Order the best Pizza near Lake Grove, NY

(10k+)

$0 delivery fee • 1.6 mi • 33 min

"I ordered a Neapolitan pizza from O Sole Mio through DoorDash, and it was absolutely incredible! The flavors were authentic, the crust was perfectly cooked, and the quality of the ingredients was top-notch. Although it was my first time using the app, I’m no stranger to this wonderful restaurant—we frequent O Sole Mio regularly because their food is consistently amazing. What makes O Sole Mio even more special is their dedication to the community. They are major supporters of the Grace Care Food Pantry in Medford, helping to feed hundreds of people in need every week through their generous donations. It’s clear they truly care about making a difference and are passionate about helping those less fortunate. If you’re looking for fantastic food and want to support a business that gives back to the community, O Sole Mio is the place to go. Highly recommended!"

"The pizza was one of the best I have had in this area. The crust stood out to me—it was crispy but soft. The mozzarella had a good flavor and went well with the sauce. I also ordered a couple of specialty slices—the Baked Ziti Slice had the perfect ratio of ziti to crust. The crust maintained its structural integrity, which meant I could eat like a slice without dumping half of it into my lap. I also really enjoyed the Buffalo Chicken Slice - the pepper wasn't the usual Frank's red hot, but it had a homemade flavor. Finally, the Garlic Knots were some of my fav. I liked the generous helping of parm. I did not let a drop of parm/garlic mix go to waste. I will be ordering again."

Neapolitan

A round pizza with cheese.

$20.81

Garlic Knots half dozen

Rolled baked garlic bread.

$5.71

Alla Vodka

House specialty. Pink cream and vodka sauce with a touch of meat.

$20.73

Caesar Salad

House specialty. Crisp romaine topped with homemade garlic croutons, aged parmesan cheese and homemade Dijon Caesar dressing.

$14.27

Domino's

4.1

(30+)

• Pizza • Pizzeria

$0 delivery fee • 1.0 mi • 29 min

Build Your Own Pizza - NEW CRUST

A custom pizza made to order. Choose from any of our delicious crust styles, including Handmade Pan, New York Style, and NEW Parmesan Stuffed Crust.

$17.39

Stuffed Cheesy Bread

Our 8-piece oven-baked breadsticks are generously stuffed and covered with a blend of 100% real mozzarella and cheddar cheeses then seasoned with a touch of garlic.

$9.78

Wisconsin 6-Cheese

Feta, provolone, cheddar, Parmesan-Asiago, cheese made with 100% real mozzarella and sprinkled with oregano. Choose from any of our delicious crust styles, including Handmade Pan, New York Style, and NEW Parmesan Stuffed Crust.

$19.55

Cinnamon Bread Twists

Handmade from fresh buttery-tasting dough and baked to a golden brown. Crusty on the outside and soft on the inside. Drizzled with a perfect blend of cinnamon and sugar, and best served with a side of sweet icing for dipping or drizzling. Orders are 8-pieces.

$8.69

Mozzafiato Pizzeria

4.8

$0 delivery fee • 1.8 mi • 35 min

• Panini • Pizza

"LOVE this new Pizzeria in town. The meatballs are by far the best, they are moist and flavorful. The Chicken Marsala, the gravy was REAL gravy with mushroom and herbs, tasted just like home made. The Penne Ala Vodka was cooked perfectly and the mozzarella sticks were large, hot and stringy! I have not had the pizza yet, going to try it tonight. I used Doordash and the order was here within 25 minutes of ordering. "

"The Meatball Parmigiana Hero was good. They used a vented container so it didn't get soggy. But for a $19 hero four meatballs barely filled the small hero. The meat balls and sauce were good, not great but good. And the meatballs were uncut which was the worst part. Try to take a bite and they fly out the side."

Neapolitan

18" round pizza with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$25.61

Garlic Knots

Each. Angel hair pasta and cheese formed into patties and deep fried.

$6.13

Capellini Cake

Thin pan pizza with mozzarella and fresh San Marzano plum tomatoes.

$4.24

Grandma

Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, topped with freshly shaved grana padano with Caesar dressing

$26.92

Alberts Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 2.0 mi • 33 min

"Seriously the best Zucchini Sticks I've ever had! came delivered piping hot soo good! the Rice Ball with Sauce and Cheese was ahhmazing!! bigger than I even thought but my god delicious! and hands down my ultimate favorite is the Upside Down SLICE !! best around!"

"Cream of Spinach Slice was amazing, it sounds a little odd but was actually fantastic. Upside Down Square Slice was also very good. Dough was delicious and nice and crispy (for slices. I haven't tried a whole pie. Yet.) "

18" Neapolitan Pizza

Cheese under the sauce.

$22.72

Upside Down Square Pie

12 pieces.

$23.72

(6) Garlic Knots

Grandma crust with vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil

$4.48

Regular SLICE

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

$3.53

Umberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

(4k+)

$0 delivery fee • 1.4 mi • 37 min

$5 off on $40+

"First time try the pepperoni pinwheel, it was delicious and so filling that I will have to save the pasta for later. Even though I did not order it this time around I would recommend their garden salad - it is one of the best I've ever had."

