Order the best Italian near New Middletown, OH
Best Italian Restaurants Nearby in New Middletown
Papa Gege’s Italian Villa
4.7
(500+)$0 delivery fee • 6.4 mi • 59 min
Farther away
"I have ordered the Village Roll three times now. The previous two times the item did not accompany the other dinner orders. Today, I ordered just the Roll, and as per usual, when the item actually arrives, it was delicious. Everything from this restaurant is great quality. I will give this 5 stars"
"Eggplant Parmigiana is just one of my favorites to order.Large portions and best tasting Italian food in Boardman. Fried Mozzarella Zucchini is crispy and delicious. Was so happy when they joined doordash"
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta Salad and Garlic Knots.
Petite (2-3 people)
Medio (4-5 people)
Grande (6-7 people)
$23.68
Cheese
Baked Rigatoni with Pasta Salad and Garlic Knots.
Petite (2-3 people)
Medio (4-5 people)
Grande (6-7 people)
$24.16
Pepperoni Roll
Lady fingers soaked in espresso, layered with mascarpone cheese and finished with chocolate sauce
$6.79
Cavatelli Marinara
Eggplant Parmigana with Pasta Salad and Garlic Knots.
Petite (2-3 people)
Medio (4-5 people)
Grande (6-7 people)
$22.42
Capo Di Carbs
$
$0 delivery fee • 4.7 mi • 38 min
Newly Added
Vodka Made Me Do It
Rigatoni in pink vodka sauce topped with crispy chicken, melted mozzarella, and Romano cheese.
$18.5
Tira-Miss-You
Classic tiramisu layered with espresso-soaked cake and creamy mascarpone filling.
$8.99
Alfredo No Regrets
Penne tossed in rich Alfredo sauce with grilled chicken and Romano cheese. Decisions were made.
$18.5
Mozzarella Fried
Crispy mozzarella served with Sunday sauce. Loyal to the last cheese pull.
$11.99
Poland Belleria
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 4.7 mi • 37 min
"Would rate 10 stars if I could. Antipasto salad was superb! Ingredients were fresh & diced beautifully! Also ordered off my previously ordered menu. Thought I ordered a Deluxe Pizza; when I actually ordered Deluxe Calzone to my surprise! It was EXCELLENT, as well! We live 20 minutes out. Calzone was received very warm. Belleria Poland has never disappointed! Great job ALWAYS!! "
"My fried vegetable basket had barely any fried veggies in and very poor portion compared to the price."
Traditional Pizza - 12" Pizza
Homemade dough filled and rolled with pepperoni and chewy mozzarella cheese.
$14.41
Traditional Pizza - Half Sheet
A generous portion of lettuce with tomatoes, onions, pepperoncini, olives and hard-boiled eggs topped with french fries, seasoned tender chicken or steak strips and covered with mozzarella cheese. Served with your choice of dressing. When ordering fries on the side, for additional cost to cover packaging and time.
$18.57
Traditional Bone-in
Served with 2 meatballs and our homemade sauce.
$12.15
Hot Chips served with French Onion Dip on Side.
Tender breaded chicken breast covered with cheese and homemade sauce served with a side of spaghetti.
$9.23
Blue Wolf Tavern
4.7
(900+)$0 delivery fee • 8.8 mi • 48 min
Farther away
"Kids Grilled Steak was good and flavorful the pasta side was a little skimpy compared to the last order. Kids Grilled Chicken was good as well and again was a little skimpy on the pasta compared to my last order. I love the packaging because the food is really secure. Portions are good for the price. Will definitely order again!"
"1st time ordering but not the 1st time having their food. Everything I ordered was great. Kids Chicken Parm and Pup Burger were both fresh and tasty. The portion size was great for me. The sweet potato fries were good just wish they were crispy and had a little more cinnamon sugar and maple because we couldn't really taste any maple but still good. Definitely ordering again."
Wolf Wings
Ten jumbo wings lightly beaded, crispy fried, choice of sauce: Hot, Mild, Barbeque, Spicy Barbeque, Garlic, Garlic Parmesan, Cajun, Ranch, Buffalo Ranch, Teriyaki, Sweet & Hot Thai Chili, Honey Mustard.
$15.47
Kids Grilled Steak
Prime Angus Reserve, 5oz. hand-cut, seasoned & grilled to temperature.
$13.17
Blackened Chicken Alfredo
Choice of pasta, creamy Alfredo, Cajun blackened chicken.
$23.72
Grilled Chicken Alfredo
Choice of pasta, creamy Alfredo, grilled chicken.
$23.27
Bogey’s Bar and Grill
4.6
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.3 mi • 47 min
Farther away
"You may Love the Pasta, and Sause; but Try-out The Beer Battered Jumbo Haddock Dinner, and their Awesome Calamari Fritti! It's amazing, and Hands-down; the BEST of Loweville, Ohio. Try it, the Next time, You're in Town!Blessings."
"Probably the first 5 Star I've left.. Bogey's is simply ALWAYS good. I've lived in the area for years (3mi away) been here many times. Ordered the full Rack BBQ Rib for the first time, and WOW! Simply Delicious! Their Haddock is amazing too, anyway you get it. Large Portions, and I mean LARGE portions of sides, it's just a great place to get a meal, and you'll likely have some left over to pick at later, big points there to Bogey's.
I will say tonight I had just one issue, though normally perfect, the Steamed Broccoli was a tad under cooked. The Wild Rice is ALWAYS good, perfect subtle seasoning. Order you won't regret it."
Bogey's Wings
Best buffalo wings this side of the mahoning river!
