Best Italian Restaurants Nearby in Bay Shore
Mama Mia's Pizzeria
4.6
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 1.1 mi • 27 min
"12" Margherita 6 Garlic Knots That was amazing and awesome, especially after a long travel day, as was the 2 Liter Soda A++++++++++ Thank you very much"
"This may have been the BEST Chicken Parmigiana Dinner I have had. The chicken was the perfect amount of juicy and crispy, the mozzarella tasted so fresh and the pasta was cooked perfectly. The sauce wasn't too acidic which was my favorite part. The portion sizes were also MASSIVE! With great pricing, great food and amazing flavor I'd 10000% order again"
18" Regular Pie
18' round crust pizza with grande mozzarella & tomato sauce.
$21.18
Chicken Parmigiana Dinner
Breaded chicken cutlet with homemade Italian plum tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese with your choice of pasta or salad
$24.5
Family Meal Deal
1/2 tray of salad: choice of house or Caesar salad.
1/2 tray of pasta: choice of penne with tomato sauce, garlic and oil or ala vodka sauce. Spaghetti & Meatballs, Baked Ziti or Fettuccine Alfredo
1/2 tray of protein: eggplant parmigiana, sausage and peppers, meatball parmigiana, chicken parmigiana, chicken Marsala
$59.58
6 Garlic Knots
Rich and creamy vodka infused tomato sauce. Tossed with our blend of pecorino cheese.
$4.79
Butera's Restaurant
4.7
(700+)$0 delivery fee • 0.3 mi • 21 min
"Top tier place everything is amazing, called to order just the bread and dip they bring to the table and got it for free. Best ever Cesar salad just nothing but great things about this place!!!! Must go too."
"my first time ordering here and I am so upset that I waited all this time... I deprived myself of a reasonably amazing madeGrilled Chicken, Spinach, Roasted Pepper, and Mozzarella Sandwich and on this side was a mixed Creed arugula salad with appropriately sized sliced tomato wedges cucumbers and radish with a wonderful red wine and oil vinaigrette dressing. this was definitely a satisfying amazing unexpected lunch choice. I will be ordering again. the only downside is I did not want to share but it was so amazing I had to spread the word, taste, and satisfaction of an experience!!!!! A Hidden Gem!!!!"
Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken breast, marinara, mozzarella, and linguine.
$28.55
Rigatoni Butera
Fresh rigatoni, crumbled chicken sausage, green peas, pink sauce, and shaved grana Padano.
$27.2
Romano Crusted Chicken "Piccata" Style
Mushroom, lemon caper wine sauce, arugula, frisee, and roasted tomato Insalata, and crispy roasted potato.
$29.18
Rigatoni Short Rib Ragu
Fresh rigatoni, herb ricotta, crispy onion, slow-cooked tomato, short rib, and sofrito vegetable ragu.
$27.92
The Pizzeria
4.7
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 1.8 mi • 33 min
"That was the best Chicken Roll i ever had. Chicken was crispy and crunchy but not dried out. The roll itself was tender and cheesy and seasoned. And i LOVE their Side of Marinara Sauce. Their sauce is a little sweet and a little tart. Love that. Hard to find a good, fresh chicken roll. "
"I always get the salad slice with grilled chicken and broccoli added on. the dressing is sooooo good and the dough is still crispy underneath. the rice balls are very flavorful and the marinara is good tooSalad Slice Rice Ball"
Large Pie
Traditional new york style slice
$25.26
Regular Slice
No Order is Complete Without Them
$4.11
Garlic Knots
Traditional ny style sicilian slice
$4.79
Sicilian Slice
Marinated chicken, mozzarella cheese and drizzle of our homemade buffalo sauce
$4.3
Vinnies Mulberry Street
4.8
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 2.2 mi • 23 min
"Food was good but my order was incomplete. Ordered the Lipton Pure Leaf drink and did not receive it. It cost $3.50."
"The sauce is very watered down, and is bitter, the inside was cold as if it was frozen. I am disappointed since I had heard good things about this place. It did not reach my expectations, unfortunately."
Large Pie 18" (8 Slices)
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
$28.53
Pepsi
Mixed greens, cucumbers, plum tomatoes, carrots, black olives and red onions.
$4.12
Chicken Roll
Breaded chicken cutlet, baked in tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella.
$12.97
House Salad
Homemade vodka sauce with prosciutto and onion.
$16.91
Amore Pizzeria & Fine Food
4.7
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 0.8 mi • 29 min
"This place never disappoints. Makes the best potato and egg heros. Great customer service. Staff has been extremely friendly."
"Really enjoyed the pizza. Freshly made good price for the size. One of the best in town hands down. Would definitely order the pizza again! Not as impressed with the black out cake, it was very dry and the cannoli tasted like it was fried in old oil. I have to say though I frequent an Italian bakery that knocks every other pastry shop I've ever been to right out of the ball park, but if you have a need to satisfy à sweet tooth it will do."
Cheese Pizza - X-Large 18"
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$25.6
Cheese Pizza - Large 16"
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$24.46
Garlic Knots - 6 Pieces
A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.
$4.09
Garlic Knots - 6 Pieces
A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.
$4.09
Gio's Pizza & Restaurant
4.8
(500+)$0 delivery fee • 3.6 mi • 31 min
$7 off on $45+
"Best of the best not only in food quality and yumminess but also with customer service! Poppers, Caesar salad, and grandma vodka at least once a month "
"The Regular Large (18") pizza was fresh and cheesy. Their sauce has a hint of sweetness to it that won't hurt you later on. Their Chicken Fingers (5) are delicious so crispy, and even my dad who has celiac and can't eat breading will cheat for them. Their French Fries are always crispy and delicious. Their House Salad is legitimately always fresh. The lettuce is crisp and their dressing is out of this world. A top tier lunch/dinner place always."
