni bites were really good. Most importantly our special instructions were read and followed, which doesnt normally happen with other places. They even threw in a few extra! We will be ordering again! "
Round Pie Large
Pepperoni, buffalo spinach.
$21.14
Bites
6 pieces. rolled baked garlic bread.
$10
Sicilian Small
A rolled filled tortilla or flatbread made with boneless skinless chicken.
$20
Garlic Knots (6)
Stuffed folded pizza pocket.
$3.75
Cafe Dolce Vita
4.7
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 4.2 mi • 33 min
"Ive been eating their food for over 10 years. Amazing quality and reasonable prices for what you receive. My go to Pizzaria. Their entrees are phenomenal."
"I got the Rigatoni Alla Vodka with chicken, good but bc I asked for whole-wheat pasta they gave my penne instead, not exactly what I was looking forward to. Especially when I already was disappointed when my home cooked dinner(whole wheat Rigatoni Alla Vodka with ground chicken) ended up in the garbage bc of bad parmesan 😔. The portion size was good and I liked the fact that there was chicken in every bite, most places just give you a little grilled breast and it's not enough for the whole dish."
Regular Pie
Round pizza topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$24.56
Garlic Knots (6)
Spicy buffalo chicken topped with mozzarella cheese.
$4.82
Regular Slice
Penne pasta topped with vodka sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$4.26
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Five pieces.
$7.09
Mama's
4.7
(3k+)$0 delivery fee • 5.2 mi • 41 min
"The place messaged to let us know their Tosted Almon Tiramisu's was at its end and it wasnt the best looking piece, to remedy this they told me they would add extra almonds & throw in a bottle of wine, but at my request- sent an extra original tiramisu instead at no charge. THIS is how you do business!!! Btw the Tosted Almon Tiramisu was DELICIOUS regardless of how it looked to you guys, it looked great to me! .
customer for life! "
"Everything I've ever gotten is above and beyond. It's pricy cause the portions are tremendous. Had chx parm dinner it's enough for almost 3!! Rigatoni ala vodka slice still #1!!"
Rigatoni Vodka Slice
pink cream, fresh ground beef, parmigiano cheese
$8.52
Garlic Knots (6)
fresh tomato, grande mozzarella, grated cheese
$4.51
Regular Slice
pink vodka sauce, crispy chicken, ricotta filled rigatoni
$4.51
Sicilian Slice
hearts of romaine, caesar dressing, parmigiano, croutons
$5.82
Mr G's Pizzeria
4.6
(800+)$0 delivery fee • 3.8 mi • 40 min
"Fresh hot hero crispy bread! Nice cool salad tender chicken. "
"Amazing Neopolitan Pizza Pie!So far the best pie I have ordered on DD! I have ordered pies around my area and for 3 years they have been disappointments! I waited till Iwent into another county out west where I used live for apizza!Not anymore!! FRESH and worth it!"
Large Cheese Pie
Full topping $6.50 1/2 topping $4.50
$19.18
Regular Slice
Additional topping $1.50
$4.43
Small Cheese Pie
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$18.51
Meatball hero’s
Add cheese for $1.50
$10.92
Mario's Pizzeria (Commack)
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.7 mi • 43 min
"Hero was delicious and stuffed with chicken and cheese! The garlic bread it was on just made it perfect! BOGO on the Mozzarella Sticks was an added bonus! We love Mario's!!"
"Mario's has become my favorite place to order Italian food. Everything is delicious and arrives well packaged and hot. I especially enjoy the Lunch Chicken Francese because they make such a bright and flavorful sauce and the chicken is cooked perfectly . They also make a great variety of pizzas and the White Slice and Sicilian Slice were a big hit tonight. Everything is worthy of 5 stars."
Medium Cheese (12")
Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!
$19.82
Large Cheese Pizza
Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!
$26.93
Garlic Knots
Tossed with Garlic, Oil, Parmesan Cheese & Fresh Parsley. Melted Mozzarella Available
$4.99
Plain Slice
Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese - Click to add Toppings!
$4.78
Pizzaiolo Gourmet Eatery
4.7
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 9.2 mi • 55 min
"This was a Margarita Pizza with only Fresh Mozzarella on Cauliflower crust. DELICIOUS!!!! We have also had their other Gluten Free Crust which is doughy and perfect! Gluten-Free Pizzette"
"Only place I order Neapolitan Cheese Pizza (Large 18") from and always so good. Can eat whole pie myself"
Neapolitan Cheese Pizza (18")
Round pizza with cheese.
$25.31
Garlic Knot (6 Pieces)
Pizza dough tied into knots seasoned with garlic, butter and grated parm cheese.