$12.98
Beer Battered Jumbo Haddock Dinner
Fresh Haddock Filet, prepared to your liking, served with choice of two sides.
$17.43
Chicken Parmigiana
Fresh Boneless Chicken Breasts, hand breaded, crispy fried, served on a bed of spaghetti pasta, topped with Italian cheeses & smothered in our homestyle tomato sauce.
$21.79
Homestyle Pasta Dinner
Fav! Roma Tomatoes, seasoned greens, Italian cheeses, crispy fried, served with a side of marinara sauce.
$16.44
Red Plum Pizza and Pasta
4.7
(300+)$0 delivery fee • 8.9 mi • 90 min
Farther away
"I absolutely love their pizza and the rolls with peppers are absolutely amazing! Super lucky to have this so close to my house. I always get red plum on the weekends. I highly suggest trying it you won't regret it!"
"This is hands down without a doubt the best New LG NEW YORK BROOKLYN pizza I've ever had. The dough is chewy and crisp and the ingredients are all super fresh. The hot SIDE HOT PEPPERS IN OIL were delicious and crunchy. This will be my new go to pizza place."
10 WINGS
MOZZARELLA, ROMANO, RED SAUCE
$17.82
MED NEW YORK CHEESE
CUP & CHAR PEPPERONI, MOZZARELLA, ROMANO, RED SAUCE
$16
LG NEW YORK PEPPERONI
MOZZARELLA, PARMESAN, SUNDAY SAUCE
$23.53
CHEESY GARLIC BREAD
MOZZARELLA, FRESH RICOTTA, WHITE CHEDDAR, ROMANO, FRESH BASIL, RED SAUCE
$10.38
Pizza Joe's
4.7
(300+)$0 delivery fee • 5.4 mi • 38 min
Farther away
"We ordered the 12 square cut pepperoni and sausage and it was SO good. Even my picky child loved it! The sauce had really good flavor as well. "
"ive ordered from here several times i've gotten their pizzas wings fried mushrooms Battered Mushrooms every time its hot fresh and delicious"
Veggie Pizza
Spices, broccoli & cauliflower, white sauce, Romano, Cheddar/mozzarella. 243-322 Cal.
$15.01
Wings
4.6 calories per wing, sauces range from 0-55 calories per wing.
$14.02
Garlic Knots
1980 calories. Seasoned thin crust with mozzarella cheese.
$6.78
Original Dip-N-Stix
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
$7.87
Belleria Pizza
4.4
(900+)$0 delivery fee • 10.7 mi • 51 min
Farther away
"everytime i order from here it's premo taste. the taste is so good and real. friendly people in the store as well. Meatball Sandwich is amazing and the Italian sub is to die for. the dressing really brings it all together. the square pizza is the best out of them all."
"Significantly overpriced and lacking in flavor for the price. But on the positive, everything came very well packaged and organized and also nothing was missing. But unfortunately I will not be ordering again. You can get more flavor at Domino's and not spend a fortune."
Traditional Pizza | 12"
A traditional Italian soup with greens and tiny meatballs in a delicious chicken broth.
$19.1
Rudy’s Homemade Wedding Soup
Small.
$7.24
Pepperoni Roll
A large steaming bed of spaghetti and two homemade meatballs covered with our homemade sauce. All dinners include salad, bread and butter.
$10.24
Spaghetti
Served homemade sauce.
$16.1
Pizza Hut
4.5
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.5 mi • 43 min
Farther away
"The staff absolutely did their thing with our dinner box the pizza and cheese sticks were made perfectly the boneless wings were good as well "
"was exactly as expected for what I payed,well worth the 50 bucks,it was fresh the sauce was great crust wasn't flimsy or moist like some of the other pizza options in the area,we bought the Big Dinner Box and was well worth the money,who ever manages this pizza hut has there store in tip top shape and has chosen employees who actually work and aren't just there for a paycheck and it shows in the food,if you want your money to be worth it,pizza hut in struthers is a very good option"
Create Your Own Pizza
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$21.43
Personal Pan Pizza®
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$8.31
My Hut Box
Choice of entrée: 2-top. Personal Pan Pizza, full or half melt, or 6 wings. Choice of side: fries or 4 wings. Wings are boneless or bone-in. Melt dipping sauce incl. Addt'l charge for extra cheese/toppings.
$9.77
Cheese Sticks
A side everyone can agree on! Get these cheese sticks sprinkled with flavorful Italian seasoning and a cup of our delicious marinara.
$9.31
BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse
4.3
(10k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.9 mi • 47 min
Farther away
"The BJ's Brewhouse Bowl With Salmon* was delicious. A generous piece of Fish and an excellent selection of vegetables. We selected it Blackened and it was cooked to perfection. It was quite satisfying."
"The rice pilaf was moist and flavorful. The asparagus wasn't overcooked. The steak with mushroom and onions made medium well was hot fresh and delicious. The portion was on point! I will be ordering again."
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken breast
$20.75
Pizookie® Trio
fettuccini
$13.32
Jumbo Spaghetti And Meatballs
creamy alfredo
$20.72
Chocolate Chunk Pizookie®
steamed broccoli
$8.34
MAC HAUS
4.3
(300+)$0 delivery fee • 4.7 mi • 41 min
"The stuffed hot peppers were perfectly cooked and very tasty! Best ive had from a restaurant by far!!! Portion size for two was great, will definitely be ordering these again. Happy with both bowls of Mac. Huge portions great taste will be eating these bowls for multiple meals great execution on everything"
"SMASH-N-DASH looked amazing and the first bite was cheesy and creamy. First time eating here will definitely be coming back for more. My portion size was enough for two people easily and it was still hot and fresh when it got to me. They wrap the to go container in plastic wrap."