Regular Large (18")
Tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$24.55
Regular Small (14")
Meat: ham, salami, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese or broccoli: broccoli, mozzarella cheese & ricotta.
$22.2
Pinwheels
With cheese (American or mozzarella) for an additional charge.
$3.62
2 Liter
Romaine lettuce, croutons & grated cheese.
$4.3
The Cheesecake Factory
4.4
(31k+)$0 delivery fee • 1.8 mi • 34 min
"I always get the Factory Chopped Salad and it's always great. Today I tried the Barbeque Ranch Chicken Salad With some modificatios and it was perfect! HUGE! Some think it's a lot for a salad but I have 2 days of leftovers. Check the pic!"
"Some of the worst food I have had delivered in a long time. The Korean chicken was non edible not sure what they did to it. The meatball sliders were the size of a quarter and dry and the smash burger was indeed smashed, driven over, thrown against a wall and then thrown into a fryer. Just wow. Off my list now"
Linda's Fudge Cake
Layers of Rich Chocolate Cake and Fudge Frosting
$13.86
Fried Macaroni and Cheese
Crispy Crumb Coated Macaroni and Cheese Balls. Served over a Creamy Marinara Sauce
$19.95
Lunch Cajun Salmon*
A Louisiana Classic, Blackened with Creole Sauce, Mashed Potatoes and Buttered Corn
$24.95
Fresh Strawberry Cheesecake
The Original Topped with Glazed Fresh Strawberries. Our Most Popular Flavor for over 45 Years!
$14.76
Our Little Italy
4.6
(7k+)$0 delivery fee • 3.1 mi • 26 min
$6 off on $47+
"I have been to SO many different Italian restaurant's but this one really takes the cake. The Pasta Alla Vodka was cooked perfectly and I asked for a lot of mozzarella and THEY DELIVERED!! 110% only spending my money here! Thank you!!"
"Pepperoni on the Hot Honey Pepperoni Slice (7/10) made the slice so much better. Garlic Knots (Dozen) (7/10) were delicious and the Trio Slice was amazing (8.7/10) the mix of the sauces work well together. The Trio Slice is also a thicker than the Hot Honey Pepperoni Slice ."
Neapolitan Pie
18" round crust pizza with mozzarella & pizza sauce.
$26.29
Neopolitan Slice
Regular crust with mozzarella & pizza sauce.
$4.26
20 Oz Soda
Baked dough knots marinated with fresh garlic, olive oil,
grated cheese and seasonings.
$3.41
Garlic Knots (12 per order)
Regular crust with chicken, bacon, mozzarella, and cheddar
cheese topped with ranch dressing.
$7.33
Americano Pie Bar
4.6
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 1.8 mi • 28 min
"First time eating anything from here and it was delivery and the food was 10/10 even with it being delivered.
Short Rib Mac & Cheese was so delicious and wasnt your typical Mac and cheese but flavors were deep and oh so delicious.
Philly Rolls also, so simple you think but whatever they did made it so delicious and was still crispy and crunchy exterior after being delivered
And the Chicken Taco was also so delicious and flavors were all put together perfectly.
Cant wait to actually eat the food in the restaurant in person instead of having it delivered"
"I ordered porcini filet mignon and Cesar salad and when I tell you this is ABSOLUTELY the best food I've ever had! I mean it! I keep telling my family about how delicious it was. The steak with was so juicy inside of the pasta.. it melts in your mouth! The Ceasar salad was so fresh and delicious as well! Wow! 10/10"
Regular Cheese Pizza
8 slices. Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$19.89
Penne Alla Vodka
Pancetta - Onion - Tomato - Cream - Pecorino
$22.59
Troffolini
Stuffed pasta with ricotta and pear and truffle cream sauce.
$14.12
Firenze Penne
Spinach, fresh mozzarella, and pink sauce.
$24.89
Gino's Pizzeria
4.5
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 7.3 mi • 40 min
"When our order arrived the door dash driver had only one bag. We were missing the majority of our order. I called him through the app and he blamed the restaurant and offered no help. I then called Gino's figuring id have to go pick it up myself. I could tell they were very busy, phones were ringing off the hook and it was quite noisy but they immediately said they'd have the food to me ASAP.. within 15 minutes it was at my door. Excellent customer service - and the food was delicious!!! Great sales/specials as well. will definitely order again"
"The margarita pizza is one of the best I have ever tried it was so flavorful and the crust was so crispy only issue I had is the tomato chunks are bit to chunky if not watery now idc if that's how you make margarita it cannot be inconsistent with its portions the tomato chunks are sometimes too much and soggy leaking water but even after that this is a 8/10 it was delicious and the crust truly the best I have ever had."
18" Regular Pie
18' round crust pizza with grande mozzarella & tomato sauce.
$29.63
Regular Slice
12" Round with Grande Whole-Milk Mozzarella
$4.55
12" Regular Pie
Breaded chicken cutlet with homemade Italian plum tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese with your choice of pasta or salad
$15.17
Chicken Parmigiana Dinner
Chicken Cutlets in tomato sauce with melted mozzarella on Italian bread
$26.65
Mamma Santina Pizza
4.6
(300+)$0 delivery fee • 1.5 mi • 45 min
"The Grilled Salmon is so delicious with cannelini beans and spinach. "
"I have been going here since 1989 when it was Frank's. The Sicilian is right off the boat. The new renovation is spectacular, and it is unbelievably busy. Yet somehow, the service is always the best. Family owned and operated. Top notch."
Margherita Pie - 12"
Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and basil.
$29.35
Meatball Parmigiana Hero - Heroes
Grilled or fried chicken tossed with diced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, croutons, fire-roasted peppers, red onion, mixed greens, basil with lemon and olive oil, mixed in.
