Order the best American near Southold, NY

• American (New) • Seafood

(100+)

$0 delivery fee • 5.6 mi • 37 min

"The Panko Chicken w/ Lemon Cream Sauce is awesome!"

"I used to love Legends—the food was always consistent and amazing. However, something changed late last summer, and the flavors just aren’t the same anymore. The curry tastes completely different and is definitely not the same recipe as before. I’m not sure if the new owner lost her chef, but it was inedible. This was surprising because I love Minnow, and when the new owner first took over, the food at Legends remained the same. It’s only in the past six months that things have completely changed. After being disappointed three times in a row, we won’t be ordering from there again. It’s sad to say, but Legends is no longer what it once was."

Hamburger - Marinated

lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche bun, fries

$24.98

Wings

with jasmine rice and sauteed mushrooms

$21.39

Panko Chicken w/ Lemon Cream Sauce

rice noodles, vegetables, tamarind, fresh ginger, sesame, peanut, cilantro, fish sauce

$37.95

Vegetable Pad Thai

garlic, pickled peppers, scallions

$34.9

Green Hill Restaurant

• American • Barbecue & Smokehouse

(100+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.3 mi • 34 min

"Did not disappoint! Delicious and the fires were jamming. I had my sauce on the side because I fidn it too sweet but the burger -yummmmm"

"Wow, Green Hill is consistently fantastic and delicious! The Smash Burger rivals all Smash Burgers far and wide. The Smoked Brisket Sandwich is rich and irresistible, as is The Smoked Turkey (which I now order to make a great chicken salad at home). The Mac 'N Cheese has too much butter/oil for my taste but it's yummy for sure. Order. Now."

Smash Burger

North fork grass-fed double beef patty, special sauce, cheese, onions, pickles, ketchup.

$22.43

ST. Louis Ribs

Green hill bbq sauce.

$29

Hand-Cut Fries

Smoked tomato aioli.

$10

Grilled Chipotle Shrimp

White bbq sauce.

$19

Tuckers Smokehouse

• American • Barbecue & Smokehouse

(20+)

$0 delivery fee • 8.4 mi • 39 min

"Great BBQ - it's the real deal. The ribs are phenomenal, and I love the pulled pork. You can't go wrong here."

"Always delicious, always includes what is ordered, this place always hits the nail on the head with every order. Large portions, ingredients are always fresh highly recommend"

Cornbread

Smoked & fried, plain, buffalo, garlic Parm, sweet chili, mango habanero, dry rub.

$3.22

Seasoned Fries

(1/4 each) brisket, pulled pork, pulled chicken, spare ribs and sausage link.

$9.31

Brisket Baked Beans

American cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles and ketchup.

$9.1

Coleslaw

1/2 lb pastrami, Swiss cheese, kraut and thousand island dressing.

$7.55

Braun's Kitchen

• American • Seafood Restaurant

(90+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.3 mi • 32 min

"The SHRIMP ROLL. was really delicious. I would have put more mayo and added some celery...but that's just me. The roll was amazing...toasted with garlic and butter.YUMMY.Fresh shredded slaw and the crispiest fries I ever ate. Very very good meal. IT's a KEEPER!!"

"Very delicious, just a bit disappointed on the small portion size for $27+tax and fees etc. The meal did not include salad or even bread with the pasta order. Burger is perfect!"

LOBSTER ROLL

hot butter & garlic or traditional cold, toasted brioche served with fries & slaw

$39.82

CHARRED BRUSSELS SPROUTS

served with fries

$8.6

KIDS CHICKEN FINGERS

3 each. blackened mahi, pickled red cabbage, sriracha lime aioli, guacamole

$9.52

MAHI TACO TRIO

mixed greens, almonds, dried cranberries, crisp red apples, goat cheese, sourdough croutons, bacon vinaigrette

$16.11

Greenport Harbor Brewing

$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 24 min

(50+)

• Burgers • Wings

"amazing! best chicken sandwich I've had in a long time"

"The best store ever! I will recommend to all my friends and will order again! Fresh food and the best employees. Gave me extra fries because they are the best ever. Highly Recommend and order didn't take long"

NOFO grassfed cheeseburger

6oz. burger, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles & Harbor sauce.