C.B.R.
Crowd favorite energy. Creamy mac and cheese blended with cheddar and mozzarella, loaded with crispy chicken and smoky bacon, finished with a cool drizzle of ranch and a crunchy crown of buttery Ritz crackers. Comfort food with confidence.
$19.45
ROCK LOBSTA
This one rocks. Creamy mac packed with tender lobster, melted Muenster and mozzarella, then crowned with a golden crunch of buttery Ritz crackers. Rich, cheesy, and ready to steal the show.
$21.13
SMASH-N-DASH
This one does not play fair. Creamy mac and cheese topped with crispy fried chicken, golden fries, crunchy onion rings, smoky bacon, melty pepper jack cheese, and a bold drizzle of BBQ sauce. Loud, loaded, and absolutely unapologetic.
$19.98
PLAIN JANE
No frills, all thrills. Creamy cheddar mac and cheese topped with a golden crunch of buttery Ritz crackers. Classic, cozy, and always the right choice.
$17.87
Little Caesars
4.4
(800+)$0 delivery fee • 6.9 mi • 50 min
Farther away
"Custom round with extra cheese and pepperoni was awesome! Forgot to take a picture of the whole pizza but this will do, and an excellent value too!"
"Awful. Surprised bc this location is usually good, but the cheese sticks were old and dry, there were no breadsticks available, there was no seasoning on the cheese sticks, the pizza crust was hard and chewy... just awful. Will go to another LC next time."
ExtraMostBestest® Pepperoni
Large round pizza with more Pepperoni and Cheese than our Classic Pizza
$9.63
ExtraMostBestest® Cheese
Large round pizza with more Cheese than our Classic Pizza
$9.63
Slices-N-Stix®
Four slices of Pepperoni pizza combined with eight Italian Cheese Stix, plus Crazy Sauce®
$8.43
Custom Round Pizza
large Pizza with toppings of your choice
$11.23
Belleria Pizzeria
4.4
(3k+)$0 delivery fee • 11.2 mi • 50 min
Farther away
"Best pizza in the world every bite was the best tasted everything"
"steak salad was the same size as the side salad that came with the spaghetti dinner and only a few pieces of steak... the sauce was all over in the inside of the bag.. the garlic sticks were way over baked. very disappointed and won't order from this one again"
Traditional Cheese (12" Pizza)
Medium...8 Slices
$18.21
Traditional Cheese Pizza (Half Sheet)
Large...12 Slices
$22.46
Traditional Cheese (6" Pizza)
Personal...2 slices
$8.81
Grilled Chicken Salad
A generous portion of lettuce with tomatoes, olives, onion, and hard-boiled egg topped with French fries, seasoned tender steak strips and covered with shredded mozzarella cheese. Served with your choice of dressing.
$13.5
Red Lobster
4.3
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 5.8 mi • 41 min
Farther away
$10 off on $65+
"The most expensive DoorDash order I have ever put it in but it was my 70th birthday and my ex-domestic partner served me with eviction papers and I haven't had Red Lobster in over 8 years, so what the heck, right? They did not disappoint!!! I had the Ultimate Feast® and my daughter had the New! Crabfest Boil and OMG! Half Dozen Cheddar Bay Biscuits® are always a plus and always fresh! The food was packaged so well that it arrived very warm. It was fresh and very, very tasty. The Mocktails tasted just like the alcohol version, maybe better! I wish I could order again but gotta pay for a lawyer!!! Thank you Red Lobster for the wonderful birthday dinner."
"The lobster tail was disappointingly small for the price of the dish. The steak wasn't bad. One of my sides was missing (bacon Mac and cheese). The pasta was tasty but overly sauced and also perhaps also not worth the price. The biscuits were delicious."
Shrimp Linguini Alfredo
Shrimp in a house-made creamy garlic Alfredo sauce on a bed of linguini.
1010 Cal
$18.48
Seafood-Stuffed Mushrooms
Signature seafood topping and Monterey Jack cheese.
360 Cal
$11.49
Create Your Own Ultimate Feast®
Choose 2 Premium and 2 Classic selections. Served with your choice of sides.
1080 Cal - 2260 Cal
$43.89
Admiral's Feast
Walt's Favorite Shrimp, wild-caught flounder, clam strips and bay scallops, all crisped to a golden-brown. Served with cocktail and tartar sauces and your choice of two sides.
1670 Cal
$27.02
Subway
4.3
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 0.2 mi • 44 min
"B.M.T.® had everything I wanted, not too much lettuce and all the pickles I wanted 🤤"
"Love this salad normally- but it was LOADED with onions and I cant eat them so I wasted $$ today. I order this a lot andsomehow I missed unclicking onion this time?? Delivery was fine- but why did it come from new Middletown when tgeres 3 with 5 min of here"
Oven-Roasted Turkey
Oven-roasted Turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo served on our freshly baked Artisan Italian bread.
$10.26
6 Pack Cookie Box
Our 6 Pack Cookie Box is the most delicious out-of-the-box thinking. Pick your favorite flavor and enjoy a half-dozen of fresh-baked cookies. One for you, one for him, one for her and even more to keep sharing…or not! Get the New 6 Pack Cookie Box today and get that sweet treat you’re craving.
$4.19
Grilled Chicken
Tender grilled chicken, Monterey cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo served on our freshly baked Artisan Italian bread.
$11.67
Meatball
Meatballs, marinara sauce, provolone cheese & parmesan cheese served on our freshly baked Artisan Italian bread.