$22.2
Chicken Bruschetta Salad - Salads
Whole littleneck clams broiled with seasoned breadcrumbs.
$29.39
Baked Clams Oreganata - Appetizers
Romaine, toasted bacon bits, tomatoes, corn, red onion, dried cranberries, provolone strips, croutons, and ranch on the side.
$22.03
La Famiglia Italian Restaurant
4.7
(600+)$0 delivery fee • 12.5 mi • 59 min
Farther away
"The food is excellent and their family style portions help keep the costs down. I would highly recommend the Italian Salad, it's a meal in itself and very delicious."
"I had some friends over and ordered La famiglia bc it's always easy serving family style food. It was delicious ! It's also a great price for what you get! We got 4 large orders, Chicken Parmigiana, Homemade Meatballs with Ricotta, Alla Vodka with Prosciutto, and chicken Marsala. Pasta is sometimes a bit dry so I always ask for extra sauce. I did ask and didn't get it but I'll give them the benefit of the doubt bc the food is so good!"
Chicken Parmigiana
Serve 2-3 people
$28.18
Alla Vodka with Prosciutto
Linguine, spaghetti, fettucine, cappelini, and penne or rigatoni.
$27.17
Homemade Meatballs with Ricotta
Serve 2-3 people
$25.03
Buseto Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.5
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 1.8 mi • 45 min
"Good well done, loved the pizza. "
Regular Slice - Pizza by the Slice
Plain cheese & tomato sauce pie.
$5.41
Chicken Parmigiana Hero - Large
Diced breaded chicken mixed with bacon, cheddar, diced tomatoes and drizzled with ranch dressing.
$23
Meatball Parmigiana Hero - Large
Diced breaded chicken tossed with tomato sauce, Romano & mozzarella cheese.
$21.69
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice - Pizza by the Slice
Filled to order with traditional ricotta cream.
$7.9
Applebee's Grill & Bar
4.3
(6k+)$0 delivery fee • 3.2 mi • 27 min
"good! food came nice and warm and the cheeseburger felt juicy, the pasta i got to get more cheese and was just perfect "
"My soup was missing , french fries tasted old and the grilled cheese cheeseburger wasn't toasted enough, just being honest.The food is usually good when I order. I don't know what happened this time around."
Ultimate Trio
Get ready to build your Ultimate Trio! Choose 3 appetizers from a mouthwatering selection of 10 and pair them with 3 irresistible dipping sauces. With endless combinations, every bite is a new adventure!
$21.66
Boneless Wings
Crispy breaded pieces of tender boneless chicken tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with Bleu cheese or house-made ranch buttermilk ranch dressings and celery.
$20.41
Fountain Drinks
Satisfy your taste buds with our line-up of cold fountain drinks.
$3.99
Triple Chocolate Meltdown®
All the classic apps you love - Boneless Wings, Spinach & Artichoke Dip, Chicken Quesadilla and Mozzarella Sticks.
$12.41
Mulberry Street of Babylon
4.7
(900+)$0 delivery fee • 5.0 mi • 32 min
"Food is great. Grilled Small House Salad With Chicken was flavorful and big portion for the price. Pizza was just excellent. Very happy they had Beef Pepproni for non pork eaters. Thats a game changer for me."
"why is my penne and broccoli literally floating in oil? also, 2 tiny sad scoops of gelato for$8, seriously?"
Large Round Cheese
hearts of romaine, caesar dressing, parmigiano, croutons
$25.28
Regular Slice
four tender chicken breasts, lightly egg battered and floured, served in a zesty lemon sauce
$5.11
6 Garlic Knots
four crispy chicken cutlets topped with fresh tomato sauce, grande mozzarella, and grated cheese
$5.07
20 oz Soda
2 meatball
$3.31
LEGGIOS DELI
4.7
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 1.2 mi • 24 min
Trending
"Sandwiches were great. Very large, very filling, and perfectly prepared."
"As a customer of leggio's back in the 80's. The old family would be turning in their grave with the sandwiches they are selling under the ledgendary name. I had the Italian or should I say wish hero, because I wish I never wasted $25.00 on it. It lacked cold cuts, taste and the ingredients listed in the legendary Italian they advertised."
Build Your Own Hero
Ham cappy, salami, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato,
onion, sweet or spicy peppers, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper *Please Specify Type Of Pepper You Would Like On Sandwich
$18.78
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Ovengold turkey with bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. served on leggios Italian
$10.64
Build Your Own half hero
Ham cappy, salami, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato,
onion, sweet or spicy peppers, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper
$11.46
1- Legendary Italian Hero
Chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, pesto,
vodka sauce, on garlic bread
$20.68
The Penny Pub
4.3
(3k+)$0 delivery fee • 0.5 mi • 22 min
$6 off on $40+
"Food was so good! Was a little skeptical hence it was being delivered to Hauppauge which is some distance from Bay Shore. But it was still fairly hot, so we were happy.
The meat on the Dublin dip was tender, the dipping gravy was out of this world. The bread was tasty and soft. Wings had the perfect amount of kick. Honestly so happy we ordered from here!!! "
"There is about 10 French fries with my grilled cheese that cost over 16$ for some bread, cheese, 2 pieces of bacon, and 10 French fries. I am not happy and I order quite often but if I don't get some money refunded I don't think I will order again. "
Small Wings (8)
with salsa and sour cream
$18.52
Quesadilla
add: chicken +3 steak +4 bacon +2
$19.94
The Penny Burger
half pound certified angus beef burger on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, and red onion, served with a pickle
$22.1
Dublin Dip
add american, monterey jack, mozzarella, swiss, sauteed onions, fried egg +1
$23.29
Savianos Pizza & Restaurant
4.7
(700+)$0 delivery fee • 8.3 mi • 33 min
Trending
"The Grandma Pie is on another level!!! Deliciously made with quality ingredients!!! Get ready to overeat!"
