Order the best Italian near Central Islip, NY

Best Italian Restaurants Nearby in Central Islip

Prestano Bagel & bakery

Prestano Bagel & bakery

4.7
(600+)
• Bakery • Breakfast
$0 delivery fee • 5.1 mi • 46 min
$4 off on $34+
"They were amazing! I asked them to write happy birthday on the cake and put in candles, but I figured they wouldn't because I only ordered the cake.... but they did! The cake looks and tastes wonderful! "
"Ordered a Large Italian bread; it was fresh & tasty. The Apple pie was delicious! Generous amount of apples. The frosted donuts were large & the jelly donuts were filled to the max! They were delicious too! Everything tasted so good & the sizes were grand."
2 Eggs Meat Cheese
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
$8.19
Hungry Man On Hero
A juice drink made with a blend of summer’s most delicious fruit juices, with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.
$12.75
Cheese Danish
apple, blueberry, or cherry
$3.99
Bagel with cream cheese
vegetable, scallion, olive, jalapeno cream cheese, lox spread, strawberry, chocolate, cinnamon raison, garlic and herb, and bacon and cheddar.
$4.13
Smithtown Bagels

Smithtown Bagels

4.5
(600+)
• Bagels • Omelets
$0 delivery fee • 5.5 mi • 50 min
15% off on $20+
Wallet-Friendly
"Bagels are made fresh in house and it shows. The cream cheese flavors are all on point and the prices are the best of all the bagel spots in town. Don't skip it. "
"I paid extra for avocado on my egg sandwhich and it was in a container on the side and not good quality and rotting. It's common to put avocado in egg sandwiches so that was odd. I also asked for ketchup with my sandwhich (also common) and they didn't provide that."
2 Eggs Meat and Cheese Bacon, Ham or Sausage
Choose 14 from over 20 flavors including classics like plain, sesame, and unique options like bacon, gluten-free. Mix and match for your perfect dozen bagels selection.
$8.03
Bagel with Cream Cheese
100% pure squeezed pasteurized orange juice. A delicious orange juice with a taste that’s the next best thing to fresh squeezed.
$3.43
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese
Two eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, cheese.
$4.33
1/2 Dozen Bagels
3 eggs, Bacon, sausage, ham, cheese, sautéed onions home fries or hash browns on a hero
$9.63
Handy Pantry Friendly Food Stores

Handy Pantry Friendly Food Stores

4.4
(1k+)
• Deli • Grocery
$0 delivery fee • 5.0 mi • 40 min
"Best The Italian hero I've had in a long time. The hero is huge, i paired it with a deli pickle. Chefs kiss"
"got an egg sandwich, was over 10$ and they gave me literally like one bite of sausage on my sandwich. then I got Hash Brown Patties (2 ct), how do you mess that up? they were cold and not even crispy they looked and tasted like they had been sitting out for hours. everything was bad"
Start with Eggs
A hearty breakfast sandwich featuring many options including your choice of eggs, melted cheese, and crispy bacon, ham or sausage along with various bread or roll options. customize yours today
$9.76
Build Your Own Sandwich | Up to Two Meats
Served with your choice of side.
$15.96
Hot Handy Pantry Coffee, Tea, or Hot Chocolate
Choose from a variety of coffee blends, teas, or hot chocolate, including options like house blend coffee, organic guatemalan, hazelnut, french vanilla, colombian, and many more.
$3.14
Build Your Own Hero | Two Meats
Choose style and choice of Boar's Head turkey breast.
$19.28
Bagelati