$9.85
Riser Tavern & Grill
4.8
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 6.2 mi • 36 min
Farther away
"Order came exactly as ordered. Wings were excellent and hot chips were crispy and not greasy."
"my 12 Confit Wings had no sauce and were burnt, idk what happened, I used to eat there all the time and the lemon aoili was my favorite but today was a huge disappointment, luckily I got a refund because I sent pictures. the Crab Rangoon Dip was extremely underwhelming but unfortunately that can't be demonstrated with pictures."
Chicken Tenders
Hand Breaded Gerber Chicken Tenders, Choice of Dipping Sauce. Served with Fries.
$17.51
12 Confit Wings
2 Smash Patties, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Smash Sauce.
$22.37
Smash Burger
House Made Pretzel Served with Beer Cheese, Queso & Bavarian Mustard.
$18.84
Riser Knotty Pretzel
Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cucumber, Mozzarella, Hard-Boiled Egg, Steak, French Fries.
$15
Magic Tree Pub and Eatery
4.3
(800+)$0 delivery fee • 5.7 mi • 39 min
Farther away
"I got 2 Magic Haddock Dinner s with a salad and 2 sides. in the picture it's only half of the beer batter fish I got in my dinner. I got fries with mine as well and my daughter got the grilled green beans which are awesome. everything was great and if you've never been you should stop in they've got a cute place and great food that's all fresh, local, and good value for money spent."
"I love Magic Tree Edamame App. Best in town but the portion size is extremely small I wish they have size options because when you order a meal you get the same size as an appetizer I would definitely pay more for a larger portion size"
Fried Chicken Tenders
Southern fried chicken tenderloins with a choice of a side and 1 dipping sauce.
$17.32
Magic Haddock Dinner
Beer battered, broiled, or panko breaded haddock filet, served with tartar sauce & two sides
$22.11
Twisted Time Pretzel
House made one pound pretzel, buttered, salted
Choose three dippers
$16.51
Cheeseburger
Brisket blend patty, choice of cheese, brioche bun
Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle upon request
Add Bacon for $2
$16.19
Avalon Downtown
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 10.7 mi • 63 min
Farther away
"This was my first time trying anything from the Avalon, I was not disappointed. My order consisted of a 14" pepperoni pizza and house salad. My salad was so fresh, delicious, and the dressing was amazing. Now for the pizza, it was so good and I could taste all the great flavors of the beef pepperoni, the cheese, crust , and the sauce was on point."
"This place is good 100%. Just a 2 Gripes. The Margherita pizza tasted fantastic 100% but the dough was about a half inch to 3/4" thick. So I tasted more dough than my toppings. when I did taste the toppings, it was great. the sauce is nice and sweet, the tomatoes were sliced thin, the cheese was crisp yet had a pull still. The pesto was good too. just need that dough a bit thinner and I think this would be a 10/10. My only other complaint is if im spending $15 on calamari, id expect more than just a small handful of it. it tasted great as well and the cocktail sauce it came with tasted good as well. Im definitely gonna eat here again dont get me wrong. But I just wanted to put my 2 cents in. 14" Margherita Pizza Fried Calamari"
12" Traditional Pizza
Tomato sauce and blended Mozzarella and Provolone.
$21
14" Traditional Pizza
Tomato sauce, blended Mozzarella and Provolone.
$24.06
Pepperoni Roll
Pepperoni, provolone cheese, and Avalon dough with marinara sauce.
$13.41
12" Brier Hill Pizza
Tomato sauce, sweet peppers, imported Romano.
$18.22
Jersey Mike's Subs
4.7
(6k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.1 mi • 36 min
Farther away
"The #9, Club Supreme was delicious. Fresh ingredients, generous portions."
"The subs are good, but I ordered double meat on the Italian and all they did was quadrupled the ham. No extra on any other meats. $26 for a sub you would think it shouldn't be an issue. Last time I'll order here for a long while if ever again."
Chips
Provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoniServed Mike's Way with onions, lettuce, tomato, vinegar, oil, oregano, and salt.
$2.06
#13 The Original Italian
Provolone and TurkeyServed Mike's Way with onions, lettuce, tomato, vinegar, oil, oregano, and salt.
$14.61
#7 Turkey and Provolone
Turkey, ham, provolone, applewood smoked bacon & mayoServed Mike's Way with onions, lettuce, tomato, vinegar, oil, oregano, and salt.
$12.76
#8 Club Sub
Grilled onions, peppers & white American cheese.
$14.22
G's Pizza World - Washingtonville
4.6
(600+)$0 delivery fee • 12.1 mi • 54 min
Farther away
"12 Inch (8 Slices) Excellent as always. fresh dough. plenty of cheese and toppings. still my go to pizza in the salem area."
"Excellent as always. The 12 Inch (8 Slices) is my go-to for pizza. The 4 Pcs. (I requested all dark and they always accommodate this) was crispy and moist. Prices are exceedingly reasonable. Never disappointed."
16 Inch (12 Slices)
Includes any three traditional items.
$16.82
12 Inch (8 Slices)
Two wings, two thighs, two legs and two breast.
$13.91
Boneless Chicken Wings
Three wings, three thighs, three legs and three breasts.
$11.56
Breaded Mushrooms
Includes tomato, Cheddar cheese, black olives, yellow pepper rings and fries.
$6.46
Papa Johns Pizza
4.5
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 5.7 mi • 38 min
Farther away
"The Works pizza was delicious!! It was warm upon delivery and cooked just right. The sauce was light so even though I was eating it late at night, it didn't set heavy on my stomach! I would definitely order it again!"