$5.47
Neapolitan Pizzette (12”)
Personal 12” pizza
$17.25
Mozzarella Sticks (6 Pieces)
Mozzarella cheese breaded and fried served with a side of tomato sauce
$13.95
Parisi’s Pizza & Pasta
4.5
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 6.2 mi • 40 min
"This place is great. Always delicious. The Drunken Garlic Knots are out of this world. The cheese pull on those things were insane. Keep up the good work guys. "
"wings were tiny and dry. i did get buffalo sauce on the side, however I expected buffalo wings to have sauce on them. these tasted like plain fried chicken wings. the tossed garden salad, however, was generous and very good."
Cheese Pizza
8 slices.
$26.97
Garlic Knots
Romaine, tomato, red onion, fried buffalo chicken.
$6.45
6 Wings
Bacon, ham, pineapple and mozzarella cheese.
$16.09
La Slice Pizzeria
4.5
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 9.3 mi • 48 min
"Individual slices are HUGE for the price. Love coming here for lunch during the week, always good quality food. "
"La Slice's chicken noodle soup is my favorite! They add potatoes to it too, which is different, but it tastes good. Every time the ingredients taste fresh, like their soups are made daily. One soup is filling enough for dinner. I always order more than one at a time, so I have another one for the next day since I'm usually still craving it."
Regular Pie
romaine lettuce, croutons, homemade dressing
$21.67
Regular Slice
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$3.58
Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.5
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 8.1 mi • 52 min
"The only real old Brooklyn style pizza on the south shore of Long Island. Bianca is sheer perfection, amazing how using quality ingredients produces quality products. Regular slice is the best I have had since leaving Brooklyn."
"I always order from Umbertos in Glen Cove and love the Fried Calamari so I ordered it from this umbertos thinking it was the same. It wasn't fresh and over cooked like rubber! It tasted like frozen defrosted product. would not order from here again."
Neapolitan Classic Pie
Round pie and 8 slices.
$28.93
Garlic Knots (6)
New York style tomato sauce and cheese. 10" personal pie.
$3.72
Neapolitan Pizzetta
Square pie and 12 slices
$17.96
Neapolitan By The Slice
Romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese, and Caesar dressing.
$4.55
Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 9.3 mi • 37 min
"Everything was Great!!! The Sicilian slices were delicious!!! The Chicken Francaise was deliciousy ohhhhhh sooooo good. And the warm baked bread and... canolli just did me in! "
"Really upset about my wild shrimp salad. The hot shrimp came on top of the salad and melted the mozzarella and wilted the lettuce. I was unable to eat it. "
Regular Pie
With a side salad and fountain soda.
$27.14
Regular Slice
Creamy pink sauce, shredded mozzarella, and grated pecorino.
$4.68
Order of Garlic Knots
Pizza dough formed into a pocket and filled with sauce and poultry.
$5.46
Penne alla Vodka
Bite size pieces of buffalo chicken topped with bleu cheese and melted mozzarella.
$26.41
Francescos Pizza& Pasta
4.7
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 6.6 mi • 44 min
"Absolutely love this location, ordered pizza on valentines day and they made the pizza shape into a heart not to mention that pizza was SO flavorful, true mom and pop pizzeria 🫶🏽"
"Grilled Chicken Breast Hero has an amazing taste. Fresh ingredients. First time ordering and will probably always get from here. Prices are great. Thank you!"
Cheese Pizza (X-Large 18'' (8 Slices))
Classic cheese or create your own pizza, fresh tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$17.7
Speciality Pizza Slice
With sauce. 12 Pieces.
$5.78
Chicken Wings
Breaded.
$11.58
Caesar Salad
12 Slices. With fresh tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese.
$14.43
Pita & Pizza Wood Fired Chicken
4.5
(700+)$0 delivery fee • 5.6 mi • 39 min
"The best wings"
"The fries and pasta were really good, but what really ruined it for me was the ribs, they were very hard and not a lot of meat on the ribs. For the price i expected the ribs to be hot and soft, they didn't seem fresh or taste fresh. i would not order the ribs again."
10" Personal Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$9.96
1 Whole Chicken with 2 sides
With 2 sides.
$23.09
1 Half Chicken with 2 sides
With 2 sides.
$13.57
1 Half Chicken with 2 sides
With 2 sides.
$14.17
Umberto's of Sayville
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 12.0 mi • 54 min
$5 off on $35+
"SO glad my favorite pizzeria on Long Island is finally on DoorDash! Their Sicilian is amazing and their deep dish is equally delicious! No one else touches this place-The best! Pizza is perfect every time. "
"Ordered Pasta E Fagioli I wrote this review about 10 times over so here is the final draft..
Very salty and yet still very bland. I'm actually surprised cause I love the food in this pizzeria however the chef dropped the ball cause I suspect chef Mic was responsible for this disaster. ( Chef " Mic"rowave) Noodles are mush and over inflated with what ever broth was in there. Just no flavor."
Neapolitan (Regular) Pie
romaine lettuce with our homemade croutons.