"First time ordering from Savianos. The side of Homemade Meatballs came with four meatballs which was great to split with the Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Dinner with Pasta for the kids who are picky. The Tortellini Alfieri was for me and it was the perfect amount of food, very good as a healthy choice meal if you're into that. Enjoyed our meal and will be back again."
Neopolitan Pie (Regular)
Served by the half dozen
$28.11
Garlic Knots
Hearty ground beef sauteed in a creamy pink vodka sauce tossed with penne
$5.89
Penne Alla Vodka
Baked Italian bread basted with fresh garlic, evo and imported spices
$26.6
Neopolitan (Sliced Pizza)
Fried chicken cutlets topped with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese
$4.87
Mary's Pizza and Pasta
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.4 mi • 59 min
"Wasn't expecting much as I'm staying close by at a hotel and needed something late to eat. Pleasantly - very - surprised. Order this place! Cheese burger was large and tasty. Well seasoned, cooked properly to med rare and the bun handled the large burger nicely and there was plenty of tomato. No ketchup or napkins so make sure you ask for them. Also ordered the personal macro I and cheese pie. Looked totally soggy BUT it wasn't and the crust was crispy with sesame seeds - kind of toasted bagel taste. So good. Cheesey and rich! One slice and done."
"We ordered the ravioli with shrimp on top absolutely delicious and we ordered linguine with white clam sauce one of the best linguine with clam sauce that we've ever had couldn't stop eating it!!! And we ordered meatballs on the side for ravioli. Absolutely delicious! Their food is consistently delicious and fresh!!!!!"
Regular Cheese Pizza
Large.
$25.39
Penne Alla Vodka
Pink cream and vodka sauce with touch of prosciutto.
$24.6
Chicken Parm Hero
Chicken cutlets, tomato sauce, and mozzarella on toasted Italian bread.
$16.95
Mozzarella Sticks
(6) Italian breaded mozzarella sticks, served with side of tomato sauce.
$10.93
La Bottega
4.7
(200+)$0 delivery fee • 5.3 mi • 37 min
"Oooommmmgggg the food... MOUTH WATERING DELICIOUSNESS!!! I ordered it for the past three days in a row! The portions are big so your getting money worth and you can just tell its fresh, and made with time and love... I am a forever customer"
"Cavatelli alla Norma con Ricotta is excellent! Comes with four pieces of fresh bread also. Love the eco friendly container.
Thank you for a great meal !"
Avocado Salad
Grilled chicken, iceberg lettuce, shredded mozzarella, avocado, toasted almonds, and cherry tomatoes with balsamic dressing.
$21.8
Pietro
Chicken cutlet, mixed greens, roasted pepper, mozzarella, and herb mayo on ciabatta.
$19.32
Cotoletta
Chicken cutlet, mozzarella, tomato, red onion, and herb mayo on ciabatta.
$19.48
Piccante
Chicken cutlet, mozzarella, mixed greens, and spicy aioli on ciabatta.
$19.39
Francescos Pizza& Pasta
4.7
(300+)$0 delivery fee • 4.4 mi • 36 min
"Absolutely love this location, ordered pizza on valentines day and they made the pizza shape into a heart not to mention that pizza was SO flavorful, true mom and pop pizzeria 🫶🏽"
"Was disappointed in the bread but LOVED the Chicken Parmigiana so delicious, very big portion for the price. I am very happy with my order. Even though the bread felt stale, I had plenty of Angel Hair pasta and Chicken Parmigiana to fill me up and have plenty of left for tomorrow night!!! Great experience"
Cheese Pizza (X-Large 18'' (8 Slices))
Classic cheese or create your own pizza, fresh tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$18.02
Garlic Knots
With sauce. 12 Pieces.
$3.88
Speciality Pizza Slice
Classic cheese or create your own pizza, fresh tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$6
Chicken Wings
Classic cheese or create your own pizza, fresh tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$11.9
Bella cucina
4.7
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 4.5 mi • 32 min
"This is my first time buying from here and I WILL be ordering again. The food us extremely good but I had to give it 4stars because of some hiccups but not based on taste!. The Baked Stuffed Shells tasted amazing honestly like really REALLY GOOD, I personally got mine with shirmp but what I wasn't expecting was for the shells to still be on the shrimp.. the food is covered in sauce I wasn't expecting the shells in a stuff shell dish, that doesn't really make sense ti me and it was an inconvenience but very tasty.
And for the Neapolitan Pizza Slice I was expecting it to come with everything as advertised and i selected to have EXTRA olives and sausage , but whn the pizza arrived it was ONLY olives and sausage. Not what I was expecting and I payed extra for that.
Food is delicious though"
"The Margherita Pizzetta was good. The garlic knots had hardly any garlic on them. I paid extra for more garlic on the knots. They actually had less garlic than any other garlic knot I've ever had."
Neapolitan Cheese Pizza
Mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce.
$21.69
Sicilian Pizza Slice
Mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce.
$3.5
Penne Alla Vodka
A combination of sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, peppers, fresh mushrooms, onions, black olives and extra cheese.
$19.93
Neapolitan Pizza Slice
Tender chicken pieces sautéed in a blend of BBQ and hot sauces, baked onto a round pizza crust with bleu cheese dressing and mozzarella cheese.
$3.25
The Pie at Salvatore's
4.8
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 0.3 mi • 18 min
"It was amazing, first time I tried and I gotta tell you it was outstanding, the flavor on point, the portion size and also the way they baked it was very very soft and yummy ( definitely a must try if you live in bayshore or around the area trust me you'll get your money's worth and be satisfied)"
"Consistently good quality and tasty food. Especially the white pizza - perfect portion. Fresh, large ravioli with delicious sauce."