"You get your money's worth. I love me some Papa's. Pizza is always hot and fresh. Even the Brownies we always get, To die forrrr!"
Create Your Own Pizza
Build your own custom pizza and we'll handcraft it for you. With so many delicious options to choose from, your masterpiece is waiting!
$17.52
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni, cheese and pizza sauce on your choice of crust.
$17.07
Cheesesticks
Our original dough covered with Special Garlic Sauce, topped with cheese and baked. Served with original pizza dipping sauce.
$10.81
Cheese Pizza
Cheese and pizza sauce on your choice of crust.
$16.17
Sub Station 46
4.6
(90+)$0 delivery fee • 8.4 mi • 44 min
Farther away
"Taste was good but the grilled chicken salad is half the size it used to be."
"Our 1st time ordering from this store, and now its our new go-to store....The food is fantastic!A must visit place 😋"
Hot Pepper Cheese Balls
Pepperoni, salami, capicola & cheese. Garnished with lettuce, onion, oil and vinegar.
$6.25
Fried Mushrooms
Ham, salami, turkey, cheese. Garnished with lettuce, onion, oil and vinegar.
$5.75
Steak Salad
Garnished with lettuce, onion, oil and vinegar.
$15.75
16. Italian Delight Sandwich - Half
Pepperoni, salami, capicola & cheese. Garnished with lettuce, onion, oil and vinegar.
$10.96
Marco's Pizza
4.4
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.6 mi • 45 min
Farther away
"The Italian Chef salad was really good. It's a pretty decent size too bcuz for that same size salad at PB cost me around $16 and that would be added extras $20. So this will definitely be my new place for salads. I got my go to for pizza magnifico pepperoni w garlic sauce. Always enougb leftovers for the next day. My food was hot and fresh. The tase was delicious. Will definitely keep ordering and trying different items off the menu."
"This was my 1st time having Marcos pizza and it's definitely going to be in rotation for me. The Pepperoni Magnifico® was good and the garlic dipping sauce was good with the pizza too. The pizza was hot and fresh when it arrived. The portion size was good for the price. I made two meals out of it. I heard the salads and sausage pizza are good so I'll try those next time."
Build Your Own
Choose size, choice of crust style, sauce and your favorite toppings
$16.05
Pepperoni Magnifico®
Pepperoni, Old World Pepperoni®, romesan seasoning, garlic sauce crust
$16.51
CheezyBread
Our hand-made dough baked with our three fresh signature cheeses and garlic sauce, served with a side of our original pizza sauce and ranch
$6.71
Big Square Deal
16 square slices with romesan seasoning, plus one topping of your choice
$13.67
Kennsington Grille
4.3
(300+)$0 delivery fee • 9.7 mi • 49 min
Farther away
"Oh my lanta! It was all soooo gooood! The Bone-In Wings 8 were saucey and big, the Loaded Potato Skins were perfectly loaded, the pastas were a great portion, the deserts were superb, wedding soup hit the spot! Definitely hving again!!!"
"Found out after I ordered that they were out of 2 bread puddings. They substituted 2 lime pies, which I detest, especially since theirs is too sweet, has little lime flavor, & is topped with artificial whipped cream. They proceeded to charge an extra $7.98 for the favor.
While I realize that it is the restaurant's option to not substitute, at the prices one pays for Doir Dash nowadays, one should be able to cancel an order or pick something else if vendors are out of item. Not fair to the customer. Other vendors give you the option."
Fork & Knife Hot Turkey
Shaved turkey breast served between two slices of white bread smothered in chicken gravy w/ mashed potatoes
$16.63
Fried Pierogies
Lightly battered pierogies fried till golden & topped with caramelized onions. Includes sour cream
$14.34
Bavarian Chocolate Mousse Cake
Thinly sliced roast beef served between two slices of white bread smothered in beef gravy w/ mashed potatoes
$8.77
Fork & Knife Hot Roast Beef
Choice of one sauce or dry rub seasoning
$17.01
Tic Toc Food Mart
4.2
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 1.0 mi • 30 min
Wallet-Friendly
"Way too much salt on fries, but this never happens. Food is delicious!"
"I order 3 different meats in 1/2 pounds and ham in 1 pound. I got 1 of the half pounds plus a phone message that they don't sell 1/4 pounds. Don't order if you're hungry "
Double Cheeseburger
2 Juicy Burger Patty, cooked on our grill with a fresh Kaiser Bun
$8.02
King Size Candy
Choose from our Variety of Candy.
$3.34
Large Chicken Sandwich
Deep Fried Large size Chicken Patty on a fresh Kaiser roll.
$6.36
16" Round Cheese
16" Round (12 slices).
Includes new and improved sauce and Cheese
Toppings additional $1.25
$15.15
Jimmy John's
4.6
(900+)$0 delivery fee • 7.0 mi • 39 min
Farther away
"turkey tom never dissapoints! also tried the pickle, and definitely worth the 2 bucks!!"
"There was only 1 piece of Turkey barely any lettuce 2 tomatoes there was alot of bacon mayo was only in the middle of sub I could have bought just a sub bun cuz that was about all I tasted."
#9 ITALIAN NIGHT CLUB®
TURKEY, lettuce, tomato & mayo<br />
$10.39
#4 TURKEY TOM®
Soft, buttery, chock full of chips. what more can we say? enjoy.