$19.36

Hand breaded chicken tendies

Hand breaded buttermilk tenders, french fries, ranch, Awesome sauce

$19.54

Chicken Sammy

Fried chicken breast, with mayo, lettuce, tomato & pickles.Hot Honey

$19.1

Senor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar

$0 delivery fee • 0.5 mi • 30 min

(800+)

• Mexican • Burritos

"I ALWAYS get the Taco Salad and every single time it is delicious!! The chicken is always cooked to perfection. Same with the rice and beans!!!! The lettuce is always fresh. Not once have I ever had a brown piece! So so so good everytime ive gotten it. Ive li gotten this 15 times!!!!!!! The Churros are to die for too! Get some Nutella with them and theyre even better!!!!! I would add photos, but I ate everything already!"

"The taco was soooooooooo small. Less inside of it than a Taco Bell taco and the shell is definitely just Ortega. Delicious don't get me wrong but it wasn't worth the $6 price. Nachos are always worth it!"

Classic Taco$

ONLY ONE TACO PER ORDER!!! Crispy corn or soft flour tortilla, blended cheese, sour cream, pico de gallo, and mixed greens.

$6.01

Classic Burrito

Flower tortilla filled with rice, choice of beans, sour cream, pico de gallo, blended cheese, mix greens.

$15.71

Nachos

Tortilla chips smothered in queso and melted blended cheese, served with pinto beans, pico de gallo, sour cream, and jalapeño coins for our nachos with protein.

$13.1

Empanadas (3)

Select your choice of meat.

$11.38

Olive Branch Restaurant & Cafe

$0 delivery fee • 4.3 mi • 34 min

(80+)

• Turkish • Kebabs

"absolutely fantastic, fresh food! Love a locally owned restaurant. The Muhammar is always a crowd favorite, delicious. The grape leaves are always a surprising hit... even if you don't like them in general, I guarantee you'll love them (warm) from Olive Branch."

"Olive Branch is a neighborhood gem! The food is so fresh and always delicious. I love their Eggplant Istanbul - it's addictive - and the Baba Ghanoush is also wonderful. Their portions are very generous - all the appetizer mezze come in pint containers. I'm a huge fan and have been a loyal customer for several years."

Chicken Shish Kabob

Contains Dairy. Tomato, cucumber, red onion, scallion, herbs, feta cheese, vinegar, olive oil.

$29

Ottoman Shepherd's Salad

(Gluten-free). Red lentil, garlic, onion, dry mint, olive oil, pepper paste.

$22

Red Lentil Soup

Chickpeas, garlic, lemon juice, tahini paste, cumin, white pepper.

$14

Hummus

Jasmine rice, onions, parsley, scallion, currants, cinnamon, white pepper, olive oil.

$12

Lucharito's

• Quesadillas • Chips and Salsa

(300+)

$0 delivery fee • 4.3 mi • 32 min

"Got the burrito and added steak and shrimp. Don't think I've ever had a $25 dollar burrito in my life. But probably the best burrito I ever had"

"The OG Lucharito's! Always fantastic! The Burrito Bowl is fresh and delicious. I can never get enough of their Dip Salsa Fresca - the tomatoes are roasted giving it smokey depth - and the Dip Pico De Gallo and Dip Size Guacamole are consistently off the charts. I love their burritos, tacos and jalapeño poppers too!"

Burrito Bowl

Your choice of protein with cilantro lime rice, black beans, picked red cabbage, cheese, pico de gallo, lettuce, sour cream & guacamole

$17.25

Chicken Quesadilla

Pulled chicken with shredded cheese, pico de gallo & lettuce.

$17.25

Alize Brewing company

4.4

(40+)

• American • Fast Food

$0 delivery fee • 8.0 mi • 44 min

$5 off on $15+

Prime Rib Au Jus

Slow roasted prime rib, mashed potatoes, & chef's vegetable of the day

$38

Hot Pastrami

Shaved pastrami, caramelized onion, Swiss, mustard, grilled rye, fries.

$21

Blackened Mahi Taco's

Twin taco's with blackened mahi, pineapple and shredded cabbage, and chipolte aioli.

$19

Tony's Fusion North

4.4

(1k+)

• Asian Food • Takeout

$0 delivery fee • 8.2 mi • 37 min

"Our order was large but everything was delicious! We love the Sushi Pizza .. the different layers add such a unique taste. The hibachi chicken was good as was the fried rice. The noodles were good as was the Tropical Roll ... so fresh! It's a bit of a trip to get here but the food is worth it."