"Sicilian Pie was perfect! cheese melted just right, sauce tasted nostalgic and perfectly balanced, and the crust was buttery smooth yet crunchy in the right places. these guys have mastered the sicilian pie."

Neapolitan Pie

Eighteen inches round, eight slices, cheese and tomato sauce.

$22.2

Garlic Knots (6)

Sixteen inches square, twelve slices thin crust pan pizza with mozzarella cheese and spotted tomato basil sauce.

$3.73

Neapolitan By The Slice

Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, red onion, black olives, house dressing

$3.28

Grandma Pie

Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, parmesan cheese, caesar dressing.

$26.27

Gino's

$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 31 min

"Food is consistently fantastic. Every single item on the menu is delicious. The prices are fair. Great portions. The staff is great! Absolutely recommend !"

"The Alla Vodka has meat in it for sme reason and I don eat meat! Garlic Knots (6 per order) arent the best. They dropped the ball big time tonight. "

Regular Pie

18 inch round crust pizza with mozzarella and tomato sauce.

$27.12

Regular Slice

Traditional crust with mozzarella & tomato sauce.

$4.25

Pepperoni Pinwheel

Dough rolled with pepperoni and cheese.

$4.99

Sicilian Slice

Thick crust pan pizza with mozzarella & tomato sauce.

$4.4

Joe's Pizza & Pasta

$0 delivery fee • 3.4 mi • 39 min

(7k+)

• Sandwich • Italian

"Amazing!! The Baked Ravioli (6) was so soft and tasty. The Homemade Meatballs (3) were thick and filling. The Tossed Salad | Large was a lot of salad, but I wish it had cucumbers. The bread they give you for free with the entree is way better than the one you order on the menu. "

"The Sweet Italian Sausage (3) was delicious and cooked perfectly. They had a nice snap but stil very tender... Oh my GOSH THAT SAUCE WAS INCREDIBLE I wanted to drink it right of of that tin conta... One of the best saucs I have ever had!!"

Neapolitano Cheese Pizza | 18"

8 slices. Regular pizza.

$27.36

Penne Alla Vodka

Includes tomato dipping sauce.

$23.26

Garlic Knots (6 Pieces)

Chicken cutlet, Mozzarella, and vodka sauce on toasted garlic bread.

$6.86

Cheese Personal Pizza

Our famous grilled chicken Caesar salad served inside our homemade seasoned flatbread.

$17.82

Spuntino St. James

$0 delivery fee • 3.3 mi • 39 min

"I got a blackened chicken Caesar Salad and it was amazing, a good portion of chicken and lettuce, very tasty. I also enjoyed the Vegetarian Pizza Vegetarian Pizza Slice, it had a good selection of toppings and was loaded with them. "

"The food was fantastic! Bread was still warm, my wife loved her fettucine. My Chicken Parmigiana had about 5 pieces."

Neapolitan Round Cheese Pizza

Mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

$24.72

The Little Neapolitan Pizzette (12")

Mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce.

$20.21

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce, garlic croutons, Parmesan cheese & Caesar dressing.

$17.11

Round Neapolitan Pizza Slice

4 pieces.

$3.29

Paisano's Pizza & Catering

$0 delivery fee • 2.9 mi • 36 min

15% off, up to $8

"Pizza is well made - thin, crispy crust, right amount of sauce and cheese. My favorite "parm" heroes in the area. Good portions, fair prices, great service. "

"This place is the best!! Delicious food at a great value! They always get the order and modifications right!! Best around for sure. "

18" Cheese Pizza

A large 18-inch pizza topped with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a crispy, golden crust.

$23.47

Rigatoni Alla Vodka Dinner

Rigatoni in a creamy vodka sauce, topped with grated cheese.

$20.95

Chopped Italian Salad

Mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers and fried chicken topped with Shredded cheese.

$16.85

Garlic Knot Crust Pizza

Breaded chicken cutlets, marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a hero roll.

$30.66

Caffe Amici

(800+)

$0 delivery fee • 3.4 mi • 36 min

"Pollo Romano was extraordinary! the chicken was incredibly tender and paired so beautifully with the sliced eggplant and the tomato sauce was the best as always. Cafe Amici always delivers high quality Italian food but yesterday's dish was truly one of their best."

"The Margarita Pie was huge and tasty!! My husband loved his Garlic Knots and the Wings were nice and juicy! Definitely coming back"

Neapolitan Pizza

A round pizza with cheese.

$23.84

Garlic Knots

Pink cream and vodka sauce with a touch of meat.

$6.99

Rigatoni Alla Vodka

Crisp romaine topped with homemade garlic croutons, aged Parmesan cheese, and homemade dijon Caesar dressing.

$22.64

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Pasta purses stuffed with six cheeses and sautéed in a roasted pepper cream sauce.

$15.8

Nesconset Pizza & Pasta

$0 delivery fee • 2.6 mi • 35 min

(200+)

• Pizza • Panini

"my mom and i are obsessed with the Margarita Pizza here, always fresh and delicious! we ordered the Rice Ball tonight and it's possibly the best one i've ever had. highly recommended!"

"I got the regular pie. $20 for the worst pizza ive ever had. It doesn't taste fresh, crust is a brick, no way to put toppings, the sauce was cold, cheese tastes weird. It's simply the worst pizza I've ever had I'm sorry."