$10.73
#5 VITO®
PROVOLONE, AVOCADO SPREAD, cucumber, lettuce, tomato & mayo (Shown with Jimmy Peppers®)
$9.34
#11 COUNTRY CLUB®
TURKEY, PROVOLONE, AVOCADO SPREAD, cucumber, lettuce, tomato & mayo
$11.36
Firehouse Subs
4.5
(5k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.2 mi • 44 min
Farther away
"This is my favorite place for subs and sammiches. I can't say if I think subs are too pricy because to me yes but they the same prices every where else. Excellent taste as well as portion sizes. for me I get a whole and split it in 2 meals. better food than fast food and price ends up better"
"This is my 1st time ordering from this establishment, and it may be my new FAV! 😋 I got a "bogo" deal Italian,+ on wheat bread 🍞The sauce is sweet & savory!!generous amounts of meat and produce!!! I will ddefinitely order from "Firehouse Subs" again!!!!! Impeccable 1st impression, Ladies 'n Sirs !!!! Thank You! 🙂🫡🙃 P.S. Love that you list all the protein grams on every Sammie 💪"
Italian
Genoa salami, pepperoni, Virginia honey ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, deli mustard, and Italian dressing and seasoning. ** Protein grams based on medium size. Subs are made to order and actual amounts may vary.
$14.52
Firehouse Meatball®
Italian meatballs, melted provolone, zesty marinara & Italian seasoning. ** Protein grams based on medium size. Subs are made to order and actual amounts may vary.
$14.59
Smoked Turkey Breast
Smoked turkey breast and Provolone, served Fully Involved® (mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, deli mustard, and a pickle spear on the side). * Protein grams based on medium size. Subs are made to order and actual amounts may vary.
$14.37
Soups
Creamy potato soup loaded with tender potatoes, savory bacon, sharp cheddar cheese, onions, chives, and a hint of pepper.
$6.33
Pizza N Gyro
4.6
(700+)$0 delivery fee • 11.0 mi • 43 min
Farther away
"Great Food -- for The Per-Dollar, Total-Cost and Will be Back for: The Lamb Gyro - Sandwich, The Chicken & Lamb Over Rice Platter & Chicken & Lamb Over Rice and with Grilled Green Peppers!!! We Loved and Ate it ---ALL. Lol!!!! ;) ;) :P Blessings, Everyone. We'll Be Ordering it All; Even Next-Month, too of August // 2026!"
"This is the first time Ihave had them and I was pleasantly impressed! the 4pc Garlic Parm Wings are HUGE and nice and crispy.the Chicken & Lamb Over Rice is a very large portion that I can eat over 2 ddays. Taste is phenomenal. I would order again in a heartbeat!"
Chicken & Lamb Over Rice
Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Onion, Cucumber Sauce, and Lamb rolled on a pita
$14.84
Lamb Gyro - Combo
Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Onion, Cucumber Sauce, and Lamb on a pita
$13.63
Lamb Gyro - Sandwich
Golden-brown fish fillets paired with a generous serving of crispy fries.
$10.06
Lamb Over Rice
Rich, creamy cake with on a buttery graham cracker crust
$15.2
Pizza Joe's
4.4
(500+)$0 delivery fee • 12.6 mi • 50 min
Farther away
"some of the best pizza around!Fresh taste, great sauce, perfect ratio of sauce, cheese and crust!Brownies are a gooey chocolate delight!"
"Two 12 cut Cheese Pizzas for $25. is worth every penny. big slices and was hot and fresh. will order again!"
Build Your Own Traditional Style Pizza (8 - Cut Round)
Fresh dough, delicious sauce, 100% real Romano and mozzarella cheese.
$13.57
Dip-n-stix
"A great appetizer" fresh dough, pressed thin, topped with spices and cheese and served with a side of dip-n-sauce.
$7.94
Build Your Own Traditional Style Pizza (12 - Cut Square)
Fresh dough, delicious sauce, 100% real Romano and mozzarella cheese.
$17.86
Wings 6pc
Fresh dough with cinnamon topping, baked and topped with sweet icing.
$10.73
DiBella's Subs
4.6
(3k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.3 mi • 39 min
Farther away
"Huge sandwiches! Ordered "medium" 10" subs and they were 3x bigger than subway and quality was 100x better. "
"This was my first order from DiBella's, I had the 10" turkey sub. I was disappointed because it didn't look anything like the photo, there was hardly anything inside! I didn't care much for the bread either. I did take my own snap but it wasn't from the side so there's nothing to compare. My whole ticket was $30.01, a lot of money for a not so good meal. "
Godfather
Genoa salami, capicola, spicy ham with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise and DiBella's Famous Oil Dressing on a fresh-baked everything or sesame roll. Customize it to make it your own!
$16.8
DiBella's Cheesesteak
Grilled steak with grilled sweet peppers, onions, mayonnaise and American cheese on a fresh-baked sesame roll. Customize it to make it your own!
$18.45
Turkey
Turkey, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise, American cheese with DiBella’s Famous Oil Dressing on a fresh-baked sesame roll. Customize it to make it your own!
$15.97
Build Your Own - Pick Two Meats
Start with two deli meats and add all your favorite condiments and toppings!
$17.44
Bulldogs Bar & Grill
4.6
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 2.3 mi • 27 min
"Salad was very skimpy, but overal everything tasted great! The deep fried green beans were AMAZING!!! "
"Food was hot and ready when I arrived to pick up. However ranch was given with the wings instead of requested blue cheese. The salad is advertised with French fries but was not received with any and the Hot Pepper Cheese Balls were hard from overcooking."
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Fried chicken tossed in buffalo ranch, wrapped with fresh lettuce, and shredded cheddar.
$15.52
Steak Hoagie
Thinly sliced steak smothered with peppers, onions, mushrooms, and provolone cheese on a toasted hoagie roll.