Original Neapolitan Pizza (Large)
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & Basil.
$29.03
Original Neapolitan Pizza (Small)
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & Basil.
$14.1
Original Neapolitan Pizza (Medium)
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & Basil.
$27.13
Caesar Salad (Small)
Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese, homemade Caeser Dressing
$11.53
Angela’s Pizza
4.7
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 2.6 mi • 30 min
"I had doubts about the Chipotle Chicken but it turnes out to be AMAZING. Very flavorful and saucy. The Pepperoni Slice was nice and crispy. The Regular Slice is probably one of the best cheese slice's ive had in a while. Truly an amazing experience, i'd 100% order again. Also might i add everything came HUGE so definitely worth the price."
"My son has gone here w/his friends for slices and recommended it to us. We ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pie and a Medium Pie w/pepperoni. Some of the best pizza we've had! Fresh ingredients and cooked perfectly. No flop!!!! Great undercarriage and crunch!"
Large Pie
Large Cheese Pie
$21.94
Regular Slice
Charred Pepperoni over Vodka Sauce with Hot Honey Drizzle
$4.09
Hot Honey Slice
Medium pie : size 14’
$4.96
Sicilian Slice
2 Liter of Choice. Put in Comments. Coke, Diet Coke, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sprite, Root Beer, Grape Soda, Orange.
Will get as close to choice as possible if out.
$4.01
Victorio's Pizza
4.6
(700+)$0 delivery fee • 2.4 mi • 29 min
"I love it and always order this dish from them. So delicious. "
"Excellent Customer Service but the potato and egg hero was very very bland. No seasoning at all or butter it seemed. I would give them a second chance with a different item but not this one again."
Round Pizza with Cheese
Fresh garlic, grated cheese, and parsley.
$19.87
Garlic Knot Pizza (Large)
Breaded chicken lightly fried topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$20.01
Regular Pizza
6 pieces
$8.46
Chicken Parmigiana
Mozzarella and ricotta cheese.
$10.72
Mama's Pizza Pasta & Seafood
4.8
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 8.1 mi • 43 min
"Our first time ordering from here. The crust was airy, tasty and perfectly cooked. The sauce was fresh and well made, flavorful without being overpowering. And, perfect proportion of sauce to cheese.
"
"$18.95 for the Ravioli dinner expecting an adult sized meal...received 6 cheese ravioli... . This is insane. Also. Ordered the linquini with Meatballs. ... 2 meatballs and not 3? Other Italian places that charge this much come with a side salad at least. Pricing is too much for too little. "
Neopolitan Cheese Pie - Large (8 slices)
served with a side of tomato sauce
$24.29
Jumbo Garlic Knots (6)
With fresh tomato sauce & mozzarella served with a side of linguini
$4.12
Rigatoni alla Vodka
Tomato sauce, basil & light marinara
$20.39
Garlic Knot Crust Pizza
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$29
Tonys Pizza Restaurant
4.8
(300+)$0 delivery fee • 6.8 mi • 44 min
"The best Pizzaria in the area hands down. They cook the 18" Pizza (8 Slices) perfectly for this style of pizza. The Chicken Roll is by far the best that I have had in years, hands down."
"As a 30+ year customer of Tony's the quality of their food has not changed. The 18"pizza was hot, fresh and taste amazing. The greek salad was fresh and tasty . The portion size of salad was enough to feed 3 people. The pizza slices were equally impressive. Well worth the money and would definitely recommend."
18" Pizza (8 Slices)
Peas, sun-dried tomatoes in a creamy meat sauce.
$28.97
Bella Vie
4.4
(60+)$0 delivery fee • 0.9 mi • 30 min
"The short ribs here are always amazing and the chicken Francese is the best I have ever had. Chicken is always tender and cooked to perfection and the flavor is out of this world. "
"Terrible experience. House salad description was misleading and overly priced. I wo n order fr this restaurant ever again."
Mamma Antonietta Lasagna
Homemade pasta sheets, mozzarella, béchamel sauce, bolognese ragu.
$33.15
Caesar Salad
Homemade potato gnocchi, caramelized onions, shaved black truffle, creamy fontina sauce.
$20.7
Gnocchi Alla Bava
Prime boneless beef short ribs, sweet potato puree, crispy onions, brussels sprouts, and demi glaze.
$32.86
Pork Chop Bella Vie
Roasted beets, red grapes, watermelon radish, apples, goat cheese, and honey mustard dressing.
$46.59
Francescos Pizza & Restaurant
4.6
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 4.5 mi • 25 min
"someone told me about this olace a long time ago and I 4got about it. My husband and I ordered from them about 3 weeks ago and ordered at least 3xs a week since! lol
Food is excellent, menu is HUGE.The one complaint i have is that we ordered a dish and a couple of slices and for the 3rd time, the slices came without the toppings"
"the sauce was grey, no salt, clearly came from a can not fresh, portion however was good and pasta was cooked well. would not order again, honestly would try to get my money back but don't think that's possible"
Reg Pie
16" Regular Cheese Pie, Non Bleached, Non Brominated King Auther Flour, Grande Mozzarella and the finest California Tomatoes.
$21.82
Side of Pasta
Delivered Slices may not arrive hot to your liking as a full pizza due to driving distances
$10.95
Half Dz Knots
Breaded chicken cutlet with tomato sauce and melted mozz
$3.67
Slice
Pink Vodka sauce with butter, tomato and cream
$3.99
Mario's Pizzeria (Commack)
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 9.3 mi • 37 min
"oh my goodness this is immaculate. im so srs , this is the most amazing pasta I've ever had, its so worth the money !! its a big portion too so i had save it for later as well. it's very creamy and filling)) ! its also very fresh. I got the penne alla vodka thing and i would order again and recommend it ! 20/10 !! photo doesn't do it justice ! also they give u bread with the pasta which is even better"
"Mario's buffalo chicken wrap is SECOND TO NONE!!! It is always freshly made as opposed to the pizzerias that serve rolls that have been sitting out on the counter and are all dried out. Mario's puts just the perfect amount of buffalo sauce, chix and cheese. And their dough is the best! It's so nice to have somewhere I can order from and always count on to be awesome!!!"