"Ordered the Hibachi chicken steak. Tasteless and meal overpriced. Meat was rubbery and chicken was no better. Sorry, but very disappointed."

Wonton Soup

Pan fried shrimp dumpling / pork / veg (6 pcs)

$7.79

Pookaberry Cafe

Filipino • Japanese

$0 delivery fee • 7.6 mi • 49 min

PANCIT noodles

Chef Pooka is Kah-rayzee about PANCIT & for good reason-this tastee noodle dish- first introduced to the Philippines by the Chinese was quickly absorbed into the culture influenced by the strong Spanish presence comingled with indigenous culinary techniques leaves tastebuds saluting veggies sautéing cooked in a broth or braised noodles comingling with a succulent choice of inclusions as varied as the number of islands in the Philippines you too will be Kah-rayzee about this fun yummy dish made with LOVE for sharing! Eat Drink be Pookaberry!

$27.35

Dumplings Fat Lady Sings

Filled with dreams a mere pillow weeping beams willow thin was Chef Pooka ere he was a wee one before even being weaned our would be troubadour of Filipino cuisine slept wrapped in gyoza dough... no small wonder Chef Pooka's Deeliteful Dumplings are yummy bundles of bliss! try them fried of steamed veggie or meat either way precious few are the foodies who fail to hitch a ride on this flavor ferry- lo behold! truth be told munching on Chef Pooka's delectable throw pillows of bliss never gets old-Eat Drink be Pookaberry!

$17.41

Spring Rolls Yo! Love Me Sum Lumpia!

in a deep Tyrian purple funk after an eternal ephemeral intro Chef Pooka was wrapped by a warbling lyric of the singer waxing: "April is a cruel time...Even though the sun may shine...and world looks in the shade as it slowly comes away..." sarcophagized in a paper crepe pastry skin of the lumpia Chef Pooka woke cocooned in a half swoon mused of a day when crisp golden fried meat - veggie or shrimp rolls welcomed spring since then to this day April has not been grey-funny say some basking in the blinding rays of culinary fame Chef Pooka should hear quavering the singer's trill Tyrian purple plea: "still falls the April rain...and the valley's filled with pain..." Away with Melancholy! sink your teeth into Chef Pooka's golden crisp lumpia bliss...Eat Drink be Pookaberry!

$17.64

take a BAO!

be it Chicken Adobo...Bistek Tagalog...Veggies...Beef Kalderetta nestled in a pair of steamed Bao Buns soon as u get sum BAO... Wow! Eat Drink Be Pookaberry!

$21.83

Starbucks

4.4

(200+)

• Coffee • Cafe

$0 delivery fee • 8.0 mi • 37 min

"I absolutely love all the extras, some baristas could care less, but the one in Mattituck is 🅰️ OK in my book!!! Thank You for taking my order seriously.. next time I'll take pictures. 💕 Thanks again!"

"I asked for ice in my strawberry acai refresher and I got it with none in it. The Summer-Berry Refresher had pearls in it and I asked for none. The pearls are gross and taste too sweet. My drink was also not filled up all the way so it was a small portion. Didn't taste very fresh and was too sweet without ice. I would order again but maybe someone else can make it."

Caramel Ribbon Crunch Frappuccino® Blended Beverage

Buttery caramel syrup blended with coffee, milk and ice, then topped with a layer of dark caramel sauce, whipped cream, caramel drizzle and a crunchy caramel-sugar topping—oh-so-beautifully delicious.

$8.38

Chocolate Croissant

Two generous pieces of chocolate wrapped in a butter croissant with soft, flaky layers and a golden-brown crust. –VEGETARIAN

$4.75

Iced Brown Sugar Oatmilk Shaken Espresso

First we shake Starbucks® Blonde espresso, brown sugar and cinnamon together, and then top it off with oatmilk and ice for a cool lift to power you through your day. If Starbucks® Blonde Espresso Roast is not available, Signature Espresso Roast will be substituted.

$8.49

Crispy Grilled Cheese on Sourdough

This classic sandwich with 21g of protein is a blend of mild Cheddar and baby Gouda cheeses on sourdough bread, topped with an olive-oil butter spread. - VEGETARIAN - HIGH-PROTEIN

$8.21

Southold Wayside Market

"food is always delicious,they do custom orders very professional!"