$15.69
Hot Pepper Cheese Balls
Creamy pepper jack cheese balls, lightly breaded and fried to a crispy golden brown, served with cool ranch for dipping.
$10.7
Chicken Tenders basket
3 juicy southern-styled battered chicken tenders deep fried to golden brown served with your choice of fries or chips.
$13.36
Gyro Bar and Grill
4.3
(800+)$0 delivery fee • 5.4 mi • 39 min
Farther away
"There is so much food and it is all such high quality and the chicken is amazingly seasoned and the gyro is perfect"
"The gyro meat was dry and tough. Almost like I was eating Lamb jerky. I paid an extra $4 for a combo and got a TINY amount of French fries and no drink. (aren't combos supposed to include a drink?) The Philly pizza did not have enough cheese on it and the pizza dough seemed like it was frozen pre-made. This part, I don't think, is the restaurants fault but everything was cold when it arrived. I will not be eating from here again."
Gyro
Grilled lamb topped with lettuce, onion, tomatoes and our homemade cucumber sauce. Add more items at an upcharge.
$10.27
Chicken Over Rice
Choice of side.
$9.24
Mozzarella Sticks
Tender chicken breast topped with fresh onions, tomatoes and lettuce. Served with cucumber sauce.
$5.94
Fried Mushrooms
Yellow rice topped with gyro meat, lettuce and tomato with our homemade white sauce.
$5.99
Westside Bowl
4.6
(5k+)$0 delivery fee • 12.2 mi • 63 min
Farther away
"They barely put any pepperonis on it it had exactly 2 pieces of pepperonis per slice of pizza could of used more but with the sale price not bad deal I had some just cooked an added.Over all flavor great an never over cooked I love that always never burnt an cheese thick an gooey. All there food is good they just started skimping on the topping her in the last 6 months though."
"Westside bowl has the very best Small Calzones in the area! We've tried several other places and still keep coming back. The Small Calzone is very full, mostly sturdy, customizable, and decently sized especially for their pice! Every order has been good from here, not just for a bowling alley but in it's own right as a restaurant!"
12" Pizza
with marinara sauce
$13.16
10 Wings
with Three Toppings
$13.4
16" Pizza
with Three Toppings
$17.72
Fried Pierogi
with Cucumber Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato and Onions
$7.37
McAlister's Deli
4.6
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 5.9 mi • 37 min
Farther away
"King Club sandwich was very good, bursting with flavors from the veggies, meat and cheese, to the condiments. I added horseradish to kick it up a notch. Purchased as a meal with McAlister’s Famous Tea ( which needed to be a bit stronger in my opinion, but still good nevertheless) and a side of potato salad. Pineapple Upside Down Cheesecake was delicious! Sugar Cookie was large in size. ( My son enjoyed that.) I can say without hesitation I have found a new favorite place to eat out at! McAlister's is definitely a hit with my family and this is only our second time ordering from there."
"Bacon Spud and Smokehouse Spud were humongous. These potatoes were easily able to feed at least two people. The Smokehouse Spud was delicious. We ordered Reuben sandwiches and they too were quite tasty. However, I personally would've preferred my sandwich hot and toasted. It was cold. Despite that, the Reuben was still good. It was my first time trying and I was highly impressed. Plan on returning again and I highly recommend the spuds."
Choose 2
Choose two halves of any item and create one great plate.
$14.17
McAlister’s Famous Tea
Rainforest Alliance CertifiedTM. Specially filtered. Made fresh with Orange Pekoe Black Tea leaves. Sweetened and poured over ice.
$3.59
McAlister's Club
Smoked turkey, Black Forest ham, bacon, sharp cheddar, Swiss, spring mix, tomato, mayo and McAlister's Honey Mustard™ on wheat. Includes a side and pickle spear.
$14.26
Fountain Drinks
Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Swiss and Thousand Island on Marbled Rye
$4.17
Chuck E. Cheese
4.4
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 6.2 mi • 43 min
Farther away
20% off on $30+
"we had the family pack and it was great and mind you I have five kids everything was made the way they wanted it and then on top of that they had games and candy All for a great price 🙂"
Cheese Pizza
Enjoy one of our most popular pizzas for easy ordering! Modifications are not available.
$19.41
Pepperoni Pizza
Enjoy one of our most popular pizzas for easy ordering! Modifications are not available.
$22.54
Half & Half Pizza: 1/2 Cheese & 1/2 Pepperoni
Enjoy one of our most popular half & half recipes for easy ordering! Modifications are not available.
$21.69
Large Build Your Own Pizza
Choose your toppings and select your crust to create your perfect pizza. Pineapple on your pizza? Triple chicken? ALL the veggies? Go for it! Serves 3 - 4. Contains Milk, Soy, Wheat. May also contain Gluten.
$23.21
Pizza N' Gyro Place
4.4
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 9.2 mi • 41 min
Farther away
"tangy gold sauce was delicious. Wings cooked perfectly crispy not over cooked. Fries had a nice season salt on then as well."
"The food is incredible! We live in a food Mecca, and this is most definitely in my top five! It is owned and operated by a beautiful, local family, who treat me like family when I order. There is nothing on their menu that will ever disappoint! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
I highly recommend the wings, and my personal my personal favorite, Spicy Lamb Kebab Over Rice"
Lambo Gyro - Sandwich
Golden-brown fish fillets paired with a generous serving of crispy fries.
$10.14
Fish and Fries
Crispy Wings
$16.38
Chicken & Lamb Over Rice
Crispy, golden-brown chicken wings
$14.92
4pc BBq Wings
Choice of fish atop golden rice, accompanied by a small side salad and sauce drizzled on the rice.