Large Cheese Pizza
16" Pie Baked With Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!
$27.98
Garlic Knots
Tossed with Garlic, Oil, Parmesan Cheese & Fresh Parsley. Melted Mozzarella Available
$5.36
Plain Slice
Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese - Click to add Toppings!
$4.95
Medium Cheese Pizza
12" Pie Baked With Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!
$19.84
Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.7
(8k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.9 mi • 44 min
"Their food never disappoints! Pizza made to your request and absolutely amazing garlic knots! Dinners are huge portions and always delicious! They've kept it consistent for over 20 years for a reason! Thee BEST!"
"You can't go wrong with the Regular Pie for dinner or an anytime w. An always favorite in my house. And it's perfect every time.
The Mussels appetizer is always fresh and there is plenty. And as always, we order garlic knots just to have as a snack. Yum!"
Regular Pie
With tomato and mozzarella.
$25.22
Garlic Knots
Garlic knots, breadsticks twisted with garlic. Options: 12 or 6 pieces.
$5.54
Regular Slice
Thin crust topped with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$4.55
Cheese Mini Pie (12")
A 12-inch pizza topped with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a crisp, golden crust.
$13.66
Vinnies Mulberry Street
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 2.9 mi • 35 min
"The food here is always outstanding. I always order a Pint of sauce to use at home.Delicious. Of course their Pizza Pies are great. I tried the Sausage Parmigiana for the first time today, and I was NOT disappointed. It was just what I would expect from Vinnie's Mulberry Street. EXCELLENT!
Letty Sustrin"
"the ravioli was extremely hard and nasty tasting. the shrimp was very rubbery. i only took a few bites and didnt even eat the rest. i spent $40 on this and the quality was awful. doordash refunded my money though and handled the situation very well."
Regular
Neapolitan crust, oregano, mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce.
$27.11
Half A Dozen Garlic Knots
Caesar salad with grilled chicken, crispy romaine, croutons, traditional dressing.
$6.43
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero
Thin crust Sicilian, fresh garlic with mozzarella and Italian plum tomatoes, spicy sauce.
$15.68
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Boneless breast of chicken, sautéed in white wine, butter, and lemon.
$21.75
Patrizia's of Hauppauge
4.6
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 8.8 mi • 47 min
$7 off on $60+
"The rice Sicilian rice Balls (3) were absolutely amazing, penne vodka as always was top notch and the chicken Parmigiana had the perfect melted cheeses"
"Escarole and White bean soup was not good, flavor is off and that was NOT ESCAROLE which threw off that taste completely.
Flounder oreganata, pasta with same sauce, Pasta was Dry, the portion is half the size from when we first started ordering from you a few years ago. Step it up, you are a wonderful restaurant don't let yourselves go like this Please. "
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded, topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese
$26.27
Chicken Francese
White wine lemon sauce
$26.21
Penne Alla Vodka
Penne pasta in a creamy tomato vodka sauce.
$29.67
Skirt Steak Fusilli Cacio e Pepe
Sliced, grilled skirt steak served over a bed of al dente fusilli pasta tossed in our classic Roman cacio e pepe sauce. Made with Pecorino Romano cheese and freshly ground black peppercorns. A modern twist on a timeless comfort food.
$34.01
D'Fortinis Pizza
4.6
(20+)$0 delivery fee • 3.9 mi • 35 min
"Orders D'Fortinin's for a staff lunch everyone loved it!! The salad was amazing and they make the best Pizza! We had plain, penne à la vodka and chicken marsala"
Neapolitan
Round 16" (8-slice pie).
$23.48
Garlic Knots
Thin square crust with homemade marinara & mozzarella.
$7
Grandma Pie
Thinly sliced grilled steak served with sautéed onions, chopped green peppers & mushrooms, topped off with melted American & mozzarella cheese.
$23.7
Philly Cheesesteak
Pepperoni & mozzarella cheese or spinach.
$14.42
Gavone's Pizza
4.6
(40+)$0 delivery fee • 3.2 mi • 30 min
"This please is SOOO good. A new staple in our home. Food is delicious, always hot, the pasta bar is amazing."
"Eggplant fries.. amazing!!"
Pasta Bar
Stuffed Birria Beef And Cheese Crust With Cilantro, Onions And Consome On The Side
$19.82
The OG Pie
Romaine, Caesar Dressing, Croutons and Grana Padana
$28.07
Pastina Cakes
Romaine, Grape Tomatoes, Shredded Mozz, Artichoke Hearts, Roasted Red Peppers and Basalmic Vinaigrette
$16.57
Birria All The Way Slice
Marinara, Vodka, Pesto on a Grandma Sytle Crust
$10.18
Cafe Gio
4.6
(300+)$0 delivery fee • 5.9 mi • 33 min
"It came piping hot, meatballs are super flavorful and the sauce is lovely. Made with love!"
"the Zeppole had little to zero powdered sugar and the Garlic Knots had no Garlic Knots, the cheese pie was okay. The food use to be fantastic not it is hit or miss and the price has increased, but the quality should have been consistent"
18" Cheese Pie
6 pieces.
$24.4
Garlic Knots
Crispy chicken cutlets in a pink cream sauce topped with burrata.
$3.75
Stuffed Rigatoni Grimaldi
Rigatoni flambéed with vodka, tomato, bolognese, onions and scallions in a creamy Parmesan sauce.