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, and caesar dressing wrapped in a soft tortilla.

$14

Regular Slice

Hand-tossed New York style pizza slice with premium cheese on a thin crust.

Sicilian Slice

Thick square slice with cheese and tomato sauce on a Sicilian crust.

Vodka Sauce Slice

Vodka sauce slice: Smooth tomato and vodka cream sauce with a blend of cheeses.

Brunellos

(40+)

$0 delivery fee • 3.1 mi • 33 min

"the Garlic Knot Pie was full of yummy garlic. the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie was just as delicious, and the chicken they use was yummy and very filling. nomnom"

"Everything was fresh and good portion size. All cooked to our liking. Sticks were cruncy and cheezy, knots were garlicy and flufy inside. The pizza also crunchy flavorful crust and nice topings. The only downside was mising a little flavor in the topings and cheese. We added a little garlic salt and it worked. "

Reg Pizza 18 Inch

Sicilian Pie with 4 toppings. Toppings choices: Sausage, meatballs, peppers, onions, olives, extra cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, fresh tomatoes, eggplant, garlic broccoli, spinach.

$21.61

Pizza Hut

$0 delivery fee • 7.2 mi • 37 min

• Pizza • Chicken Wings

20% off, up to $5

"The Tavern Double Pepperoni Pizza was absolutely delicious the sauce and pepperonis where nice and spicy like I ordered, the only reason I didn't give it a 5 star rating is because I called the restaurant and told them my order name and info and specifically asked for the pie to be "Well Done" and they said no prob however the pie was not well done at all!"

"the Create Your Own Pizza that i ordered was under cooked and not cut properly. but the saving grace was the Breadsticks they were cooked to perfection."

Create Your Own Pizza

Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!

$18.82

Breadsticks

Nobody does breadsticks like the Hut. Crispy-on-the-outside, soft-on-the-inside, and seasoned with garlic and parmesan, they're perfect with pizza or pasta. Comes with a cup of our delicious marinara!

$6.86

Cheese Sticks

A side everyone can agree on! Get these cheese sticks sprinkled with flavorful Italian seasoning and a cup of our delicious marinara.

$8.17

Big Dinner Box with Breaded Boneless Wings

Feelin' saucy? We got you. Get a Big Dinner Box with 2 medium 1-topping pizzas, 5 breadsticks & 8 boneless wings. Additional charge for multiple toppings.

$31.26

Villa Grazia

$0 delivery fee • 2.4 mi • 39 min

"Traditional Pizza (Mini 12") was delicious, plenty of olives, and cooked just right. we really like the fact that they are mini. perfect size for one person. we will definitely order again."

"The food is very good and we like the combo meals. Unfortunately we never seem to get our complete order. Whoe is handling the DoorDash orders needs to be more diligent in making sure the order that is being picked up is complete. This has happened multiple times. "

Traditional Pizza

Savory pie with a dough base topped with sauce and cheese. Add toppings for an additional charge.

$24.34

Traditional Pizza (Mini 12")

Savory pie with a dough base topped with sauce and cheese. Add toppings for an additional charge.

$11.93

Pepperoni Bites

Rolled baked garlic bread.

$7.72

Garlic Knots

Penne pasta and mozzarella, drizzled with our homemade vodka sauce.

$6.4

KC’S Pizza N Wings

$0 delivery fee • 4.2 mi • 37 min

(40+)

• American • Pizzeria

"As always Five Stars! Wings arrived pip Hot and Crispy!"

"Pizza was so good, and the garlic knots are the BEST!! Highly recommend! "

12 Piece

Our 12-piece wings come in breaded, naked, and boneless varieties and can be paired with your choice of two of our 25 wing sauces and dry rubs. Customize your order for a unique flavor experience every time.

$18.63

Large 18"

Our large 18" pizza is crafted with our signature hand-tossed dough, topped with rich tomato sauce and premium mozzarella cheese, then baked to perfection. perfect for sharing, this classic pizza is customizable with your favorite toppings

$22.92

Garlic Knots

House made knots with marinara

Specialty Slice

Our specialty slice features a rotating selection of our delicious specialty pizzas, offering unique flavors and toppings on our signature crispy crust. ask about today’s specialty options for a fresh and flavorful twist on your favorite slice

$6.6

Vincents NYWF Pizza

4.8

(30+)

• Pizza • Pie

$0 delivery fee • 3.0 mi • 34 min

"Everything on the menu is amazing! The East End & The L.I.B.E.C personal favs 🔥🔥🔥"

"The pizza was done right and the Manhattan was good. That said, the chicken on the suffolk tasted old. I'm sure Vincent's is normally better than this, but the chicken was inedible. I normally love buffalo chicken and buff chic pizza, and this was inedible."

The Queens

Hand crushed tomatoes, melted fresh mozz, just enough basil, then hit with a drizzle of EVOO.

$17.04

The Manhattan

All the goods *pepperoni, meatball, sausage, peppers, onions mushroom, & extra cheese.

$19.87

Margarita Pie

Lil extra sauce, fresh mozz, basil, and extra virgin olive oil!

$18.3

The Bronx

Creamy ricotta, spread with garlic-infused olive oil, a hit of pecorino romano & finished off with a handful of mozzarella.