$7.62
The Varsity Club of Youngstown
4.6
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 10.9 mi • 46 min
Farther away
"First time ordering from The Varsity Club, I heard it was awesome so I tried it for myself! I had the Haddock Sandwich and a Side Caesar salad, the sandwich was huge and the side salad was a nice size too. Needless to say I'm full and I'll definitely order from there again, or even make a trip to dine in instead of ordering out!! Thanks VC, great job and thank you!!"
"This food had to of been made with love, my food was so good. My chicken strips tasted so real& hand breaded. In a world where everywhere is cheaping out& food just doesnt taste as good as it used to. THIS CHICKEN was DELICIOUS, it brought me back to the past!I got loaded fries as well and they were great, they had a sweet seasoning which was a nice suprise but worked so good. And my portions were big, tired of places handing me baby strips, these were actual big sized strips. I'm happy where I put my money. I'll be back!! Thank you for giving us great food that's worth our money."
Breaded Tenders
Hand breaded with one side and a sauce.
$17.98
Wings
Can not split an order of 6 wings but you can split the 12 and 24 for no charge.
$13.08
Hot Honey Sandwich
Brioche-Breaded Chicken-Butter Pickles-Slaw-Hot Honey-Cheese Spread
$17.94
Bacon Burger
Cheese-Applewood Bacon-Caramelized Onions-Sriracha Mayo
$18.07
Panera Bread
4.5
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.0 mi • 30 min
Farther away
"Soup is wonderful though a bit expensive, but worth it. "
"As they raise the price the level in the bowl gets lower and lower and I used to thin it down with milk - now it's so watered down you wouldn't dare do that to the 3/4 bowl that you get. Also there's less & less broccoli - and it's mostly stems at that. Pappas on Poland Av now gives you about the same soup for half the price."
Broccoli Cheddar Soup
Bowl (380 Cal.), Cup (240 Cal.), Bread Bowl (910 Cal.) Chopped broccoli, shredded carrots and select seasonings simmered in a velvety smooth cheese sauce. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Milk
$9.66
Sandwich and Soup/Mac
Selection of a half soup and a half sandwich
$16.18
Homestyle Chicken Noodle Soup
Bowl (100 Cal.), Bread Bowl (730 Cal.), Cup (60 Cal.) Tender pieces of white-meat chicken simmered in a rich, perfectly seasoned homestyle chicken bone broth with curly egg noodles, sliced carrots, celery and herbs. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Egg
$10.15
Mac & Cheese
Bread Bowl (1150 Cal.), Small (480 Cal.), Large (960 Cal.) Tender shell pasta in a blend of rich cheeses including our tangy aged white cheddar cheese sauce. Allergens: Contains Wheat, Milk, Egg
$11.89
Coaches Burger Bar
4.3
(3k+)$0 delivery fee • 4.8 mi • 43 min
"Coaches cheeseburger salad is my favorite salad of any restaurant around. I order it often and it never disappoints. "
"The Little P Pulled Pork was very salty and dry, even with extra bbq sauce. The Oreo Milkshakes had no oreos in them AT ALL, I even paid for extra, and the small cups they came in were maybe 3/4 of the way full. For a $9 shake, I expected it to be made right, and to get a FULL shake!"
Chicken Salad
Mixed salad greens, choice of grilled or fried chicken, tomato, red onion, hard cooked egg, provolone and mozzarella cheeses, topped with our signature fresh cut fries. Your choice of dressings. Add buffalo for 1.00
$17.38
Cheeseburger
Grilled, topped with American cheese. Served on our traditional bun.
$16.64
Build Your Own
Grilled, then topped with American, bacon, our BBQ sauce and pilled with onion tanglers. Served on our traditional bun.
$18.77
Big Texan Burger
Grilled then topped with American cheese, onion, pickles and thousand island dressing. Served on our traditional bun.
$18.68
New Middletown Italian Delivery FAQs
Is Italian delivery available near me in New Middletown?
Yes, Italian delivery is available near you in New Middletown through DoorDash. Enter your address in the DoorDash app or website to find the best Italian options available for delivery near you.
Where can I find the best Italian delivery near me in New Middletown?
To find the best Italian delivery near you in New Middletown, look for restaurants with high ratings and user reviews on DoorDash. You can filter by ratings to see the top-rated Italian spots near you.
Where can I find cheap Italian near me in New Middletown?
For affordable Italian delivery near me in New Middletown, DoorDash allows you to filter restaurants by price. Look for spots marked with a single dollar for budget-friendly options.
What is open now for Italian delivery near me in New Middletown?
To see which Italian restaurants are open for delivery in New Middletown right now, enter your address on the DoorDash website or app. You will be shown a list of Italian places that are currently available for delivery, including their hours of operation.
Can I schedule a Italian delivery in New Middletown?
Yes, DoorDash allows you to schedule a Italian delivery in New Middletown at a time that works best for you. During checkout, simply choose the schedule option to set a future delivery time for your order.
How can I get free Italian delivery in New Middletown?
To enjoy 0 delivery fees on Italian orders in New Middletown, consider joining DashPass, DoorDash’s subscription service. DashPass members get free delivery on eligible orders from participating restaurants.
How do I pay for my Italian delivery on DoorDash in New Middletown?
Payment for your Italian delivery in New Middletown is easy and secure with DoorDash. You can pay through the app using credit/debit cards, DoorDash credits, or other available payment methods. No need to handle cash!
What are the most popular Italian dishes I can order near me in New Middletown?
Enter your address on DoorDash to discover the most-ordered Italian dishes from restaurants near you.