Bagelati

4.7
(600+)
• Coffee • Breakfast
$0 delivery fee • 9.1 mi • 53 min
"I love Bagelati! I love the food, the staff, location, everything. I usually stop in for either of my favorites BEC or Chicken Salad on a bagel, but tonight I just had a hanker for plain Chicken Sandwich on DoorDash. Just a great cutlet on a roll with mayo and lettuce. You can't really find that anywhere, they are usually are particular types of chicken sandwiches from the local spots but I didn't want all that stuff, just a great Chicken Cutlet . Well, boy was i pleased! So satisfying! Made perfect! Looking forward to ordering it again. (oh, and I also got desert, Triple Chocolate Cake. About to dive into that right now! their deserts are fantastic, and if your looking for an ice cream spot to take the kids, they have a wonderful selection of Gelato.) I love the staff, they always make me feel special. Added bonus, your helpinn a small business. Its a win win in my book!"
"Just moved back to the area and Da damn. That was the best egg sandwich I've had in a long long time. Bagel was light fluffy and fresh even though I ordered at 3pm. Instructions followed to the T. Onions and spinach in the add on list??! Bless you! Scrambled eggs with onions and spinach covered in American cheese is my jam, and though it may sound simple- usually comes flavorless too soggy or too dry or my ingredients just not there. But not today!! :) I could go on man seriously ! the bagels are the perfect Fn size I got a couple for later this week too and every variety was soft and uniform , not going to have to trim it to get in toaster tomorrow.. you guys are doing great things! Please don't change anything except maybe give the cook a raise so they stay forever. My sandwich was made expertly WITH love. Honestly usually don't get it that good unless I make it for myself lol. Also must say a special Thank you for the thoughtful ordering menu.. friends and neighbors, im telling you- any addition or special instructions you might want i guarantee is on their comprehensive and cohesive list. I dare someone to prove me wrong lol thanks again! Maybe I'll have the patience to take a picture next time.. maybe;)"
Bacon, Egg & Cheese
Eggs and cheese.
$12.36
Plain Cream Cheese Bagel
Does not include cheese.
$5.08
Sausage, Egg & Cheese
Proudly serve bean2bean cold brew.
$12.6
Egg & Cheese
Includes 2 fried eggs.
$8.84
Brendel's Bagels & Eatery

Brendel's Bagels & Eatery

4.5
(1k+)
• American • Casual Dining
$0 delivery fee • 2.8 mi • 36 min
"They always follow specific directions, I can never go wrong ordering from them. Perfect iced coffee, perfect wrapping. I love them "
"I'm very disappointed. I've been ordering at this place my whole life using pick up, going in myself, and I ordered a breakfast sandwich and the bagel did not even come cut, and it's a flagel so it's difficult to cut because it's flat. The food was cold and it was supposed to be a breakfast sandwich. They gave me everything separate. I had to make the sandwich myself. It didn't even come with cheese. The picture was completely misleading, and it was very expensive. It was a $30 breakfast for a couple of items "
2 Eggs with Meat
Two eggs with your choice of meat, served on a plate or sandwich. Includes coffee, tea, juice, or water.
$11.56
2 Eggs
Two eggs with options of fried, over easy, scrambled, sunny side up, or egg whites, served with your choice of bread. Includes coffee, tea, juice, or water.
$9.53
Hash Brown Patty
Single Egg prepared to your liking on plate or bread of choice with meat of choice. Includes Coffee, Tea, Juice or Water
$4.71
Hungryman
3 Egg Whites, Turkey Bacon, Swiss Cheese, Spinach & Avocado
$13.72
Sayville Sandwich

Sayville Sandwich

4.7
(400+)
• Sandwiches • Salads
$0 delivery fee • 9.4 mi • 48 min
Wallet-Friendly
"OH MY GOD THE ITALIAN SANDWICH SOO GOOOOOD. "
"The Bunger shrdded steak sandwich (I had it on a spinach wrap) was very tasty and there was plenty of meat and the right touch of gravy. But the Swiss cheese I ordered it with was practically non existant. Pretty stingy for a wrap sandwich that costs $17 and comes only with a brown paper bag. No cole slaw, no pickle. Like I said, stingy."
2 Eggs and Bacon
Roast beef, mozzarella cheese, bacon, and brown gravy served on a toasted garlic hero
$8.32
Bunger
Turkey, bacon, lettuce & tomato, your choice of cheese, served on a hero
$14.92
Turkey BLT
Chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella & bacon, coleslaw, Russian dressing on a toasted garlic hero
$15.18
20 Oz Iced Tea
Hot pastrami or corned beef, coleslaw, melted Swiss & Russian dressing on a hero
$3.3
Big Time Bagels