$19.04

Roccos pizza and pasta

$0 delivery fee • 3.4 mi • 43 min

15% off, up to $9

"Fresh delicious pizza every time! Our go-to place whenever we have a pizza craving. "

"the best meatballs since my mother-in-law died. she was sicilian. tha sauce wasexcellent! more sauce please."

Neopolitan (Regular)

Prepared in orders of six.

$22.56

Garlic Knots

A thin Sicilian pie with light mozzarella cheese, fresh san marzano tomatoes, garlic, basil and extra virgin olive oil.

$4.51

Grandma

Chicken cutlet, mozzarella and marinara sauce.

$23.22

Chicken Roll

Spicy buffalo chicken, bleu cheese and mozzarella.

$9.55

Setauket Pastaria

(500+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.4 mi • 41 min

"ALWAYS EXCELLENT EVERYTHING! BETTER THAN O SOLO MIO........ANYTIME.....NO COMPARISON!"

"So much toppings Amazing tastes"

16" Large Pizza

Toppings for an additional charge.

$23.06

Create Your Own 12" Personal Pie

Toppings for an additional charge.

$14.49

Pasta with Vodka Sauce

Served with mozzarella cheese and balsamic vinaigrette.

$20.07

Regular Pizza Slice

The bold, refreshing, robust cola

$4.59

Carnival Restaurant

$0 delivery fee • 5.6 mi • 43 min

(5k+)

• Takeout • Pizza

"The Harvest Arugula, Apple, cranberry, almond & goat cheese salad was fresh and the dressing was delicious. Regular cheese pie was also very good. "

"Love the pasta fagioli soup it is delicious, however, it being $16.50 you would expect to get a full quart of the soup. They don't fill up the container. This has happened now a few times to me when ordering this here."

Cheese

Crisp romaine lettuce and homemade garlic crostini croutons tossed in a cream caesar dressing.

$22.62

Sicilian

Toasted Italian bread topped with melted mozzarella cheese in our famous garlic sauce.

$24.21

Caesar

Served in a pink cream sauce with sautéed onions, fresh tomatoes, and a touch of meat.

$14.15

Chicken Parm

The best homemade mozzarella sticks in the world! Served with tomato sauce for dipping.

$12.17

Little Caesars

4.4

(600+)

• Pizza • Deep Dish Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 6.7 mi • 44 min

"Custom Stuffed Crust amazing with the Caesar Dip® 🍕🔥🔥🔥🥳"

"Lately more than ever they have beeb very cons with their quality. The Stuffed Pretzel Crust with Pizza Sauce & Pepperoni was really good. Followed My request for well done and it came out so good."

ExtraMostBestest® Pepperoni

Large round pizza with more Pepperoni and Cheese than our Classic Pizza

$12.06

Custom Stuffed Crust

Large stuffed crust pizza with toppings of your choice

$17.78

ExtraMostBestest® Cheese

Large round pizza with more Cheese than our Classic Pizza

$12.06

Italian Cheese Bread

Ten pieces of freshly baked bread with a crispy edge, covered with cheese and topped with Italian spices (1340 Cal)

$7.42

L'Anatra Pizza and Kitchen

(200+)

$0 delivery fee • 3.3 mi • 44 min

"everything ive had from here is excellent. i get the Duck Cordon Bleu but with chicken cutlet, and it reminds me of when i was young. the pomodoro sauce is to die for. and the Zeppole is perfect. worth every penny"

"Perfect size pizza for kids that can't eat a whole p Crust is crispy and delicious "

NY Style Pizza Pie (12")

Regular cheese pizza

$17.2

New York Style Pie (18")

Regular cheese pizza

$24.76

NY Style Pizza Slice

Regular cheese pizza

$9.74

Fried Ravioli (6 pcs)

Cutlet, marinara, and mozzarella.

$12.93

Eddies pizza

4.1

$0 delivery fee • 2.0 mi • 29 min

"Ordered the everything slice it was gigantic and delicious!. The pinwheels and garlic knots are the best. My favorite pizza place! Everything is delicious. Coked to perfection!!!"

"White slice was overly globbed with ricotta cheese, the plain slice was pretty flavorless and both slices were pretty small. The buffalo wings were decent, but I wasn't a fan of the breading. The garlic knots were pretty good though!"

Regular (Pie 8 Slices)

1 Cheese Pie 1 Mozzarella Stick order or Fried Ravioli 6 Garlic knots

$21.38

Garlic Knots

Romano, mozzarella, and ricotta.

$3.74

Regular (Slice)

Romaine lettuce tossed in zesty Caesar dressing with fresh baked croutons and Romano cheese.

$3.36

Wednesday Special

Wings, mozzarella sticks, fried ravioli, and chicken fingers.

$23.08

Via Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 6.2 mi • 46 min

• Pizza

15% off, up to $8

"The food was delicious, well seasoned, and had great portions! We got the Pasta Alla Vodka with Angel hair and tortellini"

"I've ordered from Via a few times and usually have had a good experience - until tonight. They called me to ask if I wanted a replacement for the Macaroni & Cheese Slice, which I appreciated, but then strangely refunded the philly cheesesteak slice (I would have preferred a replacement). And then they completely forgot the Cannoli and I had to call DoorDash for a refund. The Drunken Sicilian With Pepperoni & Hot Honey was disappointingly small About the only good slice was the Boone Slice. I don't think I'll be ordering from here again."