$26.56
Neapolitan (Regular) Slice
With mozzarella & ricotta.
$4.32
6 Garlic Knots
(includes side sauce).
$5.36
Buffalo Chicken Slice
meat or vegetable.
$6.15
Albert’s Pizza
4.2
(900+)$0 delivery fee • 7.8 mi • 54 min
"Always enjoy everything we order from Alberts. The Lasagna is always great. My daughter had 2 Meatballs Pasta with spaghetti- it was amazing. Also, a very friendly and hard working family business. A business we continue to support !! "
"The pizza crust was hard and not enjoyable and the chicken parmsean hero was just plain horrible. The bread was stale and broke into pieces. The chicken wasn't that great either. I didn't even mention that the order wasn't ready when I got there, I wouldn't have minded the wait if the food was up to par."
18" Large Pizza Regular
One square or round pie six spinach or pepperoni rolls six garlic knots two liter soda.
$21.6
Six Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded chicken, tomato sauce and mozzarella.
$6.3
Albert's Upside Down Pie
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
$18.54
Penne Alla Vodka
Breaded chicken, tomato sauce and mozzarella.
$14.25
Mary's Pizza and Pasta
4.6
(800+)$0 delivery fee • 7.3 mi • 40 min
"Alfredo with chicken and broccoli was amazing, beautiful Bacon Bomber Burger, fries crispy and the Traditional Wings were perfect. Cant wait to try more from here!"
"This place is fantastic! If you haven't tried I highly recommend. Everything always comes hot and fresh and always done how I requested it. And the happy hour discounts make it a great bargain "
Large Cheese Pie
Classic Neapolitan style cheese pie. 16" pie, 8 slices.
$25.92
6 Garlic Knots
Prosciutto, shallots, pecorino Romano, pink cream sauce.
$5.61
Penne Alla Vodka
Chicken cutlet, tomato sauce, mozzarella.
$24.13
Chicken Parm Hero
Romaine, croutons, grated Romano, Caesar dressing.
$16.75
PAPA'S PIZZA & PASTA
4.6
(50+)$0 delivery fee • 8.1 mi • 42 min
"This is the 2nd time I've ordered from PAPA'S. The food is excellent. The personal pizza was delicious, not too greasy, and perfect size for the kids. The chicken roll is super fresh and soft but the right amount of crisp at the bottom. Doesn't taste like its been sitting out all day. Will definitely continue ordering from them and try more of their food."
"This is THE BEST Rigatoni Vodka Slice that I've EVER had 🔥🙏🏻🤩"
Large Neapolitan Pizza
Neapolitan round crust mozzarella and homemade tomato sauce made with basil and olive oil. fresh and simply unforgettable!
$29.06
12" Personal Cheese Pizza
Plain pie with cheese and sauce.
$18.3
Cannoli
**Be sure to add a quantity of 2 of this item to your cart in order to get BUY 1 GET 1 FREE PROMOTION**
Crispy pastry shells filled with sweet, creamy ricotta, dusted with powdered sugar.
$6.28
Cauliflower Vodka Pizza with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese
Served with tomato sauce.
$17.95
West Islip Pizza Delivery FAQs
Is Pizza delivery available near me in West Islip?
Yes, Pizza delivery is available near you in West Islip through DoorDash. Enter your address in the DoorDash app or website to find the best Pizza options available for delivery near you.
Where can I find the best Pizza delivery near me in West Islip?
To find the best Pizza delivery near you in West Islip, look for restaurants with high ratings and user reviews on DoorDash. You can filter by ratings to see the top-rated Pizza spots near you.
Where can I find cheap Pizza near me in West Islip?
For affordable Pizza delivery near me in West Islip, DoorDash allows you to filter restaurants by price. Look for spots marked with a single dollar for budget-friendly options.
What is open now for Pizza delivery near me in West Islip?
To see which Pizza restaurants are open for delivery in West Islip right now, enter your address on the DoorDash website or app. You will be shown a list of Pizza places that are currently available for delivery, including their hours of operation.
Can I schedule a Pizza delivery in West Islip?
Yes, DoorDash allows you to schedule a Pizza delivery in West Islip at a time that works best for you. During checkout, simply choose the schedule option to set a future delivery time for your order.
How can I get free Pizza delivery in West Islip?
To enjoy 0 delivery fees on Pizza orders in West Islip, consider joining DashPass, DoorDash’s subscription service. DashPass members get free delivery on eligible orders from participating restaurants.
How do I pay for my Pizza delivery on DoorDash in West Islip?
Payment for your Pizza delivery in West Islip is easy and secure with DoorDash. You can pay through the app using credit/debit cards, DoorDash credits, or other available payment methods. No need to handle cash!
What are the most popular Pizza dishes I can order near me in West Islip?
Enter your address on DoorDash to discover the most-ordered Pizza dishes from restaurants near you.