Big Time Bagels

4.9
(100+)
• American • Cafe
$0 delivery fee • 7.4 mi • 44 min
"Bagels are good . Although they never sent my French toast bagel with chocolate chip cream cheese . I went over orde 3 times before sending it . So now I have an extra rainbow bagel with strawberry cream cheese that I didn't want ."
"Hands down my favorite bagel spot. Bagels are always fresh. Mike and team are always amazing. Always have a bloom or Celsius in stock. When we order egg sandwiches they are cooked perfectly! Genuinely never have an issue with any order I make."
6. Bacon & Cheese Omelet
This menu item can be cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish, or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Please notify your server of any food allergies before ordering.
$10.1
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese
100% Colombian. Regular, decaf, or dark roast.
$5.12
Bagel with Butter
This menu item can be cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish, or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Please notify your server of any food allergies before ordering.
$3.93
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese
Add bacon, sausage, banana or turkey bacon for an additional charge.
$5.77
Pop's Deli

Pop's Deli

4.6
(1k+)
• Deli • Sandwiches
$0 delivery fee • 5.4 mi • 38 min
Wallet-Friendly
"I had the chicken panini and it was delicious. It was so big I got 2 meals out of it. "
"Sad ingredients. Chicken was hard and flavorless. Bacon was almost flavorless"
2 Eggs on a Roll & Cheese
Medium or LARGE
$7.47
2 Eggs on a Roll
Carton
$6.27
Homemade Iced Tea or Iced coffee
Chicken cutlet, bacon, melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and Russians dressing on a toasted hero or roll.
$4.88
3 Egg Hungry Man Hero
Grilled chicken, romaine, red onions, croutons, parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing in a white wrap.
$9.94
Summerwind Deli

Summerwind Deli

4.6
(1k+)
• Pickup • Sandwich
$0 delivery fee • 12.2 mi • 42 min
Farther away
"The American Cutlet Classic, taste amazing, the portion is just right! The freshness was elite, I paired it with the sour cream & onions Wise Ridges Sour Sour Cream and Onion chips!! I would def order again!"
"the lettuce in the salad was extremely wilted and the bread of all 3 sandwiches was very stale. very upset because we go to the store often to buy food. this was my first time door dashing from summerwind and we are disappointed."
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, croutons, grated parmesan cheese, romaine lettuce, and Caesar dressing in a plain wrap.
$14.09
Our World-Famous Reuben
Pastrami, or corned beef with sauerkraut, melted swiss cheese, and choice of russian dressing or mustard on grilled bakery rye bread (served with pickle and coleslaw).
$17.12
Eggs on a Roll (2 pcs)
Come with small orange juice.
$9.57
Morning Sun
3 egg whites, turkey, Swiss, and honey mustard in a whole wheat wrap. Come with small orange juice.
$11.45
Brightwaters Village Deli

Brightwaters Village Deli

4.7
(2k+)
• Deli • Sandwich
$0 delivery fee • 8.2 mi • 42 min
"The sandwiches are always delicious and full of fresh ingredients. The home fries are so flavorful and perfectly seasoned. Hands down my absolute favorite deli to order from. The coffee is always wrapped so it wouldn't spill all over the bag. 100% recommended!"
"A chicken cutlet isnt that thick of a piece of chicken. The chicken was cut up into small pieces- so it was difficult to eat and most the breading was off. The $2.99 side of potato salad was 3 tablespoons. "
Build Your Own Egg Sandwich
Build your own egg sandwich, choose how you like your eggs, your bread, extras and add on's
$13.5
Turkey Sandwich
Grilled chicken, Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing
$16.22
Cream Cheese Bagel
3 eggs, grilled pepper turkey, bacon, cheese, hash browns, chipotle mayo in a roll
$5.59
Ham Sandwich
2 eggs any style, 2 pancakes, 2 sausage links, corned beef hash and homemade home fries
$15.55
Exit 42 Bagel & Deli

Exit 42 Bagel & Deli

4.6
(70+)
• American • Bakery
$0 delivery fee • 6.7 mi • 33 min
$5 off on $34+
"First time back since they reopened and my sandwich was absolutely delicious."
"Always fast & fresh and delicious. My new favorite breakfast go to when I come home to visit."
Bacon Egg & Cheese
Egg, sausage, bacon, ham, cheese on hero.
$9.55
Snapple large
Chicken cutlet, bacon. American cheese, lettuce, tomato, Russian dressing.
$5.61
Hungryman
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
$15.97
Exit Special
Turkey breast, bacon, lettuce and tomato.
$14.82
First Class Bagels