Large Cheese Pizza

18 inch Pizza

$19.72

6 Garlic Knots

14 inch Pizza

$3.51

Regular Slice

Mozzarella cheese that has been coated and fried.

$3.63

Small Cheese Pizza

Tube shaped pasta. tomato and vodka pasta sauce.

$16.14

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

• Bar and Grill • Chicken Wings

(3k+)

$0 delivery fee • 5.0 mi • 38 min

"I couldn't wait to review this place! Our food was sooo good. It was hot and fresh. It was very good quality, my husband and I couldn't believe it. We had the crispy and ten juicy buffalo wings with pepperoni pizza bundle. Which was perfect. But we started with the beautiful salad, which is #1 most popular item on the door dash app, for a reason!!!! The big plump tomatoes. OMG. The meatball w/ a side of crispy focaccia bread from the oven with smooth ricotta on top! Delish! The sauce was amazing on the pizza, the bread and everything! So good! We will definitely order again!"

"The Create Your Own 16" Pizza was different and not crispy but tasted good. The Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings are much smaller and Meatballs came with no ricotta and only 2 small focaccia. Overall quality was good but different than previous for price"

Create Your Own 16" Pizza

Grande mozzarella, hand crushed Italian plum tomato sauce, hand grated Romano cheese, basil and olive oil.

$27.72

Create Your Own 12" Pizza

Grande mozzarella, hand crushed Italian plum tomato sauce, hand grated Romano cheese, basil and olive oil

$23.02

10 Wings

Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings. Choose your flavor.

$21.33

Anthony's Classic Italian Salad

Romaine, celery, red onions, garbanzo beans, Kalamata olives, tomato and hard cooked egg tossed in our homemade Italian dressing.

$16.32

Dragos Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 5.1 mi • 36 min

(700+)

• Cheesecake • Calzones

20% off, up to $12

"Amazing pizza!! so delicious, and they gave us a few extra items for free! Very nice of them, and we are appreciative. Great quality. Pizza was nice and crispy, and we will be ordering again. 5 stars!"

"Cheesecake tasted like it was sitting in refrigerator too long. Slice way too small for price paid. Individual slices had no option available for toppings. But pizza itself was good "

Regular Pie

Classic pizza typically includes marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$26.21

Garlic Knots

A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked and then topped with melted butter, garlic and parsley.

$4.59

Regular Slice

A regular slice of pizza typically includes tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and a thin, hand-rolled crust.

$4.55

Pepperoni Pinwheel

pepperoni and mozzarella cheese

$4.8

Selden Pizza

(600+)

$0 delivery fee • 3.6 mi • 38 min

"When my son first said he wanted to eat here I saw the rating on Google and didn't really want to. My son swore up and down this place was amazing and he is a big pizza fanatic so I reluctantly agreed to go ahead and give it a try. I will be the first to admit that I prejudged this place without actually reading the reviews and how long ago they were posted. It's been well over a year that we have been eating here (with the exception of my long time loyal son) and I can easily say that Selden Pizza is the best around here. As for today's order the Neapolitan Round Cheese Pie was perfectly cooked as per usual. Hot, cheesy, and the crust cooked perfectly. Selden Pizzas consistency is what keeps us loyal and coming back. It doesn't matter what time of day you order the pizza is always excellent. This is the first time we ordered the Chicken Fingers with Fries and I was a little nervous since small places like this tend to be hit or miss with this kind of meal especially when their specialty is pizzas and pastas. My daughter who can't eat dairy can be pretty picky so I wasn't sure how she would like the meal. Of course there was no reason to worry. The chicken fingers were really good. Hot, great taste, cooked perfectly and was portioned just right but what I was even more impressed with were the fries. Fries can easily go wrong and in my home everyone can be quite snobby. These were perfectly cooked. They were hot, seasoned tasty, and cooked absolutely perfect not burnt or soggy like some places and priced more than fair at $10 for fries and chicken fingers."

"This pizza is the real deal. Sauce is tangy and perfect. Cheese is perfectly cooked. Crust floppy but not wet and just a bit chewy. Like the perfect amount of chewy. And thats before I get high. Well done team Selden Pizza!"

Neapolitan Round Cheese Pie

Eighteen inches.

$22.79

Round Neapolitan Cheese Pizza Slice

Thin Sicilian crust brushed with olive oil & garlic, fresh mozzarella, and spotted with chunky San Marzano tomato sauce.

$3.42

Grandma Pizza Slice

Crispy on the outside, yet light and fluffy on the inside. These mini Italian donut holes will become your new fave.

$3.71

Mozzarella Sticks

Strips of breaded chicken topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$8.49

ciro' pizza

$0 delivery fee • 4.5 mi • 39 min

"This may be the best slice of pizza that I have ever had!"

"I ordered from puns pizza section the ziti pizza and they sent me regular baked ziti this was $30 and I would not have spent $30 on a regular baked ziti"

Cheese Pizza (No Additional Topping)

Sausage, pepperoni, meatball, green pepper, mushroom, onions, & extra cheese.