$28.46
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Stuffed with bolognese meat sauce.
$24.99
Dalisa Pizza
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.0 mi • 39 min
"this Rigatoni Lasagna is probably one of the best on long Island every single person in my family enjoys this and the portions are huge definitely worth every penny"
"Chicken Soup, was hot & fresh and so was the Pizza. Best tasting pizza around imho. Order was prompt, accurate and professional. 5 Star service ***** All around.
"
Regular Cheese & Tomato: Large (8 Slices)
Regular Large Pie with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese
$20.27
Garlic Knots
The classic kids favorite.
$4.44
Sicilian Pie
Breaded chicken in a tomato sauce with mozzarella on unseeded italian bread
$22.62
Chicken Tenders - sold individually
Thin Sicilian with marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese
$6.93
Pasta Glory
3.8
(50+)$0 delivery fee • 7.2 mi • 40 min
20% off on $25+
"We stumbled upon Pasta Glory looking for some comfort Italian food. This hit the spot. My wife got the Spaghetti Bolognese which both of us thought was superb and I have tried the Penne alla Vodka and Tortalini which were equally excellent. It's our go-to Italian place now. Garlic Bread is crunchy and crispy. Servings are enough to be split by two people and we have healthy appetites! "
"Can't believe how cheap they made the pasta carbonara. First off they used the wrong pasta. Cheap cheese and it lacked taste and wasn't cheap. I've had another dish there b4 of something else was ok. But they need to go back to the drawing board"
Fettuccine Alfredo
Fettuccine in rich and creamy Alfredo sauce topped with fresh Parmesan cheese.
$20.8
Penne alla Vodka
Penne pasta coated in a delicious, creamy vodka sauce, and topped with fresh Parmesan cheese.
$20.07
Spaghetti Bolognese
Spaghetti in a traditional Bolognese sauce topped with fresh Parmesan cheese.
$21.62
Pasta Carbonara
Spaghetti in a classic Carbonara sauce of egg yolks and cheese mixed with crispy bacon and topped with fresh Parmesan cheese.
$20.97
Red Lobster
4.4
(2k+)$0 delivery fee • 5.2 mi • 34 min
"Golden-Fried Fish was Excellent, great tasting cooked perfectly. Order was on time accurate and professional. 5 Star service ***** All Around. "
"Crunch-Fried Flounder Sandwich was hot fresh and yummy. Order was on time and professional. 5 Star service ***** All around. "
Create Your Own Ultimate Feast®
Choose 2 Premium and 2 Classic selections. Served with your choice of two sides.
960 Cal - 2100 Cal
$62.14
Shrimp Linguini Alfredo
Shrimp in a house-made creamy garlic Alfredo sauce on a bed of linguini.
930 Cal
$26.75
Cajun Chicken Linguini Alfredo
Spicy chicken in our house-made creamy garlic Alfredo sauce on a bed of linguini.
1060 Cal
$25.77
Garlic Linguini Alfredo
Creamy garlic Alfredo sauce served over a bed of linguini.
540 Cal
$9.74
Bono's Pizza of Bay Shore
4.7
(600+)$0 delivery fee • 2.1 mi • 31 min
"Best pizza I've had in a while! They obviously do not skimp on the ingredients because the flavor is on point! Sauce is good, cheese is good.. and the crust, ugh, the crust is crispy yet soft exactly the way I like it! Best way I can describe the crust is that is has that Pizza Hut crispiness to it without the oily mess, it's perfect! "
"The Regular Slice was the right amount of greasy and tastes delicious! The Beef Patty was a good portion for the price even with additions and would get it again!"
Cheese Pizza
Rice ball filled with sauce, cheese, chop meat and peas
$25.03
La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria
4.6
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 9.3 mi • 36 min
"Pizza was great ! Exactly as ordered....my family enjoys pizza frequently but request it to be very lightly toasted. The pie was wonderful not dry or hard. I had a very happy family !!! Along with this the shrimp parm and artichoke was fabulous as
Always. We are happy to have this great restaurant close to our home. "
"Both the Eggplant Panino and the Eggplant Wrap were stuffed with eggplant and delicious. They also reheated well as I only ate half of each.
The spinach pinwheel was very good, crispy edges, had plenty of spinach and was a decent size. No complaints here"
6 pc. Cheese Filled Garlic Knots
Chopped romaine topped with diced tomatoes, red onions, and cucumbers, topped with shredded mozzarella cheese.
$7.44
6 pc. Regular Garlic Knots
Crisp romaine topped with homemade garlic croutons, aged Parmesan cheese and homemade Dijon caesar dressing.
$6.37
Insalata la Scala
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
$17.55
Caesar Salad
Served with a side of tomato sauce.
$16.43
Blaze Pizza
4.3
(4k+)$0 delivery fee • 1.3 mi • 29 min
"very good I should have added more stuff on ny pizza the cheasey bread is very good also all of it was very fulfilling."
"Ordered red-vine pizza to have fresh Mozzarella plus shredded mozzarella . There was zero shredded mozzarella and so much sauce. The amount of sauce was enough for 3 Pizzas. I order this pizza in-store often but maybe quality goes down when you're not there to say something. "
Build Your Own Pizza (11-inch)
choose any toppings
$14.74
2 Top Pizza (11-inch)
sauce, cheese & 2 toppings
$13.05
Cheese Pizza (Simple Pie) (11-inch)
mozzarella, parmesan, red sauce
$10.17
1 Top Pizza (11-inch)
sauce, cheese & 1 topping
$11.16
Roto All Day
4.8
(100+)$0 delivery fee • 0.3 mi • 22 min
"The quality of the ingredients. The eggs aren't boxed eggs, the cheese is amazing, the bacon was great the only thing is it had a little more fat than I like but it was still good. You don't taste ginger in the sauce which is a good thing. Love the sauce."