First Class Bagels

4.3
(30+)
• American • Bakery
$0 delivery fee • 8.9 mi • 45 min
egg everything
Ham, cappy, salami, pepperoni, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato, onions, red wine vinegar & olive oil with S&P & mayo on hero.
$6.53
rainbow
Vegetarian.
$8.18
french toast
Hot chicken cutlet topped with chopped Caesar salad on toasted garlic hero.
$6.04
super cinnamom raisin
Smoked turkey, melted Pepper Jack, sautéed onions, sun-dried tomatoes, arugula, chipotle mayo, on pressed ciabatta.
$4.95
Bagel Buzz

Bagel Buzz

4.5
(10k+)
• Pickup • Breakfast
$0 delivery fee • 10.0 mi • 52 min
Wallet-Friendly
Trending
"Roast Beef Sandwich, always filing fresh and plenty of roast beef. Heart Healthy wrap, always hot fresh and tasty, best breakfast around. Order always on time, prompt, accurate and professional. 5 Star service all around. *****"
"I love the Mini Bagel with Lite Flavored Cream Cheese when I just want that carb. The 1 lb. Tuna is delicious. This time I got the Tuna Salad Sandwich on a wrap and it's overstuffed and delish! Love my bagel buzz!"
2 Eggs with Meat and Cheese
These items are cooked to order. Consuming raw or under cooked fresh shell eggs, meats, or fish, can lead to food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
$7.66
Plain Cream Cheese on a Bagel
Write in Instruction For Milk, Creamer or Sugar.
$4
Flavored Cream Cheese on a Bagel
If quantity allowed is greater than the number of options to choose from, the min/max should be 1/0 and modifier should be named "Choose flavors".
$5.01
2 Eggs with Cheese
A juice drink made with a blend of summer’s most delicious fruit juices, with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.
$6.39
Dick's Delicatessen

Dick's Delicatessen

4.7
(80+)
• Cafe • Sandwiches
$0 delivery fee • 6.5 mi • 46 min
Wallet-Friendly
2 Eggs
Create Your Own Egg Sandwich On a roll.
$9.67
1/2 lb. Salad
Choose from Potato, Macaroni or Cole Slaw
$3.57
2 Eggs Bacon & Cheese
Ham cappy, Genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce & tomato, oil & vinegar.
$8
Italian Hero
Choose from Potato, Macaroni or Cole slaw
$13.08
Bagel Boss Deli

Bagel Boss Deli

4.5
(1k+)
• Appetizing • Breakfast
$0 delivery fee • 8.9 mi • 46 min
Wallet-Friendly
"French Toast (3 Pieces) is the BEST French toast on doordash you get a good size Portion! made with really good challah bread! best bread to make french toast. this is my only place to buy it from!!! 10 out of 10!"
"May be better in person but the quality for delivery was not good. I ordered at 7am as I have small children and am a single mom so it's easier for me. However the coffee came in a can (who does that). The order was $40 and the bacon was partially inedible as it was all fattty. There are a lot of good bagel spots in LI and I wouldn't recommend door dashing from this place."
Bagel
The Bagel, with your choice of type, provides you with a classic and New York-style bagel that's kettle-boiled and baked to perfection, offering a versatile canvas for your favorite spreads or fillings.
$5.13
2 Eggs on Bagel
The 2 Eggs on Bagel, with your choice of bagel, delivers a classic breakfast with two eggs cooked to your preference and served on a fresh bagel, providing a timeless and customizable morning treat.
$8.33
Iced Coffee
Iced Coffee is a chilled coffee option, perfect for those who prefer a cold and refreshing caffeine fix.
$4.92
1 Egg on Bagel
The 1 Egg on Bagel, with your choice of bagel, offers a simple and satisfying breakfast with a perfectly cooked egg served on a fresh bagel, providing a classic and customizable morning treat.
$7.5
Railroad Bagel Express (Carll Ave)

Railroad Bagel Express (Carll Ave)