$24.66

Matt's Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 6.4 mi • 39 min

"The lasagna was excellent and such a generous portion. I've ordered lasagna from a few other local pizzerias and always been very disappointed with the quality as well as the portion size. Matts will ve my go to from now on!"

"So our first time ordering from Matt's and was definitely a success with everyone in the house hold ( 9 )of us and some of us are VERY picky . The one thing I liked was they ran out of manicotti :( BUT for that they gave me extra meatballs :) "

Neapolitan (18")

Hot, mild or BBQ

$20.91

Neapolitan (14")

Long thing pasta.

$16.91

Chicken Wings

Cooked in oil.

$12.14

Garlic Knot

Fried potatoes.

$26.75

Luigi's Pizzeria & Restaurant (East Setauket)

(900+)

$0 delivery fee • 5.8 mi • 39 min

$5 off on $25+

"The food is always hot and good. The Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza was still steaming hot and had plenty of quality toppings without being soggy. The Chicken Tenders are also crispy and tasty cooked in fresh oil. Luigi's is expensive but worth it."

"We are a huge fan of their 16" - Large Vegan Pizza. Their crust tastes great, and they put the right amount of cheese on it and make it bubbly. I also enjoy their hot sandwiches, the Chicken Francese parm hero is my favorite."

16" - Large Cheese Pizza

Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!

$27.15

Garlic Knots

Tossed with Garlic, Oil, Parmesan Cheese & Fresh Parsley. Melted Mozzarella Available

$5.49

12" - Medium Cheese Pizza

Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!

$19.48

Plain

Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese - Click to add Toppings!

$4.83

Savianos Pizza & Restaurant

(200+)

$0 delivery fee • 6.7 mi • 34 min

"The best pizza and Italian on the island!"

"Best Homemade Meatballs around my favorite and Buffalo Chicken (Sliced Pizza) was huge and delicious with an extensive menu I look forward to trying more every thing is fresh and made daily"

Neopolitan Pie (Regular)

Hearty ground beef sauteed in a creamy pink vodka sauce tossed with penne

$27.61

Penne Alla Vodka

Fried chicken cutlets topped with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese

$25.88

Neopolitan (Sliced Pizza)

Baked Italian bread basted with fresh garlic, evo and imported spices

$4.25

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero

Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots, black olives, roasted peppers & Italian dressing

$18.22

La Slice Pizzeria

$0 delivery fee • 4.9 mi • 40 min

• Pickup • Takeout

"Sicilian Slice was good, nice crunch on the crust. chicke wings (12) were great, love the bbq sauce. chicken roll was fresh, nice amount of sauce and cheese balance. "

"Definitely my go to store! Saved me making dinner quite a few times. Food is always delicious, alla vodka is so good, great portion size, still steaming hot when it arrived, which is always a plus! garlic knot (6) were on point. meat stromboli very flavorful, as usual the Regular Slice as well as the Sicilian Slice are delicious! So glad I found this spot, by far a hidden gem. Big thank you to La Slice for making my life a little easier and more delicious"

Regular Pie

romaine lettuce, croutons, homemade dressing

$21.68

Regular Slice

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

$3.59

Coniglio's

(300+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.7 mi • 46 min

20% off, up to $12

"CHICKEN FLORENTINA comes as a solid portion size. Chicken was juicy and vegetables fresh. 10" ROUND WOOD FIRED (Build your Margherita Pizza) Healthy amount of sauce and cheese on full range of crust texture. Fresh ingredients prepared with care."

"The only reason this didn't get a full 5 dtar was because we ordered bbq wings but got buffalo wings. the buffalo wings were fantastic just wasn't what we ordered. literally everything that came was cooked to perfection! the plain pizza was amazing the build your pizza with ham, sausage, peperoni was sooo delicious, the garlic knots were soft warm and garlicy as they should be and the buffalo wings were perfectly cooked wings."

Old Town Pizza

(600+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.8 mi • 44 min

$6 off on $47+

"The salad slice..lettuce nice and crisp, crust cooked to perfection and the sauce/dressing always delicious! "

"The 6 Garlic Parm Wings were a big surprise! Big pieces, juicy, and the particular mixture they use is really tasty. Cheese Pie (l) was great as always. Fr Calamari_Marinara was so-so. A little undercooked, maybe."

Cheese Pie (l)

(6) battered mozzarella sticks served with tomato dipping sauce

$26.33

Chicken Parm Roll

Crispy cannoli shell filled to order with creamy cannoli cream and chocolate chips

$11.75

Meatball Parm Hero

Fresh orecchiette pasta, chicken, broccoli, oven roasted tomato, artichoke, kalamata olive, and roasted garlic white wine sauce

$17.02

Penne Ala Vodka

jumbo shrimp sauteed with a touch of butter, garlic and white wine

$25.76

Marinelli’s Pizzeria

4.8

(700+)

$0 delivery fee • 9.7 mi • 53 min

"Absolutely fantastic, I've never seen so much chicken in a Chicken Roll"

"I order this wrap at least 2xs a month and each time its delicious. Usually the wrap is grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers with a balsamic glaze. Last nights delivery was disappointing! Fried chicken a little bit of lettuce and a small amount of tomato. Not what I was expecting at all. "

Neapolitan Pizza

Tomato sauce, mozzarella. 18".