"Steak was a little too rare for me but the flavor of everything was still good. The portion and freshness were perfect for me. I enjoyed it very much! I would order this again."
Chicken Salad Sando
Chicken Salad, Crispy & Pickled Onion, Chili Crisp, Baguette
$16.98
Breakfast Sandwich
Ginger Scallion Mayo, Cooper Sharp, on Brioche Bun
$12.01
Latte
Toasted with Butter and Flakey Salt
$6.87
Banana Bread
Aleppo, Lime Cheek, Toasted Sourdough
$5.72
Francesco's Trattoria
4.6
(500+)$0 delivery fee • 3.7 mi • 34 min
"Delicioso 🍕😋👍👏 Fusilli, broccoli 🥦 and chicken 🐔 w/garlic and oil was awesome 👌."
"Portions are generous. Pizza was really thin crust, but good. Chicken Aglio tastes pretty bland. Does not have a garlic flavor,taste more like a heavy cream sauce and nothing else.Chicken was dry. Good size Rigatoni alla Vodka and flavorful."
18" Cheese Pizza
Include breaded chicken cutlet, tomato sauce, and mozzarella.
$20.9
Chicken Parmigiana
Ball of seasoned meat.
$22.42
Pasta with Meatballs
Stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella, baked with tomato sauce and cheese, served with spaghetti or penne.
$18.09
The Tap Room
4.5
(400+)$0 delivery fee • 0.3 mi • 25 min
"We air fry the Side Sweet Potato Fries and they are perfect! "
"My husband orders from here quite a bit; this is the first time we have gotten this much oil with the steak frites. He ended up throwing it out. Hes gonna take a break from here for a while."
Chicken Avocado Wrap
Grilled chicken, fresh avocado, crispy bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing. Served in a tomato basil wrap.
$19.85
Boneless Wings
crispy wings served with choice of wing sauce.
$17.55
The Tap Burger
lettuce, tomato, red onion
$20.9
Tap Tenders
chicken tenderloins hand dredged in our secret breading, fried golden & served with honey mustard.
$18.96
Mannino's Italian Kitchen and Lounge
Italian • Pizza
$0 delivery fee • 11.3 mi • 45 min
Farther away
Rigatoni Mignon
Filet mignon tips, cipollini onions, roasted tomato, and brown sauce.
$44
Homemade Meatballs
Tomato sauce and fresh ricotta.
$27
Traditional Chicken Parmigiana
With spaghetti pomodoro.
$45.38
Margherita Pizza
San marzano tomato, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
$26
Little Caesars
4.4
(1k+)$0 delivery fee • 6.6 mi • 43 min
"Custom Stuffed Crust amazing with the Caesar Dip® 🍕🔥🔥🔥🥳"
"extremely budget friendly, big portions, fresh food, really good taste, especially the pizza"
ExtraMostBestest® Pepperoni
Large round pizza with more Pepperoni and Cheese than our Classic Pizza
$12.05
Custom Stuffed Crust
Large stuffed crust pizza with toppings of your choice
$17.73
2-Liter Beverage
2-liter bottles of beverage.
$4.21
Lunch Combo
Four slices of Detroit-Style Deep Dish Pizza with Pepperoni and one 20 oz. PEPSI-COLA® product. For PEPSI-COLA® nutrition information, please visit https://www.pepsicobeveragefacts.com/home/find#/
$7.7
Bay Shore Italian Delivery FAQs
Is Italian delivery available near me in Bay Shore?
Yes, Italian delivery is available near you in Bay Shore through DoorDash. Enter your address in the DoorDash app or website to find the best Italian options available for delivery near you.
Where can I find the best Italian delivery near me in Bay Shore?
To find the best Italian delivery near you in Bay Shore, look for restaurants with high ratings and user reviews on DoorDash. You can filter by ratings to see the top-rated Italian spots near you.
Where can I find cheap Italian near me in Bay Shore?
For affordable Italian delivery near me in Bay Shore, DoorDash allows you to filter restaurants by price. Look for spots marked with a single dollar for budget-friendly options.
What is open now for Italian delivery near me in Bay Shore?
To see which Italian restaurants are open for delivery in Bay Shore right now, enter your address on the DoorDash website or app. You will be shown a list of Italian places that are currently available for delivery, including their hours of operation.
Can I schedule a Italian delivery in Bay Shore?
Yes, DoorDash allows you to schedule a Italian delivery in Bay Shore at a time that works best for you. During checkout, simply choose the schedule option to set a future delivery time for your order.
How can I get free Italian delivery in Bay Shore?
To enjoy 0 delivery fees on Italian orders in Bay Shore, consider joining DashPass, DoorDash’s subscription service. DashPass members get free delivery on eligible orders from participating restaurants.
How do I pay for my Italian delivery on DoorDash in Bay Shore?
Payment for your Italian delivery in Bay Shore is easy and secure with DoorDash. You can pay through the app using credit/debit cards, DoorDash credits, or other available payment methods. No need to handle cash!
What are the most popular Italian dishes I can order near me in Bay Shore?
Enter your address on DoorDash to discover the most-ordered Italian dishes from restaurants near you.
Top Cuisines in this City
American in Bay Shore near meChicken in Bay Shore near meMexican in Bay Shore near meGrocery in Bay Shore near meBakery in Bay Shore near meJapanese in Bay Shore near meAsian in Bay Shore near meHealthy in Bay Shore near meItalian in Bay Shore near meMediterranean in Bay Shore near meCafe in Bay Shore near mePeruvian in Bay Shore near meGastropub in Bay Shore near meSpanish in Bay Shore near meChinese in Bay Shore near me
See more