East End Bagel Cafe

• Breakfast and Lunch • American Breakfast

(100+)

"I love East end bagel! Everything I get from there is tasty. I got the Italian hero today and it's delicious."

"loooved the everything cheddar bagel!! definitely a must try and the service was great too!"

Meat, Two eggs and Cheese

Start your day right with our delicious breakfast sandwiches. Choose from bacon, sausage, or ham, paired with a variety of cheeses, all served on your choice bread

$9.16

Bagel w/ Cream Cheese

Everything spread, garlic and herb, olive pimento, strawberry, apple cinnamon, bacon and herb, cucumber dill, & jalapeño.

$4.5

Nova lox sandwich

Thin sliced smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onion, tomato, capers on a bagel of your choice

$13.02

Chicken Vodka

Breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella & vodka sauce served on ciabatta bread.

$13.5

STERLINGTON DELI

"Fred and crew, thank you for putting out such quality food. always satisfied. last item ordered was Super Do. delicious and the chicken breast was tender and juicy piled into a superhero. marvelous Fred. LGM 2025"

"Perfect....as always.. very attentive to the way I ask for my burger and they never mess it up.. keep up the awesome work "

Black Sheep Bagels

(600+)

• Sandwiches • Bagels

"Black Sheep Bagels is consistently excellent. The bagels and Chicken Salad by the pound are always fresh. Bagels are often still warm. The staff go out of their way to be helpful. If you order for delivery, and they don't have what you asked for they call every time. North Fork Special is out of this world and I really like the Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese by the pound. So good! You should definitely give Black Sheep Bagels a try when you're having a bagel craving - and who isn't on a weekend? Enjoy!"

"This is absolutely, hands down the best Deli around!!! It's my favorite place to get food!! My favorite is their acai bowls ..always so fresh and delicious!!! All their Breakfast sandwiches are delicious! Everything from Black Sheep is Amazing!!! A+++++ "

Bacon Egg and Cheese

Two eggs, bacon, cheese and hash brown.

$10.77

Iced Coffee

Each.

$5.32

Hobo

Each.

$12.45

Plain

Each.

$4.05

Little Fish

• Seafood Restaurant • American

(10+)

Goldberg's

(600+)

• Sandwiches • Bagels

"BEC in a whole wheat wrap is delicious. "

"This is the 2nd time I ordered a hobo with extra cheese and I didn't get the hasbrown. This time the bacon even looked grey or uncooked. Pretty gross. Greenport location is much better."

Bacon, Egg, and Cheese

On your choice of bagel, flat, bread, or croissant.

$8.81

Bagel with Cream Cheese

Please list your bagel choice in the comments

$4.28

The Famous Hobo

Bacon, Egg, Cheese, and Hashbrown

$10.11

Pips Cafe And Provisions - 218 Main St

• American • Casual Dining

(60+)

"OFF-THE-CHARTS! Pip's has the best Avocado Toast, hands down. The sandwiches, or Toasties, are phenomenal! The roast chicken with pickled peppers is my favorite though I recommend getting that and the Ham Toastie. Blueberry Muffin and Morning Glory Muffin are terrific and seasonal. Love ordering from Pip's!"

"Best breakfast sandwich in town. Everything was so delicious and delivery was seamless. Don't miss their croissants either."

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich

A classic bacon, egg, and cheese served on our house-made milk bun.

$12.61

Avocado Toast

Toasted sourdough topped with sliced avocado, a jammy egg, chile crisp, and fresh cilantro.

$12.54

Chocolate Croissant

Flaky, buttery pastry filled with rich 40% cacao chocolate. Baked in house daily.

Biscuit

A house made biscuit, tender and soft inside, served warm with butter and jam.

Ammirati's of Love Lane

American • Deli

North fork doughnut co.

Oreo Cookies and Cream Doughnut

Vanilla iced topped with Oreo crumbs and a vanilla drizzle

$4.91

Caramel Crumb Cake Doughnut

Vanilla iced topped with housemate cinnamon streusel and a caramel drizzle

$4.93

Boston Cream Doughnut

Filled with a Bavarian crème and chocolate iced

$4.93

Strawberry Frosted with Rainbow Sprinkles

Cinnamon sugar topped with chocolate and caramel drizzles

$4.92

Anker