$21.16

Regular Pizza Slice

Tomato sauce, mozzarella.

$3.77

Neapolitan personal Pizza

Served with side of marinara sauce. 6 Pieces.

$14.57

Mozzarella Sticks

Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onions, shaved carrots, black olives, and shredded mozzarella.

$9.75

La Bistro

$0 delivery fee • 5.6 mi • 41 min

"the Capellini Alla Vodka was amazing! added breaded chicken, mozzarella and spinach. delicious!!!"

"they put hot Fried Shrimp right from the fryer on top of shredded iceburg lettuce, (not red cabbage cilantro slaw like the menu said), wrapped it up in a wrap, than in paper than in a container. by the time i got the food the lettuce was a slimy mess, the breading on the Fried Shrimp was soggy and falling off in lumps. i took it apart, took the slimy mess off the Fried Shrimp and ate them. the Chicken Parm Roll was cold, the chicken inside was over cooked, dry, tasteless and hard. the shrimp could have been good if it wasn't for the slimy lettuce. the Pasta E Fagioli was ok and so were the zeppole. im disappointed, i thought i found a good, reliable place."

Regular Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$21.15

Garlic Knots

A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.

$4.05

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Fried chicken breast, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

$11.88

Chicken Parm Roll

1 Piece.

$9.43

Furci's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Trattoria

$0 delivery fee • 8.0 mi • 49 min

(500+)

• Salads • Sandwich

"Pizza was perfect crispy and all the ingredients are super fresh! I love the spinach rolls and their meatballs are the best! I've never had a bad meal here!"

"I got the Chicken Francese Hero and Eggplant Hero parm style. I don't like sweet sauces, both sauces (francese and red) are on the sweet side. Even the coating on the eggplant is a bit sweet to me. If you like sugar added to everything you eat, then you might enjoy it. "

Classic Cheese

Thin Square Pizza with Light Cheese & Striped w/ Spicy Marinara Sauce.

$23.56

Pepperoni Bambino (6)

Each.

$7.5

12” Margherita

Greens, red onion, lots of feta, Greek olives & stuffed grape leaves.

$13.97

Garlic Knots (6)

Dipped in egg, sautéed in white wine, lemon & butter. Served on top of a 12” brick oven pizza

Zara's Pizza

$0 delivery fee • 4.1 mi • 38 min

• Takeout • Italian

"I stopped getting pizza anywhere else bc its not worth the headache. Zaras is on point and perfect EVERY SINGLE TIME. I make all types of crazy requests and they never miss a beat. Its not just the pizza either. All of their food is delicious. If im going to try a dish for the first time and I want to know that its going to be made well and correctly, ill get it through Zaras. Fried food for apps also come perfect. I only order delivery and I can get zucchini sticks or Mac and cheese bites etc and itll show up hot and crunchy! And mind you I do not live around the corner this is going from selden to port jeff area during dinner time. Enough said. Love love love this place! (Pic added is of one of my crazy requests. Just look at the abundance of toppings! its superb, i order this regularly) But you 100% get what you pay for AND THEN SOME! Btw this is just their medium pizza... it weighs as much as i do. "

"We love this place!!! Always consistently delicious and fresh!! They accommodate any request we have had and are very friendly. This is the go to spot for pizza!!! "

X-Large 18" Pizza

Add toppings for an additional charge.

$20.67

Medium 12" Pizza

Add toppings for an additional charge.

$15.73

Garlic Knots (Side Orders)

Rolled baked garlic bread.

$4.55

Fried Mozzarella Sticks (6)

Vodka, Mushroom & Onions in a Pink Sauce.

$9.63

Medford Pastaria

4.4

(3k+)

$0 delivery fee • 7.2 mi • 37 min

"Great pizza as always. Was a nice crispy crust that hits the spot. Sauce is perfect. Cannolies are excellent. And massive. Def not cheating out on the filling. I typically get the rainbowcake That too is amazing. I will be getting both next time. lol eat the cake tomorrow, cannoli night of pizza. Best place around by far. "

"The Fried Calamari and the Pear Salad are delightful. The Fried Calamari is crispy, not very oily, and has substance. Topping it off with lemon makes it pop. The sauce is robust, sits on the tongue well, and is juicy without being very acidic at all. I wish there was a way to order or include more. The Pear Salad is fresh and balanced. The pears taste like Christmas, the candied walnuts are fun, and the lettuce and gorgonzola are crisp and fresh. The dressing is great but not necessary with all the above elements. It is a personal choice. Portions are great. My partner and I are were able to split both items and have leftovers for the day after. Note: you may want to either air fry or stick the Fried Calamari in the oven to reheat so it doesn't get soggy."

18" Large Pizza

Breaded chicken tomato sauce and cheese sandwich.

$26.21

Alla Vodka Sauce

Add a side of sauce for additional fees.

$24.33

Garlic Knots 6

Smooth tube shaped pasta.

$6.6

Chicken Parmigiana Entree

Add toppings for an additional charge.