4.8
(1k+)
• American • Casual Dining
$0 delivery fee • 12.5 mi • 50 min
Farther away
Wallet-Friendly
"The cannonball was excellent. huge and delicious! cheese was melted to wax paper and hard to pull away. Id order this over and over again. GREAT!"
"Love this combo of fresh warmed up cold cuts, chipotle mayo, on a hero! The Iced Coffee (24 Oz) is also a well needed morning booster! This is a great portioned meal, I always order this, it's my go to morning order!"
Express Egg Sandwich
Meat Egg and cheese. your choice of one meat: Bacon,Ham.Sausage,TurkeyBacon,and Turkey.
$8.46
Plain Cream Cheese Bagel
Your choice of one meat Bacon,Ham,Sausage,Turkey Bacon, and Turkey
$4.53
Meat & Egg Sandwich
Your choice of scallion,vegetable,bacon scallion,cin. raisin,maple walnut,chipotle garlic,green olive or jalapeno. please leave note indicating you selection.
$8.44
1/2 doz Bagels
Eggs Or Egg whites on a roll or bagel of your choice.
$9.56
Legacy Bagel Cafe And Deli

Legacy Bagel Cafe And Deli

American • Cafe
$0 delivery fee • 9.7 mi • 50 min
Just Ice Tea Organic Peach Oolong Ice Tea
Just Ice Tea Organic Peach Oolong Ice Tea is a refreshing beverage that combines the smooth, rich flavor of oolong tea with the sweet taste of organic peaches. It's a perfect drink for a hot day, offering a natural and subtle sweetness without being overpowering.
$4.55
Diet Coke Cola Soda Pop 20 Fl Oz Bottle
Diet Coke is a sugar-free, calorie-free soft drink known for its crisp and refreshing taste. This 20 fl oz bottle is perfect for on-the-go enjoyment.
$3.9
Tropicana Pure Premium No Pulp 100% Orange Juice
Tropicana Pure Premium No Pulp is a refreshing orange juice made from 100% oranges with no added pulp. It's perfect for those who love a smooth, natural taste without any bits getting in the way.
$3.89
Tim Hortons

Tim Hortons

4.5
(200+)
• Breakfast • Coffee
$0 delivery fee • 2.4 mi • 27 min
"Best coffee, best donuts. Never actually went to the store but I can tell the people there care!"
"Gracias me encanta los productos de Tin Hortns gusto la porción y frescura volvería a ordenar mi comida favorita los burritos "
Timbits® Multi-Pack
Assortment of honeydip, chocolate glazed, sour cream glazed, blueberry, birthday cake, old fashioned glazed, and old fashioned plain.
$5.89
Original Blend Coffee
We'll make you a black coffee unless customized
$3.65
OREO® Iced Capp
6 assorted classic donuts
$5.59
Donut Multi-Pack
Smoked turkey breast, crispy bacon, real cheddar cheese, fresh leaf lettuce and tomato served on a freshly baked ciabatta bun.
$12.07

Central Islip Italian Delivery FAQs

Is Italian delivery available near me in Central Islip?

Yes, Italian delivery is available near you in Central Islip through DoorDash. Enter your address in the DoorDash app or website to find the best Italian options available for delivery near you.

Where can I find the best Italian delivery near me in Central Islip?

To find the best Italian delivery near you in Central Islip, look for restaurants with high ratings and user reviews on DoorDash. You can filter by ratings to see the top-rated Italian spots near you.

Where can I find cheap Italian near me in Central Islip?

For affordable Italian delivery near me in Central Islip, DoorDash allows you to filter restaurants by price. Look for spots marked with a single dollar for budget-friendly options.

What is open now for Italian delivery near me in Central Islip?

To see which Italian restaurants are open for delivery in Central Islip right now, enter your address on the DoorDash website or app. You will be shown a list of Italian places that are currently available for delivery, including their hours of operation.

Can I schedule a Italian delivery in Central Islip?

Yes, DoorDash allows you to schedule a Italian delivery in Central Islip at a time that works best for you. During checkout, simply choose the schedule option to set a future delivery time for your order.

How can I get free Italian delivery in Central Islip?

To enjoy 0 delivery fees on Italian orders in Central Islip, consider joining DashPass, DoorDash’s subscription service. DashPass members get free delivery on eligible orders from participating restaurants.

How do I pay for my Italian delivery on DoorDash in Central Islip?

Payment for your Italian delivery in Central Islip is easy and secure with DoorDash. You can pay through the app using credit/debit cards, DoorDash credits, or other available payment methods. No need to handle cash!

What are the most popular Italian dishes I can order near me in Central Islip?

Enter your address on DoorDash to discover the most-ordered Italian dishes from restaurants near you.

Checking if the site connection is secured...