Popular
Order this restaurant’s top-selling items.
Four Custom Pints SPECIAL
We will hand pack 4 custom pints (at $8 off normal cost) for you and throw in an insulated ice cream tote bag free! For details on the custom flavors available, please call our East Village scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavors in the special instruction box.
Custom Pint
We would be delighted to hand pack a custom pint for you! For details on the custom flavors available, please call our East Village scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavor in the special instruction box.
DIY Sundae Kit
PARTY Like it’s Sundae. Includes your choice of four Hand-Packed Pints, four Crunchy Toppings (4 oz. each) , four Gooey Toppings (4 oz. each), 10 spoons, 10 cups and it’s all packed into an OddFellows insulated carrier! For details on flavors available, please call our EAST VILLAGE scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavors in the special instruction box.
Pints
Four Custom Pints SPECIAL
We will hand pack 4 custom pints (at $8 off normal cost) for you and throw in an insulated ice cream tote bag free! For details on the custom flavors available, please call our East Village scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavors in the special instruction box.
Custom Pint
We would be delighted to hand pack a custom pint for you! For details on the custom flavors available, please call our East Village scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavor in the special instruction box.
Toppings
Crunchy Toppings
Top it off with some crunch. 4 oz. package.
Gooey Toppings
Top it off with some gooey goodness. 4 oz. package.
Ovenly Cookies
Please call our shop at 917-475-1812 for available cookie flavors (we run out fast as we only sell fresh cookies). These cookies are made by OVENLY in Greenpoint and they're amazing. We usually stock the following cookies: Salted Chocolate Chip, Ginger Molasses and Hot Chocolate. They go great on their own, with milk, or used to build your own ICE CREAM SANDWICH! Don't forget to order the scoop, the ice cream, and some toppings! Available in 4-packs.
Kits
DIY Sundae Kit
PARTY Like it’s Sundae. Includes your choice of four Hand-Packed Pints, four Crunchy Toppings (4 oz. each) , four Gooey Toppings (4 oz. each), 10 spoons, 10 cups and it’s all packed into an OddFellows insulated carrier! For details on flavors available, please call our EAST VILLAGE scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavors in the special instruction box.
DIY Sandwich Kit
Sandwich. It. Yourself. Includes your choice of three hand-packed pints, two crunchy toppings (4 oz. each), four amazing OVENLY cookies, and one ice cream scoop. And it’s all packed into an OddFellows insulated carrier! For details on flavors and cookies available, please call our EAST VILLAGE scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavors in the special instruction box.
Beverages
Milkshake
16oz milkshake made with our homemade ice cream. For details on the milkshake flavors available, please call our East Village scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavor in the special instruction box.
Virgil's Sodas
Choose from various flavors of Virgil's Sodas, and make your own Ice Cream Float at home!
Catering
(Catering) Custom Pints
(Minimum 3 pints per order). We would be delighted to hand pack a custom pint for you! For details on the custom flavors available, please call our East Village scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavor in the special instruction box. A perfect choice for the big game! Just select the pre-order option at the top of the page to get started.
(Requires 24 hours advance notice)
(Catering) Milkshakes
(Minimum 4 milkshakes per order). 16oz milkshake made with our homemade ice cream. For details on the milkshake flavors available, please call our East Village scoop shop at 917-475-1812, and write in the flavor in the special instruction box.
(Requires 24 hours advance notice)