$25.58

La Famosa Pizzaria

$0 delivery fee • 4.5 mi • 38 min

20% off, up to $10

"La Famosa is an excellent pizzeria with delicious food. The Garlic Bread with Cheese & Pepperoni had a generous amount of pepperoni, which is much appreciated. You should definitely try the Vodka Slice too. The Cannoli had a generous helping of cream too"

"Wow I was impressed I order chicken franchese with spaghetti flavor is so on point and texture wow good job!! And my family is Italian"

Regular Pie

Classic cheese or create your own pie

$22.95

Regular Slice

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$3.84

Garlic Knots

Tossed in BBQ or buffalo sauce.

$5.53

Fried Mozzarella Sticks

Fresh mozzarella cheese, pomodoro sauce, fresh basil.

$10.02

Pop pops pizza

Pizza • Italian

$0 delivery fee • 1.3 mi • 52 min

Carlo's Pizza Oven

$0 delivery fee • 5.0 mi • 41 min

"Love Carlos. Over the years I have never been disappointed with anything. Great Pizza. Great entrees. My only issue with them was that they did not deliver and even now that they use DoorDash, it's expensive to get the pizza or food items delivered, but it is worth it. "

"Chicken rollatini was amazing, huge portion. Shrimp & lobster in bisque were tough & the bisque was a bit tomatoey. Baked clams were delicious & so were zeppoles"

Cheese (Large ( 8 Slices))

Chopped or whole little neck clams.

$27.01

Mozzarella Sticks With Sauce

lettuce, tomato, and mayo.

$8.36

Cheese (Small (6 Slices))

Roasted red peppers and fresh Mozzarella.

$20.32

10" Personal Pizza

Philly style cheese steak, sautéed onions & your choice of cheese.

$13.93

Pizzaiolo Gourmet Eatery

$0 delivery fee • 6.9 mi • 46 min

"Haven't had a bad choice here yet."

"The pizza was okay, nothing special. We have a plethora of great pizza options in the area and wanted to try something new. I would not order here a second time. "

Neapolitan Cheese Pizza (Large 18")

Round pizza with cheese.

$23.74

Garlic Knot (6 Pieces)

A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Boneless breast of chicken with marinara sauce, parmesan, and melted mozzarella.

$14.86

Neapolitan Pizzette

Mozzarella cheese and pizza sauce.

$15

Mary's Pizza and Pasta

(900+)

$0 delivery fee • 6.8 mi • 36 min

"my parents have been getting mary's pizza, so when i come home on leave i always get it as my first meal back since california doesnt compare to NY style pizza. mary's has never let me down with how good it is."

"Mary's has the best pizza in Suffolk County ( & beyond)! Magherita & Penne Grandma are our favorites!!"

Regular Cheese Pizza

Large.

$24.85

Penne Alla Vodka

Pink cream and vodka sauce with touch of prosciutto.

$24.17

Chicken Parm Hero

Chicken cutlets, tomato sauce, and mozzarella on toasted Italian bread.

$16.75

Mozzarella Sticks

(6) Italian breaded mozzarella sticks, served with side of tomato sauce.

$9.73

Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria

$0 delivery fee • 3.8 mi • 41 min

• Pickup • Pizza

"The Neapolitan Round Pizza (18") and Mozzarella Sticks NEVER FAIL. The food is always hot and delicious each time we order. We order out at least once a week and Goomba Johnnys is our go to when we do. The staff is always nice and helpful, service is quick and efficient, and the food quality and taste is incredible every time. The ham and cheese calzone is my all time favorite! The portion is huge that I have enough for lunch for work the next day. Definitely recommend Gomba Johnny's."

"On Nov. 7th Vinny Delivered Chicken Frances's they offer chef excellence 5 star quality ownership 5Star time logistics delivery Steaming hot to andsome fuel to my fincee healing from a very intrusive painful back surgery taking the weight of worry in cooking. A taste of Italy with exceptional manners and good taste A++++++++ Thank you Goomba Johnnies delivery and DoorDash ---"

Neapolitan Round Pizza (18")

Fried chicken cutlets, fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce on garlic bread.

$24.36

The Goomba Hero

1/2 doz

$15.5

Garlic Knots

Parmigiana cheese, cream, vodka, and sundried tomatoes with a touch of tomato sauce.

$8.8

Sicilian Pizza

12 piece

$27.28

Donatina's Neapolitan Pizza Cafe

$0 delivery fee • 7.9 mi • 46 min

(5k+)

• Pizza

15% off, up to $13

"Our go to pizza place! The crust on every Detroit Sliceis out of this world . The Arugula Salad is always fresh & delicious & the grilled chicken is perfection. If arugula isn't your thing, their Cesar salad is great too! If you haven't tried them yet, do it now. "

"The grilled chicken & broccoli looked too good to wait to take a picture. It lived up to the visual. I loved the seasonings, and chicken was moist. The juice made the leftovers of the large portion made re-heat as great. Will order again."

16" Round

Hand crushed tomato sauce, grande mozzarella cheese, oregano, sea salt and EVOO.

$23.41

Margherita

San marzano tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, fresh basil and EVOO.

$17.09

Cheese Slice

SERVED WITH TOMATO SAUCE

$4.34

6pc. Garlic Knots

SERVED WITH TOMATO SAUCE

$6.49

Pompei Pizzeria & Restaurant